6 ms·
Is there some other industry where, when a company stumbles, its employees don't get hurt? I live in Michigan, and when the car industry "stumbled" everyone I l
by jerf 11y ago
Is there some other industry where, when a company stumbles, its employees don't get hurt? I live in Michigan, and when the car industry "stumbled" everyone I locally know at least knew someone who got hit, at the very very least with long-term stagnant wages even as their responsibilities amped up to cover the missing people, and they were the ones who came out relatively unscathed.
I mean, the details of the article are all fine and dandy and interesting (no sarcasm, there's nothing wrong with the facts and they're at least worth a story), but the headline and framing seem to imply that there's some sort of alternative?
The only problem unique to the tech-unicorns here is exercising stock options when you can't pay for the taxes. Don't do that.
- justinph 11y agoAt least with the auto industry, the unions were able to offer some protections for the worker. How many programmers belong to a union?
- jerf 11y agoUnions can't do anything about the company you're working for running out of resources. That's not what they are for.
- gaius 11y agoThe can ensure the pie is sliced more fairly tho'.
- walshemj 11y agoAnd lobby for more sane tax for employee share options.
- serge2k 11y agoThey can help protect you from getting screwed over while the execs walk away with millions.
- gozur88 11y agoNot generally, no. The exception was the GM bailout, where the unions used political muscle to get moved ahead of secured creditors. That's the only case of which I'm aware, though.
- rebootthesystem 11y ago> How many programmers belong to a union? Thankfully none. One of the main reasons the car companies stumbled are unions. The whole thing has degenerated to insanity squared. For example, GM had a clause in their contract requiring them to not fire employees displaced by technology or automation. In other words, if you improve your workflow and process and can do the same work with 25 people instead of 100, you can't fire the people you no-longer need. All incentives to innovate in process and technology very quickly evaporate with such insanity in place. They reportedly had thousands of people show up for "work" every day drawing 95% salaries and full benefits only to go to this building, read the newspaper and drink coffee all day. Unions had their day and reason to exist. I am not proposing they need to disappear. However, they need to mutate into something that works towards a mutually beneficial and sustainable ecosystem. By pushing for, and obtaining, ridiculous grants, they create short term apparent gains and HUGE long term losses as thousands of people lose their jobs when they industry they worked in simply crumbles under the weight of onerous arrangements that cause them to lose the ability to compete and remain financially viable. In fact, if you look at Detroit, one could argue the unions went beyond costing people their jobs and companies their ability to compete, they actually succeeded at destroying a whole city. How is this, in any imaginable reality, good? A couple of articles: http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB114118143005186163 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB114118143005186163 This one covers other issues: http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2013/05/20/what-explains-gms-problems-with-the-uaw/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2013/05/20/what-explain... From the Forbes article: "A worker might be able to retire in his early 50s and collect an annual pension of $37,500, paid wholly by GM. By 2008 there were 4.6 retired GM employees for each active worker. Did anyone think this was sustainable?" It's called "killing the golden goose".
- mtberatwork 11y agoI'm having a hard time taking the links seriously. The WSJ article is behind a paywall so I am unable to read it. However, it's dated 2006 which would mean it was authored at the height of Wall Street "shenanigans" (for lack of a better term) while the Forbes article appears to be a canned editorial written by the Ayn Rand Institute.
- 11y ago
- rwmj 11y agoI'm a member of Prospect[1], a non-party-affiliated union for professionals. It's mainly good for getting legal advice if the company you work for tries to screw you over, so it's pretty relevant to the company/article being discussed (except Prospect is a UK union, but there are US equivalents). The cost is relatively trivial compared to a programmer's salary - about £200/yr. Unfortunately you can't claim it against tax in the UK. [1] https://www.prospect.org.uk/ https://www.prospect.org.uk/
- walshemj 11y agoMore than you might think including a former CEO of a FTSE 100 Company who in the past was an activist and not just a member.
- kenko 11y agoditonal's comment (currently below yours) is relevant here. Doesn't look like they stumbled to me! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10784180 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10784180
- thedufer 11y agoThe auto industry in Michigan didn't stumble. It crashed, hard. You can't compare that to a company selling for half a billion dollars and expect to be taken seriously.
- pmikesell 11y ago>> The only problem unique to the tech-unicorns here is exercising stock options when you can't pay for the taxes. Don't do that. Ok, sure, but what do you do when you have all of this equity vested on paper and either 1) you get fired, or 2) you want to leave the company?