14 ms·
Open Letter to Mozilla: Bring Back Persona
- dorfsmay 11y agoI created this Persona Advocacy mailing list 11 months ago, but didn't get any traction: persona.advocacy@librelist.com http://librelist.com/browser//persona.advocacy/2015/1/24/the-mozilla-persona-advocacy-mailing-list/ http://librelist.com/browser//persona.advocacy/2015/1/24/the... You can subscribe by sending an email to (first message is ditched): persona.advocacy@librelist.com
- saurik 11y agoFor more (and better) counter arguments, start with this thread (which was about one particular comparison with Facebook Connect: possibly click to see the parent for context) and then follow my chain of earlier comments I link at the bottom of that one (which were more general, going into the flawed assumptions in Persona about email). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7243172 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7243172 (By the way, I am going to try to avoid wasting even more of my life arguing on Hacker News about the benefits or lack thereof of Persona, so I am dropping these links here to maybe seed discussion among others, but I am going to attempt to avoid ruining my Christmas Eve by forcing myself to never look back at this particular thread again ;P.) Also, for anyone wondering if I have anything credible to say on this subject before bothering to read any of this--and maybe to the one person who downvoted me from 3 points to 2 points, which I noticed as I fleshed out the "I will hopefully leave" message ;P--I have run a service with tens of millions of users that only uses federated login (though accounts are optional, so I "only" have just over ten million accounts on file), and have been staring at this space since 2001, when Microsoft announced Passport (at the time, I even was thinking of starting my own single-sign-on service, but was a naive college student ;P). (later edit: I found another old thread on this subject that I am going to add here as an edit, mostly because any other way of adding it might cause me to see if there are any responses to this comment ;P. At the time, to this new link, there were two responses I hadn't bothered seeing and responding to: one from someone who insisted upon comparing the fundamental bug in Persona with an existing "worst practice" (as opposed to any of the better alternative options), and one who seems to be in left field assuming the value of a Facebook account is based on whether the user updated their email address: the point I was making is that Facebook isn't actually tied to email addresses, as they "understand" the problem inherent in relying on them for anything, and so users do not run into any of the issues that Persona not only doesn't solve but actually makes worse. Regardless, yeah: even without reading any comments from today I am already spending way too much time at this ;P.) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8250301 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8250301
- yborg 11y agoFor the abovementioned reason that life is too short, did not read the entire tl;dr thread linked above, but the core objection seems to be that email accounts are fungible. Given the operational experience with Cydia, I will accept at face value that this is a serious real-world problem. What seems wrong to me is throwing up our hands and casting our lot with either of two giant incumbents whose main motivation here is obtaining a constant stream of information on people using their authentication interfaces. I think it would be highly useful to have a successful open standard for this not controlled by a commercial third party with a financial interest in the implementation. To the point on account recovery and its pitfalls, any argument that reduces to "System A is better because (in my opinion) those accounts are changed/deleted less often" seems like handwaving. This argument can make any proposal the winner, I myself have no hard data on account churn for any major service, although I accept that email accounts are probably higher turnover than services that introduce user lock-in ... by things like supporting a single sign-on (i.e. Facebook Connect). But WHAT IF an authentication system relied on email accounts, for example. Perhaps users would then be motivated to maintain such accounts for the purpose if it being their auth key. Finally on the topic of recovery, many services already support the use of a mobile number for this, since these are portable. Implementing this as part of a Persona implementation would seem to address the 'I/someone else threw away my key" problem.
- mgreg 11y agoWhile I agree that dealing with lost/defunct email addresses and thus accounts can be a challenge there may be other solutions to these (e.g. SMS confirmation, backup pass phrases). In any case it seems we're letting the perfect be the enemy of good with this line of argument. Persona provides significant privacy and perhaps security to alternatives.
- cvalentin 11y agoThe problem at that point becomes you start to implement a service, rather than a protocol. I'm not sure there is necessarily a solution for identity with the way email is currently implemented.
- whatthefuck1 11y agoDear Mozilla, stop constantly making horrible decisions that lead to a worse and worse product.
- JohnDeHope 11y agoYou're right. I sent Mozilla $5 this year just for doing what they already do. Kickstart this and they'd get millions, I'd guess.
- SwellJoe 11y agoI hate that the best user experience for logins is "Login with facebook" or "Login with Google". I don't want to impose that privacy failure on my users, but I also don't want to impose the annoyance that is "Sign up with a username, email address, and password". Offering all of the options is also a compromise that complicates the user experience. Now, here's the sad thing, for me: I didn't even know Persona existed until its demise was being discussed on HN and reddit. Persona is exactly what I want for my users and my sites; and for my own use of the web. And, I didn't even know it was an option until it stopped being an option. In short: I strongly agree. Mozilla has to focus resources on areas where it can have the biggest impact on privacy and the open web. This is one of those areas. I hated to see Thunderbird dropped from the Mozilla roster, as it is my mail client of choice, but I understand where they're coming from. I hated to see FirefoxOS end, but I never got to use it, and it seems to have been doomed from the get-go by poor market fit and difficulty competing with the three biggest tech companies in the world in a market where money and influence play a role in which devices get into users hands. But, Persona is exactly the right kind of thing for Mozilla to be doing, and there's no reason they can't do it effectively, and without a huge amount of resources.
