9 ms·
Software error releases up to 3,200 inmates early
- orange_county 11y agoThis is a great example of the government being inefficient at getting things done. However in this case, this ended up saving tax payers money by having inmates released early. "Early estimates indicate the offenders were released from prison an average 55 days before their correct release dates, according to Inslee’s general counsel, Nicholas Brown."
- blfr 11y agoHowever in this case, this ended up saving tax payers money by having inmates released early. I hear this a bit but it doesn't seem include the cost of having criminals in the streets. At least some of them will re-offend and the sooner they're released, the younger they will be, the likelier it is that they will. With a few months across 3500 people, it can add up. Even if they commit a crime which you believe shouldn't be a crime (some drug offence), they will consume a lot of resources while going through the legal system again. Not to mention the legal mess this bug created that will need to be sorted out now. Highly doubtful that there were any savings here. Knowing the government operations, you'll end up paying even more.
- memonkey 11y agoPerhaps a valid concern but is it also possible that the cost and percentage of re offenders is lower than the cost of keeping all of them in jail?
- hellofunk 11y agoThat's quite a pessimistic view. But if you genuinely believe some will in fact commit crime again and therefore add costs to the legal system, would those costs still be more than the taxpayer cost of room and board in a prison for 2 months? And if, say, 10% were repeat offenders, how does this factor into the true "costs" of the legal system dealing with them, vs. the 90% who saved taxes by getting released early? I think you'd be surprised just how much of a tax burden keeping people in prison truly is. And I think for many crimes, the odds of one of these released inmates committing crime again is much lower than you suggest. And even if they do commit a crime, that 55 days early release is going to make much difference.
- DanBC 11y ago> And if, say, 10% were repeat offenders http://www.bjs.gov/content/reentry/recidivism.cfm http://www.bjs.gov/content/reentry/recidivism.cfm > > The most recent BJS recidivism study estimated the recidivism patterns of about 400,000 persons released from state prisons in 30 states in 2005. [...] > > In a 15 State study, over two-thirds of released prisoners were rearrested within three years US prisons don't work.
- Uhhrrr 11y agoThey work great - very few non-released prisoners were rearrested within that three year period.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI want to read the story of those non-released prisoners who were rearrested.
- DanBC 11y agohttp://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2012/02/prisons-and-crime http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2012/02/pr...
- DanBC 11y agoI'm a bit confused about the downvotes for this comment. Parent wants to know about people in prison being arrested. I provide a link that gives information about the crimes committed by people in prison. > Uncounted in the official tallies are the hundreds of thousands of crimes that take place in the country's prison system, a vast and growing residential network whose forsaken tenants increasingly bear the brunt of America's propensity for anger and violence.
- DanBC 11y agoHo ho, but you forget that some prisoners continue to commit crime while in prison. The US doesn't bother to collect accurate statistics on that - they've only just last year started gathering data on rape inside prison.
- s_q_b 11y agoI'm beginning to think we should entirely abolish the punishment motivation in the criminal justice system. It negatively affects recidivism rates, creates a huge societal cost, and really serves no purpose other than vengeance for the victim. There are many excellent aspects of United States (and other British common law descendants) law, but they were created without the psychological understanding we now have of the factors that lead to crime. The current tripartite understanding of the reasons for prison sentences (punishment, deterrence, and removal from society) is simply not an accurate reflection of the reality of how to reduce criminal activity. Sure, there are some people that we need to just remove from society. However, these individuals who have truly incurably pathological tendencies toward illegal actions are relatively rare. The true purpose of the prison system needs to be reform. We need an evidence-based approach to crime prevention, not one based on human instinct, or the haphazard trial and error algorithm that developed our current legal system. Criminals need to be treated for mental illness, withdrawn from substance abuse, and most importantly given the socioeconomic tools they need to cope as law abiding citizens. Anything else is a waste of resources.
- blfr 11y agoExcept we have no idea how to "reform" people. Even various pre-K programs return dismal results when tried at any significant scale. And these are impressionable kids, not hardened criminals. Perhaps not coincidentally, we also have a rather poor track record of helping mental patients. You could attribute some of it to mistreatment and maltreatment but largely we just don't know what to do.
