4 ms·
You can get a $100/year raise just for the asking. In tech, salaries are just not negotiated at the $100/year granularity. Imagine saying "I'm also considering
by geofft 11y ago
You can get a $100/year raise just for the asking. In tech, salaries are just not negotiated at the $100/year granularity. Imagine saying "I'm also considering an offer from this company, can you offer more" and the HR department coming back with "Sure, we can give you $100/year more."
If you can get a $100/year raise just for the asking, and you can also get a $100/year raise in exchange for equity, then simple arithmetic indicates that the equity has zero value.
- lordsper 11y agoOr it means: you value your equity at $0 a year, and your HR guys get a bonus for reducing expenses.
- graeme 11y agoThis is trivially wrong. You could get a $100 raise once, and possibly several times. But at some point, the boss would say "alright, no more raises". At that point, you could say "I'll give up all my equity for another $100", at which point the boss would jump to agree.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoSlowly a strategy emerges ... ;-)
- bkeroack 11y ago> But at some point, the boss would say "alright, no more raises". Not because $100 is too much, but because you've annoyed her by asking too many times. $100 is still trivial in value to the business.
- graeme 11y agoThis still is refusing to consider the marginal case, which is what the OP was asking about. At some point, even if asked the first time, a boss might refuse a $100 raise. They would still take the $100 for equity deal. The point was just a thought experiment to show that equity has more than 0 value.
- harryh 11y agoThank you.
- geofft 11y agoIt is quite something that the best objection HN can offer to "Equity has no value" is "Surely it's worth at least five cents an hour." OK, equity is worth five cents an hour. I admit it! Let's all negotiate with that in mind.
- harryh 11y agoI was making a rhetorical point against the idea that it was worth zero. I was not attempting to actually put a value on anyone's equity. It's quite something that you apparently couldn't tell the difference between those two things.
- rfrey 11y ago"If you can get a $100/year raise just for the asking, and you can also get a $100/year raise in exchange for equity, then simple arithmetic indicates that the equity has zero value" If I offer my Embarcadero penthouse in exchange for a $100/year raise, does that mean the apartment has 0 value?
- geofft 11y agoIf you can't ask for more of a raise, then yes. The article clearly wanted you to ask for a raise at at least the granularity of real negotiations. Try getting a $10K raise in exchange for giving up equity.
- harryh 11y ago> Try getting a $10K raise in exchange for giving up equity. This will be possible (for people operating in the eng compensation band) at almost any startup you might want to work for. If you ask for this, and they don't at least discuss it with you, it's a pretty strong sign that you don't want to work there.
- lordsper 11y agoI take it you mean they don't want you to work there?
- harryh 11y agoNo. What I meant was if a company isn't willing to discuss giving you a higher salary but lower equity it probably means that they don't really value their own equity. And not valuing their own equity is a proxy for not valuing the future of the company. You don't generally want to work somewhere the company leadership doesn't value the future of the company.
- triplesec 11y agoIt could instead mean that they are being careful with burn rate, and capital is hard to get, and their calculations include employees being part-paid with equity - for everyone's benefit - because companies die by the current account!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]