- manigandham 11y agoSide note: usernames should just be emails these days, they're unique and save all the effort of needing another made up name.
- scrollaway 11y agoTheoretically yes, but it's not as simple as that. Every identity can have more than one email associated with it, and emails can change over time. So "username == email" is fine as long as the concept of a username mutating is fine.
- manigandham 11y agoI don't see a problem, it just means you can login with multiple emails then. They're still unique to you. LinkedIn and Facebook and other services already do this. A username/real name can still be used as the "name" if this is an online community or something similar.
- scrollaway 11y ago> I don’t know if something like a Kickstarter campaign to raise some money to pay for engineer time would help sway Mozilla at all, but I’m perfectly happy pledging a few hundred dollars and running the campaign, if necessary. I just really want to see Persona succeed. I mentioned this by email, but I'll repeat it here: I believe in the design behind Persona. I believe a well structured, free authentication provider, is one of the core pillars of a free web, which is exactly what Mozilla claims to stand for. I believe in a free web and I'm also willing to put my money where my mouth is. I'm ready to pledge not just my money but my time. I am willing to volunteer my skills as a developer, UX designer and my experience leading FOSS projects to Persona, or a Persona-like project that has a chance of succeeding. If you are involved in this, feel free to email me (see my profile for a point of contact). I invite others willing to do the same to say so here.
- parent5446 11y agoI very much agree. A while ago I spent some time making an extension for MediaWiki for Persona, in hopes of maybe bringing Persona to Wikipedia at some point, but after Mozilla abandoned it we sort of lost hope on that front.
- StavrosK 11y agoDid I ever get back to you on that with the update? For people not in the loop: I would also like to pledge my time in developing a Persona or Persona alternative. I'm just a bit apprehensive on such a project's chances if it weren't backed by a big company like Mozilla. Then again, maybe we should just go for it.
- scrollaway 11y agoYou did not :) Have you talked to Dan Callahan yet?
- icebraining 11y agoSame here, though Node is not my forte yet.
- mgreg 11y ago
- prodmerc 11y agoI find Keepass and/or Lastpass are better solutions - you can have different logins for different sites, generate truly strong random passwords and login with two clicks in any modern browser. I don't want Google (or God forbid, Facebook) knowing what sites I login to and part of my credentials, and I don't want websites to know my email address. I know you say they don't have this information, but it's not hard to get access to it if they feel they want to. Google Web History already creeps me out :-) I also feel more secure with different passwords (and even emails) on different sites.
- r3bl 11y ago> Google Web History already creeps me out :-) You know that you can turn off most of their tracking by doing a privacy checkup? I can't guarantee that they don't know a lot about me and that they're still not tracking me, but I can guarantee you that my Google history is completely blank.
- prodmerc 11y agoI did, though I might need to recheck it, since they used the word "paused" instead of "disabled" :-)
- deno 11y agoDo you actually believe this accomplishes anything… This data is still in their server logs[1] (and streamed directly to NSA). USE TOR BROWSER FOR BROWSING. DON’T STAY LOGGED INTO GOOGLE. Anything less is just a waste of time. And seriously, Tor in 2015 is fast enough for 1080p h.264, there’s really no excuse. [1] https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2011/10/20/law-student-triggers-22-legal-complaints-and-likely-audit-of-facebook/ https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2011/10/20/law-student-trig...
- bobajeff 11y agoThe problem Facebook Connect solves isn't just logging in to multiple accounts but also signing up with them.
- StavrosK 11y ago
- xiaomai 11y agoMozilla shutting down Persona was one of my biggest internet-related disappointments this year. It seemed like the perfect OpenID replacement (that might actually get used by normal people). Bring it back please!
- _pmf_ 11y agoIs there a short introduction as to how Persona deviates from the original decentralized OAuth approach? I'm a bit unclear why what didn't work for decentralized OAuth should work for Persona.
- icebraining 11y agoWhat was the decentralized OAuth approach? Are you referring to OpenID? If so, the difference is that Persona works with whatever email address/account the user already owns, just like plain email/password authentication; they don't have to figure out that they need to create an account in some "identity provider", which then gives them an URL to copy-paste into the site.
- wildlogic 11y agoThis might be a silly question, but why do we need Mozilla to build this system? Is it a matter of trust in Mozilla and a greater likelihood of adoption if Mozilla is the organization providing this service?
- r3bl 11y agoI'd definitely say that the trustworthiness is the reason since a large chunk of Internet is not really satisfied with the way Mozilla adopts things.
- espadrine 11y ago> Is it a matter of trust in Mozilla Yes. Mozilla has helped bring a large number of Web-related standards while maintaining consistently high privacy and security requirements. Note that Persona isn't a one-central-service system, though. You can have a ton of identity providers, assuming they all follow the same standard. You do need one service to get started, however.
