4 ms·
Short on time, but I'll say she's looking in the right idea in general. This idea has actually been done before. Removable firmware part used to happen in older
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Short on time, but I'll say she's looking in the right idea in general. This idea has actually been done before. Removable firmware part used to happen in older machines, too.
Far as I know, I came up with it first with a proposal on Schneier's blog, etc to put both the CPU and trusted state on a stick or card you inserted into a machine containing only peripherals maybe with RAM. Research CPU's at the time had RAM encryption/integrity to make it untrusted. I was thinking PC Card rather than stick due to EMSEC, storage, and cost issues. I'll try to find the link later today.
It was actually inspired by foreign, airport security compromising stuff. People asked me to develop a convenient solution. So, real problem was physical access to the trusted components. That access couldn't happen but can't keep all our gear with us or away from inspection. A simple chip or PC Card they carried on would be better. The chassis, from laptop to whatever, they could acquire in country or ship separately with inspection. I further imagined a whole market popping up supplying both secure sticks/cards and the stuff you plug them into. Inspiration for that was iPod & its accessories like docks. One more part was that each user could determine how much protection, from tamper-evidence to EMSEC, to apply to their trusted device.
As it sometimes happens, another company showed up with government backing IIRC and R&D on security devices. Their proposed portfolio was very similar. They undoubtedly started patenting all of it. This created a second risk for anyone attempting what I or now Joanna is attempting: a greedy, defence-connected, third party legally controlling pieces of your core business. They usually just rob people but I predicted on Schneier's blog & later here in a heated debate that they could attempt to change or get rid of the product using their patents. Especially true if a proxy for an intelligence agency. We might have just seen that happen with Apple over iMessage but I can't be sure. Anyway, do know there's both prior art and probably patents on these concepts in defense industry.
So, it was a cool concept. It was one of those I was proudest of given it collapsed problems with all kinds of devices to design and protection of one component. That's basic Orange Book-era thinking I try to remember. Unfortunately, after much debate with marketing types, we determined there was a chicken and the egg problem with these [at the time]. The NRE cost would be high to the point you'd want to be sure there was a demand for thousands of them plus people willing to pay high unit prices. Custom laptops were often closer to $10,000 than $3,000 if low volume. My greater market idea was chicken-and-the-egg times a million. That plus risk of 3rd party patents made me back off the idea as nice but not practical.
Since then, what's changed is dramatically lower cost for homebrew hardware or industrial prototyping. Projects like Novena show it can probably be done for lower NRE than before. However, this is security-critical design that needs strong expertise in both hardware (esp analog/RF) and Intel x86. That will up the NRE and odds of them screwing up. ARM or MIPS ("cheaper ARM") might be easier to do but still need HW expert and significant NRE.
So, there's my take. It's a good idea that two of us in security industry already fleshed-out with removable firmware being proven in ancient mainframes. Serious marketing obstacles to getting this done and done securely. A high-level design for the technology, as I did, is pretty straight-forward and will teach one many lessons. It was a good learning experience if nothing else.
- mjg59 11y agoHaving the CPU on an external card makes things significantly more difficult - your connector now needs to break out the entire bus and also be capable of delivering ~100W, and you need a cooling solution that can handle that without the benefit of the greater surface area of the laptop chassis. Joanna's approach is much more attractive in terms of being something that involves very little modification of existing platforms.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou might be looking at it a bit differently than me, here. What I was looking at is the central components for CPU & storage are on the card. Power, memory, and peripherals are in the chassis. The card's connectors plug directly into that. So, if anything, I'm re-creating the old situation in towers of pluggable CPU's except it's externally pluggable and the tower is now a laptop with integrated electronics. Regardless, it was very important to move the CPU out given it's a high chance of targeting or subversion. It is literally the root of trust for computation. I protect it because I assume attackers will be smarter than me and use it against me somehow. Far as cooling, I admit I didn't think much of it for the high-end: just decided on efficient CPU's where that wasn't so much a problem. Think along the lines of the card computers that need no cooling but have good performance. "Joanna's approach is much more attractive in terms of being something that involves very little modification of existing platforms." Convenience vs security. Always a tradeoff. I promise you that in physical you'll find the more convenient versions will usually get you screwed. Especially if EMSEC or subversion matters to you. I'm holding off reviewing specifics of her work until she finishes it. No promises that I will but I'd rather wait for finished thing given nature of this topic. I'm writing on the general concept which predates it on paper and partly in real products.
- mjg59 11y ago> The card's connectors plug directly into that. In the past a CPU was attached to a relatively low speed bus, and the peripheral interconnects all came off some external chip. These days you've got PCIe coming off the CPU package and memory clocks in the GHz range, so the mechanical aspects of this become massively more inconvenient. Even ignoring that, once you've got storage and CPU on the card, you've basically got a card that's a significant proportion of the size and weight of a laptop. At which point you could just carry the laptop instead. > Think along the lines of the card computers that need no cooling but have good performance. The attempts on that side (such as the Motorola phones that had laptop-style docks available) have been complete failures. > I promise you that in physical you'll find the more convenient versions will usually get you screwed And a solution that's excessively inconvenient will just be ignored.