9 ms·
> It should've been supported directly within the Firefox chrome ASAP. That could have been fixed, and could still be fixed. > It had branding different than
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
> It should've been supported directly within the Firefox chrome ASAP.
That could have been fixed, and could still be fixed.
> It had branding different than the site you logged in to and was in a popup[1].
That could have been fixed, and could still be fixed.
> It took the name of another Firefox feature that users already knew about.
That could have been fixed, and could still be fixed really, but it's pointless now.
> Because the team was experimenting fast, the code quality of the service was such that outside contribution to it (or even cross-team contribution internally) was hard to impossible.
That could have been fixed, and could still be fixed.
> We had enough time to do these things, but we didn't. The team accomplished something really amazing, but it wasn't enough, and most importantly, putting more effort into what already existed was not going to work. This idea that Mozilla can just turn around and throw effort at Persona and make it win now is, IMO, wrong.
Why wouldn't it make it work? Persona was only alive for 2 years. It saw slow adoption, in part due to usability issues. If you fix the usability issues and give it more time, why wouldn't it be more successful? The issues holding it back were not fundamental. In fact, the fundamental design of Persona was sound and worked very well.
Now, yes, merely fixing things and making the project supported again won't make it more successful overnight. It may need rebranding, it may need a lot of promotion, strategic partnerships, etc. But to declare it completely dead and waste effort on recreating what you already have is silly and counterproductive.
Persona already has many sites - and people! - using it. It already has some (limited) brand recognition. It already has a solid protocol and design, a working codebase, a hosted service that is usable.
The hypothetical successor to Persona? It has none of this. A hypothetical new approach? It has none of this. Could that change? Sure, but you're still starting from zero, and you have to re-do everything.
But why start again when what you had wasn't fundamentally broken?
> We need a successor or a new project.
Why? What could a successor or new project bring that Persona couldn't?