2 ms·
Ok everyone is stuck on the bitrate argument and consumer choice. However I'm more focused on if this plan is even possible. Could Netflix really want to throw
by azinman2 11y ago
Ok everyone is stuck on the bitrate argument and consumer choice. However I'm more focused on if this plan is even possible.
Could Netflix really want to throw so much money at transcoding so many ways? Are there various tricks to do this at a reasonable cost? Like grab random 10 seconds across 15 points in a movie and try just that? Work with top n most popular first? Sort by existing biggest movies?
- angryasian 11y agothe transcodes is not where the money is spent. Its primarily on streaming costs. Every company wants to maximize quality and reduce cost to stream. Right now everyone wants 4k streams. The size and cost are becoming ridiculous. Its worth it in the end to use better encoders as well as do what Netflix is doing.
- lnanek2 11y agoDoing the transcodes is pretty much a drop in the bucket for NetFlix. Even transcoding the same movie 1000x at full length is pretty meaningless to them since it is a fixed cost against their library size. What they really care about is things that are multiplied by the number of users they have. Saving 5% of bandwidth on 100k users is very meaningful to them. So doing extra transcodes to figure out what to send is very valuable. They've come and given talks at Cloud dev meetups and just an unexpected bump in bandwidth or delay in server response time causing traffic to back up is enough to knock over their servers and they do things no one else would even think of, like having their clients upload code to their servers to batch requests together in the optimal format for the clients, just to reduce bandwidth and load on their network.
- JackuB 11y agoI was running small project that encoded videos with SaaS in multiple formats/sizes (~10) and then distributed it over CDN (no major traffic). CDN price was about 99% of project costs. Transcoding and storage on S3 was fraction of a cost. I was also trying every trick in the book to make files smaller, just to cut on traffic.
- JshWright 11y agoNetflix's internal instance spot market means they can pretty easily throw unused EC2 instances at transcoding tasks.