5 ms·
Facebook is not a carrier. If any carrier chooses to provide full Internet access for free, they may do so. So far they haven't, though. Which is why company-
by prostoalex 11y ago
Facebook is not a carrier.
If any carrier chooses to provide full Internet access for free, they may do so.
So far they haven't, though. Which is why company-sponsored basic service that's free to the users emerged in the first place.
- Crito 11y agoIf they truly had altruistic intentions, they damn well could be.
- prostoalex 11y agoSure but what's a solution that's a reasonable compromise until that happens?
- throwaway2048 11y agoits not a "reasonable compromise" from the point of view that Facebook is supposedly acting altruistically, this is a 100% self interested power play.
- prostoalex 11y agoIs someone whose wireless Internet budget tops at $0 better off with access to 1 communication tool or 0? (I realize that "unlimited communication tools" is the best answer here, but no one provides it at the budget specified, at least yet).
- throwaway2048 11y agoif the plan goes ahead, that could very easily turn into "never provides", via facebook content lockin and strongarming.
- marcoperaza 11y agoSolutions that work when everyone is following their self-interest are better than solutions that require altruism. The most successful anti-poverty program in the history of the world is capitalism.
- gcb0 11y agothat usually comes to bite you later. with only one tv channel/radio station/available free web site to billions of poor, bad politicians can focus much easier on praying them. this worked very well when their only entertainment was religion cults. everything has a consequence that will indirectly affect your ivory tower.
- marcoperaza 11y agoYour saying I'm in the ivory tower? Bad politicians have already kept a billion Indians out of modernity. Maybe they should give Free Basics a chance before they shut it down to protect their own power, or some ivory tower view that no internet connection is better than a very limited connection that nonetheless connects you with people across the world. If there's an alternative way to expand connectivity, then why doesn't it exist now, or why doesn't someone set it up in competition to Free Basics? No one will use Free Basics if they can get real internet at an affordable price. And your characterization of "one station" is wholly inaccurate. Even if the service included only Facebook (which it doesn't, as anyone can apply to have their web service included in the system), that's millions of profiles and pages with differing opinions, competing products, etc.
- rdlecler1 11y agoThere are a lot of assumptions and learning from 200 years of capitalism baked into that remark. The rampant 'success' of capitalism was also a factor leading to communism. Like any good self regulating system it needs mechanisms in place to control it's own greed. Also, altruism is perfectly at home with modern evolutionary theory because it assumes a more enlightened, rather than simple minded, understanding of altruism.
- 11y ago
- Manishearth 11y agoSee: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10791939 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10791939 One carrier is already trying this. Also, facebook isn't even financing the actual data (the carriers are), and the carriers' business plan (get people hooked onto the Internet so they migrate to a full plan) works on any form of "free limited internet" plan, where the plan is limited by speed or a data cap instead of by limiting what "Internet" means. Facebook is a third party which has wedged itself into this with extra deals; but the situation from the carriers' point of view shouldn't be much different if they set a free data cap or provide a free slow internet plan.
- bipin_nag 11y agoGoogle has announced free Wi-Fi at 100 railway stations in India. I think it does something similar in other countries (and there is Google Fibre). It is just a start but more sensible than what facebook chose to do. Now this is what I think. Facebook is interested in being a monopoly and this step will ensure its rivals don't get in (because facebook pays for it). This is what all the argument is about. Saying billion people will get free internet is just an eyewash. They don't give you full internet, just the part which serves their interest. Carriers should not control/discrimintate internet access. This should apply to other companies as well.
- prostoalex 11y agoCost structures for providing free WiFi and providing wireless telecom service are completely different though - a telecom ought to procure proper licensing, acquire some spectrum and buy/rent tower space before they earn their first dollar. End of the day it's all about barriers for entry - the barrier to provide free WiFi is relatively low, and one can do it at the cost of an uplink connection and a wireless router. If you find a way to lower the barrier for wireless telecom space, the market forces will take over.
- ecobiker 11y agoIt's not true that no other carrier is offering free internet. It's a better model with no restrictions. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/internet/aircel-to-offer-free-basic-internet-across-india-in-a-year/articleshow/49380597.cms http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/internet/aircel-to-...