- s_q_b 11y agoAbsolutely. But the goal needs to be reform. We have some idea of how to approach it (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, mandatory real time drug and alcohol monitoring, psychotropics such as antipsychotics, employable skillsets, stable housing, stable income, anger management, etc.) We don't entirely know what to do yet, but I bet we could get a lot better at reform if that's where we focused our efforts, rather than attributing all crime to moral failing.
- nfoz 11y ago> This is a great example of the government being inefficient at getting things done. I don't see any reason that "being government" had anything to do with this category of error. I'm also not sure that "inefficient" describes the problem.
- V-2 11y agoI don't know whether this was the case here, but in general governments are more likely (in compare to private entities) to award contracts to incompetent contractors. Case in point: http://inside-poland.com/t/polands-election-software-open-to-hackers/ http://inside-poland.com/t/polands-election-software-open-to... Basically, with state bureaucracies and government procurements - politics, various forms of corruption and other non-merithorical factors can often affect the outcome. Because it's taxpayer's money that's getting spent.
- jakub_g 11y agoI'd argue that often it's also like this: 1) incompetence => ill-defined requirements; 2) being afraid of corruption accusations if non-cheapest option wins => cheapest offer wins if it matches the ill-defined spec, regardless of any other factors. The "cheapest offer wins" is (IMO) in general not how private companies work, but very often how governmental bodies work. The clerks have nothing to gain for choosing the right option, but potentially a lot to lose.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> The "cheapest offer wins" is (IMO) in general not how private companies work. I'd disagree with that assessment - "cheapest offer wins" is pretty much the way private companies work as well any time they can get away with it. See: procurement in any mid-to-large company, or the whole stereotype of "made in China = sucks" when it's not the fault of Chinese factories, but of companies that want to pay as little as possible for manufacturing (if they'd pay for quality production, they'd get quality products even from China). Private companies can be as inefficient as public institutions, but it isn't talked about since they're usually wasting just their own (and their customers') money.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoIf the government instead had outsourced this system to a private contractor, who subsequently made the same mistake, would you still blame government?
- V-2 11y agoPossibly. Public procurement should always be under close scrutiny, as for who got the contract and why.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoUnfortunately, it's the same public scrutiny that makes public procurement not work in the first place. It prevents corrupt people choosing based on personal interest, but it also prevents people who know their stuff from cutting through marketing bullshit and buying a solution that works, instead of the cheapest one. I don't see a good solution.
- ArtDev 11y agoIf you think government is inefficient, you have never seen a large corporation from the inside :) Most prisons are privitized in the US but this sounds like not in this case.
- icebraining 11y agoMost prisons are privitized in the US I know this sounds true from the rhetoric around them, but they actually only house 6% and 16% of state and federal prisoners, respectively. https://www.aclu.org/issues/mass-incarceration/privatization-criminal-justice/private-prisons https://www.aclu.org/issues/mass-incarceration/privatization...
- coldtea 11y ago>This is a great example of the government being inefficient at getting things done. No more than any example of private companies screwing up (which they do a lot, sometimes with thousands of deaths too) being an example of the private sector being inefficient at getting things done.
- dclowd9901 11y agoI'd like to be lazy and call this a core-competency issue, but you'd think if anything would get a corrections office to back some software work, it'd be the possibility of erroneously releasing inmates. I really have no explanation for this aside from simple negligent stupidity.
- tajen 11y agoA rounding error on the release date isn't the most sensitive mistake if inmates have already done most of their time (and crime relapse is only probable because prison and reinsertion programs aren't working). Scheduling cells and inmates, tracking security cards, tracking prison risks are much more risky, they can lead to a revolt, guard assasination, etc.
- ohthehugemanate 11y agoWhat?! Washington, get with the program here! We're supposed to be the country with the longest sentences and highest prison population in the world. This 55 days early thing is wrecking it for everyone!
- asuffield 11y ago"the [...] developer needed to make the change had been on leave between February and September" Wow. Just wow.
- paublyrne 11y agoPerhaps his holiday time had been miscalculated due to a glitch in the system.