- Perixoog 11y ago>Tell the email provider you want to give a site permission to know your email address, without telling the provider which site it is. Then the site emails you anyway. (If you didn't want them to, you shouldn't have given them your email address).
- sp332 11y agoThe email could be used for authentication purposes and not for actual email.
- sova 11y agoPersona is a most promising idea because it will eventually lead to secure passwordless login everywhere. Keep the pedal to the metal guys!
- SimeVidas 11y agoBut Persona isn’t passwordless, or?
- quadrangle 11y agoPersona is passwordless. The idea is that you verify with your email provider who supports it. Your email provider may have a password, but there's no Persona-related password (unless you use Mozilla's Persona.org service because your email provider doesn't support Persona directly).
- tajen 11y ago- Can Mozilla set up a kickstarter for this project? - Is it technically possible to create a Bash/SSH integration? The Linux world pretty much has SSO now, it would be an awesome argument to have this and Persona extend each other.
- slasaus 11y agoThe client that wants to login always needs to execute a browser (or at least a render and JavaScript engine). See this (stalled) proposal to make it more compatible with non-browser/simpler agents: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/mozilla.dev.identity/L2ETKkdMv8g/q3ffwFaJgl0J https://groups.google.com/d/msg/mozilla.dev.identity/L2ETKkd...
- lukeh 11y agoWell, we had Persona working as both as GSS-API mechanism on Unix and a SSP on Windows. You could use it to sign-in to Exchange with Outlook - that was pretty cool. Links here: * https://hacks.mozilla.org/2013/04/mozilla-persona-for-the-non-web/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2013/04/mozilla-persona-for-the-no... * https://github.com/PADL/libbrowserid https://github.com/PADL/libbrowserid * https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-howard-gss-browserid-07 https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-howard-gss-browserid-07
- StavrosK 11y agoTo your second question, yes, it is. Your identity provider can do whatever you want, so as long as you can make a website that shows you a "connect with your SSH now" prompt and have that turn green when you connect, then Persona can go on top of that. Persona is just a way for your email domain to say "yes I know this person". The way the site does that doesn't matter to Persona, and there was a service similar to mailinator that just let you log in with a disposable email address everywhere, with no other authentication.
- zanny 11y agoMan, Linux desktops would have a huge gain to usability if we could get a distributed accounts framework in place for all the distros so if you signin using online credentials through Persona on one desktop all your config files and preferences are carried over. Its annoying to have to manually sync my laptop and desktops config files.
- romaniv 11y ago> Anyone with access to your email account can simply reset any password on any site. The right solution is to make your email account very, very secure. No, the right solution is to stop using email as sole identification for password resets. Yes, there are other solutions you can implement right now without waiting for some big company to save you. The most obvious one it to create a second factor of authentication just for account resets. It could be via an SMS OR simply by asking user to print out/write down a special randomly generated "reset" number. "But SMS costs money!" No, for most providers you can send an email to a special address reserved for the phone number. It will get translated to SMS automatically. "But users will forget/loose their reset number!" Maybe, maybe not. It's a cultural thing. You don't expect them to loose access to their email, but that happens all the time.
- devit 11y agoYou can use a dedicated e-mail address for accounts.
- ygjb 11y agoSMS is an awful point of failure to inject into a protocol. It is plain-text, monitored in many countries, and can be unreliable and expensive in emerging markets, and just no. "But users will forget/loose their reset number!" Maybe, maybe not. It's a cultural thing. Really? Can you cite anything here that indicates this is the case? Users treat email access differently, seeing as how it's bound to user identity, usually across dozens, if not hundreds of services.
- tim333 11y agoSMS though provides a higher level of security. Some hacker anywhere on the planet could have accessed my email and passwords but they can't get a code sent to my phone unless they are nearby and have got hold of the phone. I'm not sure it being plain text and monitored matters much as all that's bring sent is a random number usually. I'll admit it could cost more and so may not be the thing for sites with lots of free users. If you can't get sms some sites will phone you with a recorded message.
- 11y ago
- shmerl 11y agoI didn't even realize Persona was shut down. It was a good idea.
- buro9 11y agoAnyone who wants to see a demo of it, just sign-in here (top right): https://login.persona.org/ https://login.persona.org/ Anyone who wants to see how easy it is to deploy (JS on your page, a button, and callback verifier on your server): https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Persona/Quick_Setup https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Persona/Quick_Setup Anyone who wants to see it in action: https://www.lfgss.com/ https://www.lfgss.com/ I love everything about Persona except for the fact that Mozilla are no longer supporting a team around it, and it was given to the community in almost an abandon-ware fashion. The idea that this could have made an impact faster is laughable, choosing an auth provider is such a slow process requiring considerable points of trust to reinforce it... one of the most significant points of trust was Mozilla itself, but it also needed a social reinforcement as more people adopted it. Mozilla didn't give Persona the time it needed. My criticisms of Persona are nothing to do with the fungible nature of email as identity, which I think is OK enough in principle (it's no less identifying than anything else and changes less frequently than a phone number), but to do with: 1) The way Persona wants to centrally log-out from all sites, when a user's experience is that they can sign-out from one site and remain signed-in on another. 2) The lack of 2FA in the default instance they shipped/supported. 3) Some of the phrasing and language confuses users, especially after changing to Persona. i.e. They were still a user on my site identified by email address, but Persona would declare that they were not recognised... so I'd have to spend time telling the user to ignore that and sign-in anyway. The core product though, was exactly what the web needed, and exactly what I needed for all of the sites I run.
