4 ms·
I think the title should be updated a bit here. When I read "drone nearly hits" I imagined it flying by and getting to close on the way passed. The video shows
by dspillett 11y ago
I think the title should be updated a bit here. When I read "drone nearly hits" I imagined it flying by and getting to close on the way passed. The video shows it crashing to the ground with some force. It isn't clear whether this is under its own power (so an issue in directional control by either a pilot error or equipment fault) or due to loss of power (so it hit the ground due to gravity). Either way it could have done the skier quite some damage if it had been just that little bit closer.
- Piskvorrr 11y agoThe drone in the video seems to be flying like a brick; complete engine shutdown, IMNSHO. If any of the four rotors were operating, the vector would be significantly different. As to why "it's raining drones, hallelujah" - too early for that; I very much doubt there's enough of a data recorder to reconstruct the event, even with a commercial-grade drone.
- asynchronous13 11y ago> I very much doubt there's enough of a data recorder to reconstruct the event, even with a commercial-grade drone. Why do you think that? It's very easy to record telemetry data on even hobby level devices. In fact, it's pretty standard if someone uses a ground station. I'd be surprised if a commercial grade drone didn't have that capability.
- michaelt 11y agoIn an airliner's black box, there's enough redundancy to keep logging (and tell what happened) even if the main power fails, or the radio link fails, or the main processors' software crashes. I've never seen a drone with data recording that sophisticated.
- matheweis 11y agoIt gets pretty close; 3DRs SOLO streams "black box data" to the transmitter in addition to logging it onboard the drone, so you get data up to the moment of incident even if the transmitter link fails. It also has a fail safe processor in the hardware that the community is adding I/O functionality to for just this purpose.
- Piskvorrr 11y agoI'm pretty sure it was capable of this; I just don't think many units have this enabled and running, as opposed to the always-on recorders mandated for commercial aviation.
- matheweis 11y agoDepends on the drone... The Pixhawk controller (that many of us from the RC / tech community use) can record so much data that it can be overwhelming. The commercial 3D Robotics SOLO uses an updated version of the same controller, and has such data logging enabled continuously. In fact, it -also- streams it continuously to its controller unit; even if you lose the drone there will be enough data in the controller to figure out what happened. 3DR uses that to back their flyaway warranty (if a SOLO flys away or crashes due to a software/hardware fault vs user error, 3DR will replace the entire thing free) (I'm not affiliated with 3DR other than owning a Pixhawk.)
- notwhereyouare 11y agoin the video, the skier mentions that he felt something and just kept on going. so, it very well might have hit him
- vermontdevil 11y agoPerhaps 'crashes near skier' ?
- lucb1e 11y ago> Either way it could have done the skier quite some damage Not either way. If it was the pilot's mistake then yes, but if power was lost then the blades would not have had much force anymore. They can cause very serious cuts when propelled, but half a second after losing power they hardly have any momentum left. Tripping the skier over would likely have been the worst of it, if a loss of power was the case. Either way, safeguards may be necessary when flying so close to fragile objects...
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y agoHe was taking part in a slalom race. These guys hit ridiculous speeds. "Tripping the skier over" could have had absolutely disastrous consequences.
- alkonaut 11y agoSlalom is fast-ish but not ridiculous like downhill. Falling in slalom is common and even for crazy falls it rarely leads to major injuries. Compare that to downhill where falling often causes serious injuries. If this had been a downhill race it would have been a near-letal accident. Still, hitting the "solid" bit of the drone (camera, battery), which is probably over 1kg for this type of pro footage, the skier would definitely have been injured.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoA drone like this that has lost power is essentially a flying brick. If you get hit by a brick, you generally suffer damage. Add to that the fact that the guy had accumulated some serious momentum, and getting hit by this drone could easily turn into career-ending, or even life-ending injury.
- bhickey 11y agoFrom /r/multicopter: https://www.reddit.com/r/Multicopter/comments/3xvrdh/drone_crash_on_live_tv_at_ski_world_cup_italy/cy8m32v https://www.reddit.com/r/Multicopter/comments/3xvrdh/drone_c... The folks over there think it looks like the drone inverted and crashed into the ground under power.