- limeyx 11y agoOr perhaps he/she worked on the holiday time calculator code too :)
- Fjolsvith 11y agoYour comment reminded me of a funny thing. I did a couple years in the Alaskan prison system. The prison I was in served two tacos every Wednesday for lunch. I worked in the computer lab, and as a lark, I wrote a cute program where an inmate could input their projected release date, and the program would tell them how many tacos they had left before their release. Years later, after my release, I learned that the department of corrections had been sued by an inmate who alleged their "Taco Time Calculator" had miscalculated his sentence.
- kzrdude 11y agoParental leave?
- jakub_g 11y agoI think the OP didn't mean the guy's leave length, but a bus factor = 1 of the project
- asuffield 11y agoAny or all of the above. If you find yourself making the statement "we couldn't fix your bug because the developer was on leave for six months" then there is something mind-bendingly wrong with your world. Six months is enough time to hire another developer to fix the bug (even if it's a temp because they're coming back). You don't just... leave it broken for six months. Well, apparently you do.
- danso 11y agoReminds me of a great newspaper investigation in Nebraska a few years back. A journalist heard a story of an inmate who got released significantly early and so he and a data reporter scraped the prisons web site and, by doing simple math based on the scraped fields, found that hundreds of inmates had been wrongly scheduled...it wasn't quite just a software error, but a too simplified formula that someone stuck in the system and apparently no one bothered to double check things http://www.omaha.com/news/metro/world-herald-special-investigation-nebraska-prison-doors-open-too-soon/article_47089734-a15e-5de2-8873-4db298af81c3.html?mode=jqm http://www.omaha.com/news/metro/world-herald-special-investi...
- backtoyoujim 11y agoThe film _Brazil_ escaped from its script. It is taking over the world.
- V-2 11y agoThat sounds like a bug that should be fairly easy to catch out. If you don't write unit tests, you're going to have a bad time (or duplicate amounts of "good time" as in this case).
- kodablah 11y agoThis could be a classic example of why unit tests (or at least striving for coverage alone and not functionality) is not good enough. What the pseudo code might have looked like: def getReleaseDate() = getStartDate() + (getTotalSentencedDays() * getGoodBehaviorCoefficient()) And say all of those functions were covered 100%, then they get the new state supreme court decision changing the contents of "getTotalSentencedDays" and even wrote new tests to make sure it included the "enhancements" and what not. Coverage 100%, unit tests appear to be in order, all done. There was no "testGetReleaseDateWithGoodBehaviorNotAppliedToEnhancements". Hard to catch this stuff when you are close to the code.
- V-2 11y agoI agree, although as you said, I'd see it as an example of coverage vs. functionality. Still, if I were to bet, I would put my money on that they had no test suite at all : ) It's a gamble, but I think my chances would be favorable : )
- snarfy 11y agoGovernment code? Most likely contractors wrote it. The last time I was a contractor working on government code it was a two week process to change the title of a window. Yeah, no test suite at all.
- cmiles74 11y agoI think it may be unreasonable to assume that the requirement passed to the developer was clear and correct. The unit test is itself predicated on the belief that the requirement is clear and correct and, in my experience, this very often is not the case. IMHO, many administrators or managers lack a strong math background and may find themselves writing requirements that involved fairly complicated arithmetic in narrative form, thus introducing considerable "gray error" and potential error. I've seen it many times in my own work.
- jeremycole 11y ago"Inslee said the state is working to locate offenders released early who need to complete their sentences. Five have been returned to prison, according to Brown." What can this possibly accomplish? Presumably these people were released, probably had no idea they were released early, and now have potentially settled into their life again. Returning them to prison can only do more harm than letting it go, and seems more spite than justice.
- lvs 11y agoSeems cruel and unusual to me.
- goldenkey 11y agoEspecially considering the average computational error was 55 days. Seems to me that this whole thing is just another bureaucrats revenge. Get those TPS reports...
- mrweasel 11y ago>Especially considering the average computational error was 55 days. Add to that, that the problem existed for 13 years. I would say that it's a non-issue, barely worth fixing. The persons that have been release earlier are prisoners that have shown good behavior, so I doubt that it will any more dangerous, despite the circumstances for their crime. The law seems a little buggy to me though. Why does it even make sense that you can earn "good time", but only towards a portion of your sentence and not the whole thing? If you don't want people to get out to early just specify a minimum time that must be served.
