3 ms·
Employees do have access to an investment to an investment nobody else does. It's just that they need to do due diligence on par with or better than an investo
by nostrademons 11y ago
Employees do have access to an investment to an investment nobody else does. It's just that they need to do due diligence on par with or better than an investor to avoid getting taken advantage of.
I've turned down more startup jobs than I can count. When I interview at a startup, I thoroughly research their market, their competitors, their product, and their business model. I ask questions about how they came up with the idea, and how they know other people want it, and what questions they asked when they did their market research, and how the idea has evolved in response to new information. How did the team meet? What's the company culture like, and what do they value? I ask about financials - are they profitable? What's their runway? What's their revenue and revenue growth rate? Is it recurring revenue or revenue for one-off contracts? What's their churn rate? I ask about funding - who is their VC? How many rounds have they taken, what's the preference overhang, how many more do they anticipate taking? (And then in my head, I'm running over the financials to see if this squares with their growth & revenue plans.)
If they're cagey about this, I walk. Some companies are, and that's their right, and I'm not going to work for them. Others are very impressed that I'm doing this level of due diligence, because it shows that I view my time there as an investment, and will invest the same level of diligence and effort into the job itself.
Equity compensation itself is not the problem. Equity itself is great for employees - they have an information advantage over every other shareholder of the company (including the VCs), and if they're an early hire, they can have a meaningful effect on the value of that equity. But to take advantage of this, they need to do due diligence as if they were an investor - they are, after all, they're investing their time, which is far more valuable than a VC's money. Equity is much more highly levered than salary - its value depends on how events play out, not just on what you've agreed beforehand - and so you should make sure you have enough information to make a reasonable guess at its value before accepting it.
- gkop 11y agoIn the context of parent and grandparent, what do you look for when doing your due diligence to evaluate the risk of the employees getting screwed on common shares when every other stakeholder makes money?
- nostrademons 11y agoThe first two things would be the amount of funding taken, and the preference overhang. If you know that a company has taken $300M in funding and that their last round of $150M had a 3x liquidation preference with a 1x preference on earlier rounds, then you can do the math to figure out that any exit under $600M is going to leave the common stock worthless. If you know your ownership percentage (and every startup employee should), you can then do the math to figure out how big an exit the company would need to have the desired financial outcome, eg. if you own 0.01% of the company, it would need to exit for $10.6B before you become a millionaire. Go judge the size of the market, growth rate, and profitability yourself to see if that's likely. In Good Technology's case, just look at Crunchbase: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/good-technology#/entity https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/good-technology#/ent... There are red flags galore for startup employees there - the funding history started with a Series E in 2005, with the company supposedly founded in 1996. That's the time to ask about the company history, which the article says started as a startup that bought Motorola Mobility's business. Every funding round since then was either private equity or debt (!!), along with a secondary sale. If I saw just the Crunchbase investment history and heard that it was a startup that purchased a spun-out portion of Motorola, my immediate reaction would be "This isn't a startup, this is a mature private company with a business model that requires large infusions of cash." (I've actually been burned in the public markets by a similar company - mature companies should not need regular cash infusions.) And I'd value the company accordingly - most likely, I wouldn't take the job there at all, but if I did, I'd assume that salary and experience is all I'm going to get.
- leoc 11y agoGiven the financial acumen and street smarts involved, it almost sounds as if there's a possible role for someone acting as an agent for potential startup employees: not an employment agency which gets a lump sum when an employer fills a vacancy, but a talent agent getting something like the traditional ten percent, or two-and-twenty, or whatever, of the employee's ongoing earnings. Not that dealing with talent agents is always a wonderful experience either, of course...
- nostrademons 11y agoAs part of the market research for a previous startup, I talked with plenty of recruiters who would love for their to be a market for software talent agents. If you're curious why such a market doesn't exist, read Aline Lerner's article "Why talent agents for engineers don't exist": http://blog.alinelerner.com/why-talent-agents-for-engineers-dont-exist/ http://blog.alinelerner.com/why-talent-agents-for-engineers-... tl;dr: Agents exist when it's hard to get a job. It is not hard to get a job in software right now. If your company mistreats you, you figure that out pretty quickly and move on to a company that doesn't mistreat you. There's no need to pay anyone to make that happen; in fact, you can get paid a significant amount more just by asking around. You hear about stories of startup employees getting screwed because the software engineering labor market (particularly for startups) is expanding rapidly now, and so there are a large number of employees who have no experience in the industry. These people are easy prey for a good salesman who wants to make their sham company seem like one of the winning startups. But it takes only a couple months for most smart employees to catch on, and move to another job. My first couple tech jobs were at startups where I was paid below market rate. The first one had some serious shenanigans going on when it went down in flames; the second had no shenanigans, it just wasn't going anywhere. But I left, and my compensation very quickly caught up with and then surpassed what I thought possible. I probably ended up significantly better off, financially, by taking the hard knocks early and learning the lessons myself rather than paying an agent 10% to handle everything for me. As they say, "when someone with no experience does business with someone with lots of experience, the person with no experience gains some experience."
- ScottBurson 11y agoThis post is so good I think you should expand it into a longer blog post and submit it to HN for further discussion. "How to evaluate a startup job" or some such.
- nostrademons 11y agoI'm tempted to start a blog someday, but my own startup takes precedence (or maybe it doesn't but should, I've been spending far too much time on HN lately), so when I do come up with ideas I often just post them as a HN comment or jot down a first draft in Google Docs for later cleanup. I can make note of this one and maybe come back to it someday, though.