3 ms·
This is a stupid idea. I don't want a million "smart" devices in my house with crappy unreliable software running on them. Either they'll all be un-updateable w
by modeless 11y ago
This is a stupid idea. I don't want a million "smart" devices in my house with crappy unreliable software running on them. Either they'll all be un-updateable with bugs and vulnerabilities lasting forever, or they'll constantly be pestering me for software updates that change their functionality and behavior, and I don't know which is worse.
In the future I want fewer smart devices than I have now. I want to replace all my smart devices with one robot servant. Why have an internet-connected doorknob or light switch or thermostat, with all the reliability and security concerns that come with that, when my robot servant can unlock the door and turn on the lights and heat when I get home? Why have ambient screens and displays on every surface shouting information at me constantly when my robot servant can just tell me relevant information when I need to know it? Why have a dishwasher when my robot servant can "hand" wash the dishes? Etc.
- frik 11y agoThis. Exactly this. A personal software agent will make a lot of "smart" devices and many apps irrelevant. See Apple's vision from early ’90s: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bjve67p33E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9bjve67p33E
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoThis is a good point - but from a robotics point of view it is really really hard to build a butler able to open a door and turn off a cooker. But if we make the door and the cooker "smart but slaved" then we can have one smart device (one you are probably reading this on) that tells everything else what to do, and those things are dumb and reliable. So there are my phrases du jour - "smart slaves: reliable, dumb and listening" (I can see a joke about good husbands there)
- userbinator 11y agoA robot servant that actually obeys you, if I may add; one that won't decide it's smarter than you and do exactly the opposite of what you want, which is a problem a lot of "smart" devices seem to have.