4 ms·
> he made content available when the producers wouldn't Yeah, that's called theft. The "producers" are the guys (or organizations) that paid their money to hav
by golergka 11y ago
> he made content available when the producers wouldn't
Yeah, that's called theft. The "producers" are the guys (or organizations) that paid their money to have these TV shows shot, you know. If they wanted to, they could sell only one copy of their shows at all, like Wu Tang. Or just show us the trailers, make everyone want them, and never release them, just for the laughs.
- coldpie 11y agoNo it isn't. It's called copyright infringement.
- norswap 11y agoThat's certainly the legal doctrine. Personally, I don't happen to agree with it.
- golergka 11y agoHow? I honestly don't understand how a person in the same ethical framework could disagree with this, if he fully understands the situation.
- effie 11y agoEthic and morality judgement is very subjective endeavour with inconsistent results across the population. In other words, most people do not exist in "the same ethical framework". The justice framework used by judges is perhaps more consistent, but not necessarily better than other competitive view for any case in hand. Sometimes the very laws are very immoral.
- wfo 11y agoHere's one way: once you release something publicly enough it becomes part of our culture. You don't own our culture, any part of it, even if you created some of the art in it. Your work lives in a context surrounded by other works you did not create, and could only have been created as a response to them. That's how art works. So while you have some rights to it, you don't have absolute and complete rights to determine what happens to it after release; it belongs primarily to society now, with a respectful nod towards you. People are free to talk about it, watch it, look at it, listen to it, learn from it in ways you never imagined. And you won't get paid for all of them. Welcome to creating art.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Yeah, that's called theft. Only by loose metaphor; its actually properly called "copyright infringement", which is more analogous to trespass to chattels than to theft, or even conversion (though it obviously differs from either in that copyrights are intangible personal property, and the others deal with tangible personal property.)