- StavrosK 11y agoTo address some of your points: 1) That is completely controlled by the site owner. In my sites, for example, I just disabled the Persona JS while the user was logged in, so there was no global log-out possible. 2) I believe the bridge was just a proof of concept, with the intention of email providers supporting Persona directly so all the security could be implemented there. I know you said "default bridge", but my side-project here supports 2FA: https://persowna.net/ https://persowna.net/ 3) That is very true, some UX changes were necessary, but imagine if the browser itself could just pop up a window saying "do you want to log in to this site using your email address? Yes/No", done.
- JoachimSchipper 11y ago> Even if your email provider does end up getting breached, you only need to change one password to be perfectly secure everywhere again. I liked the article, but this is not true - if a service gives out password reset tokens or log-in-via-emailed-link tokens, a breach of your e-mail will still require a reset on that service. Even in a fully Persona'ified world, such tokens are likely to exist for at least some services.
- jaybosamiya 11y ago> As security people like to say, “put all your eggs in one basket and stick the basket in Fort Knox” I'm not so sure I want to do that. The point is, even that single Fort Knox can be breached at some point, and if it is, then everything is lost. I agree that nowadays, email is almost unanimously the way to verify a password reset, and hence all your eggs are already in one basket, but shouldn't there be further protections?
- StavrosK 11y agoLike you say, email is already the basket, so there are only advantages in migrating (such as not leaving your passwords all around the web).
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "I agree that nowadays, email is almost unanimously the way to verify a password reset, and hence all your eggs are already in one basket, but shouldn't there be further protections?" A few of the major webmail providers offer two-factor authentication, so that's one option to enhance protection. Here's some information about how to enable it for Gmail, Hotmail and Yahoo Mail: https://www.google.com/landing/2step/ https://www.google.com/landing/2step/ http://windows.microsoft.com/en-gb/windows/two-step-verification-faq http://windows.microsoft.com/en-gb/windows/two-step-verifica... https://help.yahoo.com/kb/SLN5013.html https://help.yahoo.com/kb/SLN5013.html
- deno 11y agoIt doesn’t have to be an email acc. Persona doesn’t actually have any dependency on email. Addresses that look like email (user@domain.tld) are just used for namespacing. The only requirement is that domain.tld can assert that you control user@domain.tld. https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Persona/Protocol_Overview https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Persona/Protocol_Overvie...
- um_ya 11y agoDon't know why persona never caught on, it was probably the best developer/user logon experience I've ever used. When I created my last site, I was very excited about persona, until I realized nobody was developing it anymore, which made me decide against using it. I wish Mozilla would have completed persona before abandoning it.
- sgarrity 11y agoThe best way to get Persona adopted would be to have someone significant other than Mozilla to adopt it. If IE, Safari, or Chrome had adopted, it would have had a great chance at success.
- soapdog 11y agoJust to be clear, Persona works on IE, Safari and Chrome as well. It is not tied to Firefox. You can login to MDN for example using Persona on Chrome if you'd like to.
- nine_k 11y agoBut why would they? All three have their own auth services to peddle. I don't see other browser vendors implementing Persona before (if ever) it is an otherwise widely accepted thing.
- Flimm 11y agoBut even Firefox didn't adopt it! Why expect other browsers to support what desktop Firefox never supported even for a day?
- foxbarrington 11y agoAs a dev, it was really nice to use Persona and not have to build an authentication system for each project. Now we use Authentic (https://github.com/davidguttman/authentic https://github.com/davidguttman/authentic). In some ways it's better (e.g. get to control your own UI/UX flows), but it would have been nice to just have Mozilla run/host everything.
- NelsonMinar 11y agoWe've had 10+ years now of failures to build a proper federated authentication system (RIP OpenID). The problem isn't technical, and it's only a little bit product design. The problem is political. The big companies with the influence to support a system like Persona don't want it. Facebook, Google, etc believe they can own identity on the Internet themselves, so they won't support a neutral identity provider. Which is a terrible situation for users. Mozilla absolutely is the right kind of organization to try to attack this Gordian knot.
