3 ms·
It's not just Windows. I have an enormous investment in iPhoto -- lots of curated albums with comments. iPhoto won't run in newer versions of MacOS, and Photo
by lisper 11y ago
It's not just Windows. I have an enormous investment in iPhoto -- lots of curated albums with comments. iPhoto won't run in newer versions of MacOS, and Photos won't run in older ones. So I'm looking at an event horizon: once I upgrade past Mavericks there's no going back, and as long as I'm on this side of the horizon there is no way for me to know if Photos is going to successfully import my photo albums or not.
This has happened before. When Apple dropped support for Rosetta after Snow Leopard I lost the ability to run a wide variety of useful applications. I still fire up Snow Leopard in a VM now and then just to run one of those apps. (BTW, running Snow Leopard in a VM is a non-trivial thing to do because Apple's license specifically prohibits it, and Parallels enforces that restriction.)
- wrboyce 11y agoCouldn't you try importing your iPhoto library in a VM or on another machine? I realise the situation you find yourself in is less than ideal, but there are solutions.
- lisper 11y agoYes, of course two machines would "solve" the problem. But that's an awfully expensive solution to what should never have been a problem in the first place.
- abakker 11y agoAs an Aperture/iPhoto/Lightroom user, there _is_ a perfectly viable way to test this out. First, find your iPhoto library, then copy it to an external drive. then, attempt the iPhoto upgrade. iPhoto libraries are self-contained, as are aperture libraries, so you can very easily duplicate folders. I suggest you run a library rebuild through iPhoto before copying it, and if you want to be extra sure, I also suggest moving it with a utility that can tell you if certain files have errors while copying. In the past, I have found Ditto to be pretty good for this. I did this recently, as every few months I take a complete copy of my aperture library and migrate it to an external drive which I keep off-site at a friends house. He, in turn keeps his library at mine. The overall point is that iPhoto > photos is fairly trivial to test it out, and see how it works for you. (PS. this is even easier if you have enough space to just duplicate the drive in-place. If you do that, though, I still recommend library rebuild before duplicating.)
- lisper 11y agoThe data is not the problem, the application is the problem. I'm running iPhoto 8. I tried upgrading to 9 when it came out and it was a disaster. Now iPhoto is gone from the app store so I can't upgrade any more. iPhoto 8 won't run on El Capitan (I had to hack it to even run under Mavericks). So now my only options are Mavericks + iPhoto 8 or El Cap + Photos. Those are mutually exclusive options. [EDIT] I actually considered moving to Lightroom, but the only way you can buy it is as a subscription so that doesn't actually solve my problem. The whole point here is that I want to be able to access my photos 30 years from now, and I don't want to have to pay rent to Apple or Adobe for the privilege.
- rrauenza 11y agoNot true, Lightroom is still available as a 'perpetual license.' Adobe just works hard at hiding it. http://protogtech.com/adobe-lightroom/adobe-lightroom-6-perpetual-license/ http://protogtech.com/adobe-lightroom/adobe-lightroom-6-perp... Edit: FYI, the Lightroom database is SQLite. Also, if you do go with Lightroom, enable the side car feature to also keep the metadata along side the photo: http://help.adobe.com/en_US/lightroom/using/WS638E3AC9-A04C-4445-A0D3-F7D8BA5CDE37.html http://help.adobe.com/en_US/lightroom/using/WS638E3AC9-A04C-...
- aidenn0 11y agoYeah, my wife has a few dozen databases in apple works (she'd been using it since it was Claris works on the old Mac OS). There is no upgrade path from apple, and just got a new macbook this fall; our only option is to export as a TSV, import into bento and recreate all the forms from scratch :(
- speeder 11y agoI work with mobile dev (among other things). When you update your iPhone, you can't "unupdate" it, Apple after a while always deletes the certificate of all versions that aren't the current, and the installer always check the certificate before installing (this also means you cannot install iOS without internet). Xcode, also checks the iOS version, and its own version, some versions of Xcode are tried to specific iOS versions... thus if you keep updating your iOS, you will have to update your Xcode. For some reason, completely unknown to me, Xcode is ALSO tied to OSX version, For example Xcode 6.3 requires a OSX version more than Xcode 6.2, despite having no huge differentes between the two and Xcode 6.3 don't requiring any new OS capabilities that Xcode 6.2 didn't already used anyway. But every time you update OSX and Xcode, not only they sometimes explicitly require a new machine model, but they also get increasingly more inefficient, using more and more RAM and CPU to do the same things. Since right now, I am very low on money, this means I am stuck using Xcode 6.2, and trying to not misclick anything when I plug the testing devices and iTunes nag me to update them... because if I allow them to get updated, I will have to upgrade Xcode, OSX, and the entire machine, and right now sometimes I can't afford even food, affording a entire machine (specially with our currency getting completely broken and being only 25% valuable as it was supposed to when designed, comapred to USD).
- orbitur 11y agoIf you have 8GB RAM, you should be okay to upgrade. I'm running 10.11 on my 2009 MBP, works fine.
- stock_toaster 11y agoSame here (mid 2009 mbp), and mine seems to be running quite a bit better on 10.11 than it did on 10.10 too.
- speeder 11y agoI don't have 8GB of ram ;) And this is why I mentioned ram in first place... The 6.2 Xcode already needs 6GB to run, this already killed one disk drive (because it is constantly swapping when I am using Xcode... the drive could not handle the strain of writing constantly all the time and broke down), I am using now a already damaged drive (someone gave me a drive with theirs that on Windows don't work anymore due to excessive amount of "bad blocks", the drive still work with *nixes for some reason, so I am using it, since I can't afford a new drive anyway).
- abruzzi 11y agoFYI, I just upgraded my MacPro1,1 from Snow Leopard to El Capitan (very non-trivial requiring a custom boot file.) I wanted to run a bunch of music software that never got past PPC, so I needed to keep Snow Leopard around. It turns out the easiest solution is to buy Snow Leopard server from Apple. Parellels and Fusion allow it to be virtualized, and it can still be purchased new from Apple for $20. Because I bought it right around Black Friday, I got it with free two day shipping. You have to call them as its not on the online store, and it helps to know the part number, but it's still for sale.
- frik 11y agoOn the otherside Windows Live Photo Gallery has no vendor lock-in (maintains the file metadata) and is a superb photo management application that was introduced with Vista (similar to iPhoto/Photos/Lightroom). It stays in low maintainance mode since its Vista days (moved to Live apps bundle) and it would have a better home in the open source community. Given that Microsoft recently open sourced the related Live Writer software, there is a small hope: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10706044 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10706044
- galad87 11y agoThat's not true. The App Store version of iPhoto (9.6.1) runs just fine on El Capitan.
- lisper 11y agoThere is no app store version of iPhoto. You may have an old version that you downloaded before Photos was released, and it may run on El Capitan. But I'm actually running iPhoto 8, so I am completely hosed. I can't even upgrade to iPhoto 9 any more (not that I would want to, but still...)
- galad87 11y agoThere is, but is it available anymore for purchased, you can only download it if you already had it.
- Sir_Cmpwn 11y agoSee if you can dump all of the files that iPhoto uses to store all of this data, then write (or ask someone to write) some software that is capable of reading them. Make it open source too, do the world a favor :)
- lisper 11y agoIf I were going to go to all that effort I'd probably just go ahead and write my own photo manager app so I won't have this problem any more. Apple clearly has no respect for their users any more, so I have no confidence that if I do invest the effort to move to Photos that I won't end up in exactly the same situation in another five years.