3 ms·
I honestly don't even know which side it is that you think is "far more effective" at solving social problems. Do you think it's the Democrats? Because "big gov
by jerf 11y ago
I honestly don't even know which side it is that you think is "far more effective" at solving social problems. Do you think it's the Democrats? Because "big government and taxes" are also far more effective at creating social problems that local charities. Have you read about the corrosive effects of welfare on black communities? Have you ever joined in complaining about the inability of public school systems to successfully adapt and harness changing technologies? Have you noticed that our biggest social problems just "happen" to also be located right where Democratic policies were enacted (i.e., the policies preceded the social degradation)? All of these things are certainly at least debatable, but they are also certainly not so obviously false that they can simply be discarded without consideration.
"Big government and taxes" may theoretically be more capable of solving problems, but there's a big gulf between theory and reality.
And back on point so this is at least less an off-topic diversion than it otherwise would be, are you A: inclined to agree that hierarchies are bad for cooperation even as B: you declare that the largest hierarchy in the world, "government", is better at solving social problems than distributed non-hierarchical networks? I don't know, because you, mozumder, personally didn't say, but I rather suspect there's a lot of people here holding both those beliefs simultaneously without noticing the profound philosophical conflicts they have.
- randallsquared 11y ago> I honestly don't even know which side it is that you think is "far more effective" at solving social problems. ...and I really hope that it was intentional. :)
- mozumder 11y agoHave you read about the corrosive effects of welfare on black communities? No. I have read about welfare reducing poverty. I'm sure you have, too. Have you ever joined in complaining about the inability of public school systems to successfully adapt and harness changing technologies? No. I have read about public schools outperforming private charter schools. Have you noticed that our biggest social problems just "happen" to also be located right where Democratic policies were enacted (i.e., the policies preceded the social degradation)? No. I have read about liberal policies solving social problems, as usual. All of these things are certainly at least debatable, but they are also certainly not so obviously false that they can simply be discarded without consideration. Why not? I just discarded them without consideration, and you can, too. The question isn't whether or not liberal policies solve problems far more effectively than Republican policies. The question is how quickly you will accept that truth.
- bobby_9x 11y ago"No. I have read about welfare reducing poverty. I'm sure you have, too." Only in the short-term. In the long-term, it creates generations of people completely dependent on the government, never really getting the chance to get themselves out of poverty. All of my extended family are like this. They don't work because the government gives them enough to live. "No. I have read about public schools outperforming private charter schools." Where is the proof of this? In my area, the public schools are terrible. It sickens me that I have to pay taxes to support them when they just continue to spiral downward. It's also impossible to get rid of bad teachers, because whenever some sort of solution is suggested (for measuring effectiveness), the unions come back and say it isn't possible. "The question isn't whether or not liberal policies solve problems far more effectively than Republican policies. The question is how quickly you will accept that truth" Most liberal solutions that I've seen leave out human nature and a history of complete failure and re-dress it as something 'new'.
- mozumder 11y agoit creates generations of people completely dependent on the government Where are these magical people that aren't dependent on government? Are you one of those? How do you travel? Do you build your own roads? What do you do for mail? Do you use UPS for all mail, and they use their own roads? Did your employees learn literacy from private schools? Or did government teach them? How did they learn to follow work instructions? I would like to find these magical people that aren't dependent on government. They sound like they are awesome people. Maybe they also have guns to defend themselves from invading armies, and have fire-proof houses? You are dependent on government. You can ignore your ego that actively harms you by telling you that you aren't dependent on government. The quicker you learn this, the better off you will be.
- kazinator 11y agoIn defense of grandparent, let me point out that you ignored the adverb "completely". There is "dependent on government" and then there is "completely dependent on government".