- wpietri 11y agoI totally agree with the first paragraph, but I'm not convinced on the second. Mozilla is right in the sense that they're independent and a not-for-profit. But they're also small relative to the other players, with more limited resources. They also just don't seem to be very good at politics and/or building business partnerships. In particular here they seemed to solve it as mainly a technical problem. They apparently launched it with the assumption that its existence alone was sufficient to generate uptake, which even at the time seemed naive to me. And then after a while they shrugged, said, "looks like it doesn't work" and closed it down. That doesn't seem like the right organization to me.
- NelsonMinar 11y agoI agree the Mozilla organization has failed here. I guess I don't know any other neutral organization that could do this. We have precious few user-advocacy organizations out there. It's outside EFF's bailiwick. I don't think Apache is any better at politics than Mozilla.
- drdaeman 11y agoPlease, don't. Persona is an inherently bad protocol that continues the unnerving trend to shift the concept of identities from something that's owned to something that's merely leased and temporarily granted. It's better than "Login with $Provider" in a sense that $Provider doesn't get the data, but it's equally worse in a sense that $Provider still owns your identity. I wrote about it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10595347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10595347
- sundarurfriend 11y agoCould you suggest a usable, practical alternative then? It seems from the other thread that you believe WebID to be a better alternative to Persona/BrowserID. How practical and usable is it right now, and what key advantages does it offer in your opinion?
- drdaeman 11y agoSadly, no alternative currently exists. Well, none I know of. There were some attempts like WebID and gpgAuth, but none is usable at the moment. They have to be dug out of dirt of oblivion, carefully analyzed and improved with important features they're missing to be usable for ordinary people (at least key escrow and sync - both completely optional, of course). What I want from authentication system, is complete independence and full and ultimate control and ownership of my own identity. I don't want to trust, depend or even need any third party just to have account with someone. Not even if this third party is a domain name registrar, not even if I have a legal agreement with them. When we had just usernames and passwords - it was exactly like that, except for mandatory emails thingy (but that's another story). I met someone, we introduce yourselves, negotiate a shared secret - and we're now acquaintances. With OpenID/OAuth/SAML/JWT/Persona this is no more the case - we have to call a notary and the notary will tell us who I am. And I really don't like this and want to see this fixed. I want to revoke any possibility of any third party to revoke or otherwise deny my identity. They may assert my identity (say they know me and I'm a good lad) and revoke their assertion about my identity (i.e. say they don't trust me anymore), but not the fact who I am.
- soapdog 11y agoThe main problem with Persona was not the tech, Persona is great and works well. The problem is that building federated identity services is hard. Persona is not a centralized login system such as "login with Facebook". With Persona, once you decide to login with your email account, first Persona looks for an IdP with your domain/provider, the if not found it goes back to the persona catchall service. For a while gmail.com had support for Persona as well and it worked transparently. I don't know if that is still the case. What killed Persona was not tech but the lack of traction. Developers loved it but failed to use it. By providing options such as FB, Google, Twitter and other logins, the user choose the familiar service and never tried Persona. In the end, the lack of traction together with the overall difficulty of building federated identity services killed it. But what is dead cannot die! Persona still works, I still use it every day in lots of Mozilla properties and if I had to build some service that required logins, I would use it even today. It is in the hand of the community but with some care and more traction this can become cool again. I will look into the source code and see if I can help somewhere.
- smacktoward 11y ago> With Persona, once you decide to login with your email account, first Persona looks for an IdP with your domain/provider, the if not found it goes back to the persona catchall service. This implies a classic chicken/egg dilemma: email providers won't implement Persona support unless that would be useful for lots of people; Persona wouldn't be useful for lots of people until their email provider supported it.
- soapdog 11y agoIt worked even if their email provider didn't supported it because in such cases there was a fallback Mozilla IdP. You can try it right now on MDN or MozillaWiki.
- deno 11y ago> What killed Persona was not tech but the lack of traction. Developers loved it but failed to use it. The idea was always that Mozilla would ship native integration in Firefox. There were very very pretty mockups going around and everyone was holding their breath for that to happen.[1] Even announcing they would ship it in the next version would mean 1) it’s stable now and 2) Mozilla is behind it. My guess is Google (their sponsor at that time) made them drop it because they were preparing to launch G+. I know it’s a conspiracy theory, but it frankly makes more sense than all those other non-reasons I keep hearing about in this thread. [1] http://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/firefox-account-manager.jpg http://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/firefo...
- hexis 11y agoI haven't looked into Persona since they shut it down, but is it a protocol or a service? If it was actively developed again, would one be able to use Persona without integrating with any Mozilla service at all or would there always be a Mozilla layer involved?
- wpietri 11y agoIt is a service. Plus some code to make service integration into your website easy. Sadly, my experience was that it was not very reliable.
- quadrangle 11y agoThe backend was called BrowserID, and it was supposed to integrate with your browser and be supported by email providers not be some Mozilla service. It's only a service because they didn't get around to implementing the actual BrowserID design, so they run a service for now, and then they halted development before they even tried to build the actual design!
