4 ms·
Can I ask what the damage is by allowing collection agencies who have purchased a debt to attempt to collect said debt past it's SOL? If you touch a debt (e.g.
by pc86 11y ago
Can I ask what the damage is by allowing collection agencies who have purchased a debt to attempt to collect said debt past it's SOL? If you touch a debt (e.g. make a partial payment) it resets the SOL, so it seems there's precedent that a debt past its SOL is still a valid debt.
It also seems like a beneficial negotiation tactic for the consumer. Some states have an SOL well below the ~7-year period where it falls off your credit report. So if I live in Louisiana with a 3-year SOL on consumer debt and someone tries to collect a 4-year-old debt, pay-for-delete obviously becomes a much more likely scenario. My credit goes up a lot with the removal of a delinquent account, and the collector makes money off something I could otherwise ignore without penalty.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Can I ask what the damage is by allowing collection agencies who have purchased a debt to attempt to collect said debt past it's SOL? If you touch a debt (e.g. make a partial payment) it resets the SOL, so it seems there's precedent that a debt past its SOL is still a valid debt. If the law says you can't collect, you should not be able to ask either. You're relying on someone's ignorance to collect a debt. > It also seems like a beneficial negotiation tactic for the consumer. Some states have an SOL well below the ~7-year period where it falls off your credit report. So if I live in Louisiana with a 3-year SOL on consumer debt and someone tries to collect a 4-year-old debt, pay-for-delete obviously becomes a much more likely scenario. My credit goes up a lot with the removal of a delinquent account, and the collector makes money off something I could otherwise ignore without penalty. Again, you're assuming a shred and educated citizen who is attempting to use a loophole (pay-to-delete, which violates a collector's agreement with all three credit reporting agencies). No. Asking someone to pay after the SOL has passed as the debt is time barred is tantamount to fraud. I've already placed called to Senator Warren's office, as well as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> If the law says you can't collect, you should not be able to ask either. The law doesn't say you can't collect, it says you can't enforce the debt in court. Its not theoretically impossible that a person who had undertaken a debt that had become unenforceable might be inclined to pay it off for social reasons that don't rely on the legal enforceability of the debt, so it probably shouldn't be illegal to notify and ask. > You're relying on someone's ignorance to collect a debt, and I will work to apply a boot to the neck of collection companies who practice that. To the extent that an attempt to collect an unenforceable debt relies on false implications of legal consequences like wage garnishments, seizure of property, etc., it is already barred by the FDCPA, which prohibits a variety of types of false representations and implications in the context of debt collection, and punishes debt collectors who use them. There may be a good case that this should be tightened and require explicit notice of debts that are beyond the statute of limitations and not legally enforceable in collections (which would also give the collector a positive obligation to make this determination.) But I think that prohibiting asking for payment beyond the statute of limitations is probably going to far, for the reasons above.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The law doesn't say you can't collect, it says you can't enforce the debt in court. Its not theoretically impossible that a person who had undertaken a debt that had become unenforceable might be inclined to pay it off for social reasons that don't rely on the legal enforceability of the debt, so it probably shouldn't be illegal to notify and ask. Perhaps then, instead of it being illegal, the collection agency (either via phone or through paper correspondence) should be required to (up front) disclose that the debt is no longer enforceable and that the debtor is not required to pay the debt back by law. > There may be a good case that this should be tightened and require explicit notice of debts that are beyond the statute of limitations and not legally enforceable in collections (which would also give the collector a positive obligation to make this determination.) But I think that prohibiting asking for payment beyond the statute of limitations is probably going to far, for the reasons above. I agree that a middle ground can be found between making it illegal and what we have now. My problem is with the information asymmetry.