- Twisell 11y agoIf someone at Apple is reading this... please fork it (or built up from scratch) a solid open source SSO system and become an official (but optional) identity provider for your millions customers. This would be a win-win as this could help AppleID and TouchID becoming even more central for your users while demonstrating at the same time that you care about privacy and are willing to develop an open standard to support strong and distributed identity management system as an alternative to Google and Facebook centralized and privacy unfriendly solution.
- Osmose 11y agoDisclaimer: I work for Mozilla, I maintain django-browserid (and StravosK is a valued contributor <3), and I have implemented Persona on many sites. This is all just my own personal opinion. I was very bullish on Persona early on, but the fact of the matter is, we failed. And not just because (as I feel is being implied) some higher up suddenly came over and asked for an unreasonable amount of adoption for a revolutionary product. We failed for a thousand reasons. It should've been supported directly within the Firefox chrome ASAP. It had branding different than the site you logged in to and was in a popup[1]. It took the name of another Firefox feature that users already knew about. Because the team was experimenting fast, the code quality of the service was such that outside contribution to it (or even cross-team contribution internally) was hard to impossible. There was no (or very limited) metadata available for things like a shared avatar or display name. We had enough time to do these things, but we didn't. The team accomplished something really amazing, but it wasn't enough, and most importantly, putting more effort into what already existed was not going to work. This idea that Mozilla can just turn around and throw effort at Persona and make it win now is, IMO, wrong. Identity needs more experimentation, that much is certain. But harping bringing back Persona in particular is beating a dead horse. We need a successor or a new project. [1] Not only did this make Persona look incredibly sketchy without a lot of priming users, it had a major privacy issue of leaking your identity provider and relying party to Mozilla via a centralized iframe we host. A mailing list thread among the Persona devs and community failed to find a solution to this.
- StavrosK 11y agoHey Michael! <3 Aw :( Do you think these problems can be solved with an extension or a different protocol? How close were you to a solution for this?
- Osmose 11y agoThe only thing that has a chance of happening is some external party coming up with a different protocol or extending the existing one, and gaining traction as an identity provider. Then, like we did with Pocket and "Save for Later", it's not unreasonable to think that Firefox would accept a system add-on that is compatible with this protocol to ship an in-browser UI. "gaining traction as an identity provider" being the hard part, of course.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIt's alarming that after 2 years they killed it off for lack of traction, and not only that, decided they had failed. How could they have possibly succeeded in that timescale? They seem to think there were flaws with Persona, and that's true, but those flaws could be fixed. Making a few mistakes on an attempt doesn't mean you should kill it off if the basic product works well. It means you fix them. Starting a new Persona is silly, Persona itself works.
- akerro 11y agoAND TAKE POCKET AWAY!
- cmurf 11y agoEven though I didn't use Persona, having read this, I think this is a big WTF moment for all of us, not just Mozilla. Now I want this thing I didn't know existed because I have, and have had, a need for exactly this. I use a password manager, but I don't really want to use one. I certainly don't like my parents using them, because in fact I have to use them for them because the UI/UX varies so much among web sites. There is no standard UI for changing passwords or doing account resets. All of that shit could go away with this. Fuck. We need to go retrieve that ship!
- ossreality 11y agoAlmost every single time it came up on HN it was met with FUD or straight out lies about what it was, how it worked and what it was like compared to other login mechanisms. I distinctly remember, both during development of Persona, and shortly after the discontinuation of it... people who had this BRILLIANT IDEA! They would send a token to your email /every time you wanted to login/. They repeatedly were lacking in every way to Persona but somehow managed to capture more of peoples' attention. Actually, congrats, there are several users doing it right here in this thread.
- patrickaljord 11y agoI don't really see the point in this and this is why: let's say Persona won and all the big ones switched to it (Facebook, Google, Twitter etc.) by becoming providers. Most people would still be using their Facebook, Google or Twitter persona anyway (except for a few privacy sensitive users who don't like SaaS anyway because it's bad for privacy according to them). So we would have a situation that would be de facto very similar to what we have now (3 sigin buttons for facebook, google and twitter) and then an extra one for people using their own hosted provider. This is what happened with OpenID, problem was that supporting people using their own providers became a nightmare as these providers went down or had some incompatibilities. People were just angry they couldn't sign in with their old providers, many of theme may have not even known they were using custom providers or what providers are and the other half would be privacy nerds who enjoy complaining every time their custom provider stops being fully compatible. For app owners, it would just be a big waste of time and resources supporting these users.
- StavrosK 11y agoYou misunderstand how Persona works. You can't log in with Facebook or Twitter, because they don't provide your email address. You can log in with an email address, and the email provider doesn't know what sites you're logging in to. Try https://pastery.net https://pastery.net, log in there. If you have a Gmail account, you'll just click "accept" and you're in.
- patrickaljord 11y agoI just tried it and it redirected me to google oauth2 dialog. Same thing. If anything, it's one step more than using google's oauth2 directly.
- floatboth 11y agohttps://indieauth.com https://indieauth.com Of course domains aren't as popular as email addresses, but OpenID used domains… This is like OpenID done right.
- stevetjoa 11y agoMy first experience with Persona was through my mobile phone provider, Ting. They still use Persona: https://ting.com/account/login https://ting.com/account/login. I loved it then, and I love it now.
- darklajid 11y agoI've hit the upvote button, tweeted Stavros that I think this is awesome - but I still want to document my support with a post. I don't have a FB account and don't use my Google account a lot. I should really delete the latter. But it would be so much easier with Persona. Yes, a lot of sites won't adopt it, at least at first. But with a well supported alternative that I want to use, I'd have an easier time to say "fuck it" and close the browser window. Right now I'm trying to go for the next best thing: Different accounts per service (vs braindead "Log in with Silicon Valley Corp"). Alas .. Persona would simplify my password store a LOT. I'd back a campaign. Not sure if I could offer hundreds of dollars, but let me state here that I'd find a way to add 50-80 right away/as an incentive to adopt the project again and I definitely would be able to contribute a recurring amount (a la Patreon etc) for the ongoing development.
- stickfigure 11y agoI was an early adopter of Persona (my site is billed as example in the docs) and was similarly disappointed when Mozilla gave up on it. In retrospect, I think that Mozilla made a mistake by centralizing the fallback identity provider. The fallback provider was just a temporary edifice to bootstrap the protocols; it didn't have to be run by Mozilla. Every website could have run a small stack which remained fully self-branded and would only verify email addresses for its own purposes. I understand why Mozilla took the route they did - centralizing the fallback provider eased the RP implementation, made it possible to rapidly rev the protocols, and in theory made it more convenient for users since one Persona password would work across multiple sites. In practice, however, users were confused about the extra branding and the vague sense of logging into Persona so you can log into a site. More critically, it made the whole project depend on the whims of Mozilla - it's not just software we depend on, but infrastructure, and without Mozilla's support the infrastructure will eventually die. If Persona is revived, I hope it becomes a complete software stack that every RP can run independently. The fallback IdP should be 100% branded by the RP so users are never confused about what site they are logging into. And as non-hosted software, it should be able to live and evolve as open source software without fear that some tepidly supported server will go down (or simply fail to evolve). IMHO, this is the only way that Persona (or at least the auth standard, which is what we care about) can survive long-term as a community project.
- natrius 11y agoPersona seemed like the right identity product for its time, but technology has moved on in the years since. We now have blockchains: shared, publicly-writable databases that are perfect for hosting identities that users fully control. Figuring out decentralized identity is part of my day job, and if it's something you're interested in building or talking about, email me: niran@niran.org.
- slacka 11y agoIt's nearly 2016 and Firefox can still only using 1 of my 8 CPU cores, and I can still bog down the UI with heavy web apps. My favorite email client is no longer supported, and now a potentially great privacy tool is being dropped. Meanwhile, after wasting countless man hours on a Mobile OS, they're now "pivoting" to IoT. Why can't they just focus on what people value them for, web browsers and privacy?
- fermigier 11y agoI've used Persona on one project (see: https://github.com/OWF/owf2014/blob/master/website/auth/persona.py https://github.com/OWF/owf2014/blob/master/website/auth/pers...). I was awesome (much much easier than the OAuth dance with the various providers we wanted to support). I wholeheartedly agree w/ Stavros.
- goatic 11y agoPersona sounds like what I've always dreamed of for authentication. Why is this not happening anywhere yet?
- programminggeek 11y agoNot sure if anyone realizes this, but Mozilla is not really an open source thing. It's a company that happens to be a nonprofit. It deploys resources and runs itself like a Silicon Valley company. It's not just a bunch of dudes in their basements writing code. They have like $330 million in annual revenue. They are sitting on like $90 million in cash. Mozilla isn't about software for its own sake or just for the sake of the web. They are about self preservation and Persona wasn't going to keep them alive, so they killed it. Mozilla is a company. That is what companies do.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoFrom what I understand, there are two arms to Mozilla... Mozilla the company (sometimes referred to as MoCo) and the Mozilla Foundation (sometimes referred to as MoFo). Again, from what I understand, MoCo is the not-for-profit company supporting the work of the Mozilla Foundation. The Foundation has an ethical mission to improve and protect the web. EDIT: Here's a quote from the Mozilla Foundation homepage (https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/): "Many of Mozilla’s products are developed by the Mozilla Corporation, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Mozilla Foundation. The Mozilla Corporation functions as a self-sustaining social enterprise — money earned through its products is reinvested into the organization."
- mlinksva 11y agoI've got plenty of quibbles with Mozilla (including their handling of Persona) but "open source thing" and "company" are not mutually exclusive. We need more entities with lots of resources doing almost exclusively open source.
- charlieok 11y agoAs I understand it, the main point of Persona was improving the situation around authentication and passwords. Now, I'm seeing indications that Mozilla is working on implementing FIDO U2F support (“Mozilla’s commitment to add FIDO U2F support to the Firefox browser”). https://www.yubico.com/2015/12/2015-was-a-yubico-rocket-ride/ https://www.yubico.com/2015/12/2015-was-a-yubico-rocket-ride... That seems like a much better approach to improving the situation around authentication and passwords than Persona was.
- transfire 11y agoYou know what poverty is? Always starting over. Mozilla is getting good at that.
- isolate 11y agoFirefox is ancient.
- IgorPartola 11y agoWhile I think Persona is way better than password-based auth, I can't help but feel that it's also a sideways step. No, authentication should be provided by the user-agent, not by some third party identity provider (even if you control it by running your own). We have this for ssh: you have your private ssh key and it's up to you to manage having it in the right places (work desktop, laptop, phone, etc.) It's clunky, but that's OK: it's aimed at tech people. Browsers should do something similar: provide a storage for private and public keys as proof of identity. But they should additionally provide a way to sync those identities across multiple browsers and machines. This latter concept will be familiar to anyone who has used LastPass. The former, well it should basically be a dropdown with your identities, and you choose one before clicking the "Login" button.
- mgbmtl 11y agoTo some extent, this is similar to SSL/TLS certificates that can be used to authenticate the user (not just the server). If I recall correctly, http://startssl.com/ http://startssl.com/ does that. It's not a very intuitive mode of authentication, but if the UI was improved, and combined with a sync service (& encrypted with a passphrase), I guess it could be usable? (also, presumably it requires the site to use https, but that's also much more expected today than it was 10 years ago)
- IgorPartola 11y agoYeah, basically this. I have used it before and client side TLS certs are anything but intuitive. They are also not widely supported.
- deno 11y agoBrowserID works by default with email but it has absolutely to dependency on email. It uses it for namespacing and bootstrapping, but nothing else. So foo@bar.com may or may not have any MX records, all that is required is that bar.com can provide an assertion that you control foo@bar.com. The way bar.com determines that is entirely up to bar.com, it can be a password, smart crypto card, local kerberos or Windows auth, 3-way auth involving your cat Rufus, etc... https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Persona/Protocol_Overview https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Persona/Protocol_Overvie...
- odbol 11y agoPersona is a neat idea, but there's a better one: get rid of password logins altogether. I should just be able to enter my email on ANY site, and they'll send me an email with a login button. I click the login button in the email, and am automatically logged into the site for as long as necessary. It's exactly as secure as the "Forgot my password" reset nonsense, but streamlined to be way easier on the user. Then you only need one password: the one to your email. This removes the need for Persona to "add support" for different email providers. Your provider doesn't matter, just the fact that you can receive emails! I'd really wish more sites would just do this anyway. For instance, every time I get an analytics daily report from Fabric.io, I click the link in the email, and it asks me to login. WHY ARE YOU ASKING ME TO LOGIN, WHEN I JUST CLICKED AN EMAIL YOU SENT ME? It's obviously me!
- tim333 11y agoYeah but if you do that what happens if you want to use the site again the following week? Do you have to do the check your email thing every time which could get annoying or leave them logged in for ever with cookies which could be a security issue. Not saying it's necessarily a bad idea but I wonder how well it would work in practice compared with the normal stuff.
- Flimm 11y agoIf you have an identity server, a website and a browser that all support Persona, (and you've already been through the process once), Persona would work much better than that. You don't have to memorise a new password and you don't have to click on a verification email. You just land on a new site, click log in with Persona, choose your email address, and TADA! you're in. And the beauty of it is that your email provider doesn't even know which sites you're logging in to.
- grayrest 11y agoThe message I got from Persona was "hey we're developing this thing, it'll be part of Firefox." Sounded like a pretty good idea to me and the signal for it being ready so I could reasonably push for adoption. Then it got shut down for no apparent reason.
- sergiotapia 11y agoI backed persona with a well written example back when it first 'came out' into the mainstream: https://github.com/sergiotapia/ASP.Net-MVC3-Persona-Demo https://github.com/sergiotapia/ASP.Net-MVC3-Persona-Demo It was super easy to integrate, better UX in my eyes, but Mozilla just shut it down for some reason. It died down. I hope they assign more resources to it. I hate having Facebook sign ins on my website.
- muppetman 11y agoPeople who write open letters need to fall in a hole. They're so lame.
- greggman 11y agoJust an idea but could they work with the wordpress guys to make it the default system for wordpress? They're both open source companies and apparently wordpress runs a large percentage of the web.
- ivanb 11y agoMy only gripe with Persona is that it is not easy to use in mobile apps, if at all possible.
- lukeh 11y agoI really liked Persona and put a bunch of work into extending it (adding support for things like selective attribute disclosure). One real design limitation was that it didn't support delegation (the original use case for OAuth).
- anonbanker 11y agoMitch Baker should be commended on her hard work turning Mozilla back into Netscape.
- Lethalman 11y agoSorry, where is it said they will stop development of Persona? The homepage and the service seem to be in full health, there's no warning anywhere for users of Persona. Is there any official statement that Persona will shut down?
- maxerickson 11y agohttp://identity.mozilla.com/ http://identity.mozilla.com/