- mingus68040 11y ago"Along with concerns about public safety..." This was the most amusing part of the article--to think that prison can actually make someone "safer" to their community such that releasing them a few days before the end of their sentence actually constitutes a risk.
- said 11y ago
- yannk 11y agoThat's a lot of savings for the state.
- ginko 11y ago3,200 inmates being released on average 55 days earlier with (what I found looking this up[1]) the daily cost to house inmates being $129, that would amount to about $22.7 million of savings. [1] http://www.ehow.com/about_5409377_average-cost-house-inmates-prison.html http://www.ehow.com/about_5409377_average-cost-house-inmates...
- trbvm2 11y agoOn the other hand, that is 22.7 million dollars in lost revenue for the company/companies running Washington's prisons. When viewed from that perspective, the move to recapture those released early makes a bit more sense intuitively.
- veidr 11y agoACHIEVEMENT UNLOCKED
- heisenbit 11y agoIt is worth keeping in mind that the US has a considerably higher proportion of her population behind bars than others. Mandatory sentencing rules have lead to escalating prison terms. Neither do mechanical sentencing rules make a country safe nor does double counting of good time make a country unsafe.
- unindented 11y agoIt looks like blaming the software and its developers is becoming an easy way of evading responsibilities for those in charge. Volkswagen did a similar thing a couple of months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10710354 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10710354
- TheCapn 11y agoI imagine we'll see more of it as time goes on. Management without a technical background depend on the expertise of their workers to get things right. They can only manage work so far but if there's bugs they can't understand or don't know how to find root cause of they'll have to point the finger eventually. Besides, if a whole industry of software devs are going to insist on calling themselves engineers I hope they adopt the ethics and responsibility other engineers are required to undertake.
- CaptSpify 11y ago> Besides, if a whole industry of software devs are going to insist on calling themselves engineers I hope they adopt the ethics and responsibility other engineers are required to undertake. What ethics and responsibilities do non-software engineers have that software engineers don't have?
- stevenbedrick 11y agoIn many countries, certain kinds of engineering are licensed and regulated professions. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_and_licensure_in_engineering#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_and_licensure_in_en... It's officially a Big Deal in some branches of engineering- structural, mechanical, and civil come to mind. My city just built a new bridge over our river, and the engineers who signed off on its design and construction were doing so under a certain legal framework that is designed to ensure that the design was done using proper methodologies, appropriate tests were conducted, etc. If the bridge fails due to shoddy design, those engineers will personally face certain professional and legal consequences. That same legal and regulatory framework gives the engineers certain protections should management try and make them cut corners on the design or testing (in theory, anyway). People have been debating for years about whether there ought to be a similar legal framework for software engineering. There are plenty of good arguments on both sides of that discussion, IMHO, but the sorts of situation described by the original article would fall squarely under the "pro" side of the equation. I can easily envision a world in which, for software that is critical to a public safety function of government, states had to buy software written by bonded and licensed engineers. Presumably, under such a framework, a licensed software engineering company would have to have a system in place such that their "hit by a bus factor" would be >1- i.e., they'd need to have sufficient documentation or process in place to enable any single engineer to go on extended leave without preventing critical bug-fixes from taking place. This is obviously something that any developer would recognize as a "best practice", but that in practice is often infeasible due to organizational constraints. The advantage to a system of regulation and licensure would (in theory) be that it would empower engineers to demand such practices be in place in their organizations, and would incentivize companies to set themselves up to enable such practices. In theory. As the saying goes, "in theory, there's no difference between theory and practice." Hence why this has been an ongoing debate in the software world for decades.
- asab 11y agoThis is why you should write tests.
- coderjames 11y agoMaybe they were running the sentence software on those new Rockchip SoCs with the long Novembers :-)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- stygiansonic 11y agoFrom the timeline of the events, linked to from the article: http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/doc-timeline/ http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/doc-timeline/ Nov. 3-6: Feuer meets with the IT application manager to discuss the calculation request. Feuer is told a coding fix is scheduled for Jan. 7, 2016, and is informed that the contractual coding developer needed to make the change had been on leave from February to September. Seems to be a classic case of the "bus factor" [1] being too low, in this case, only 1. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_factor
- heraclez 11y agoElliott Alderson is that you
- tcfunk 11y ago“When I learned of this I ordered DOC to fix this, fix it fast, and fix it right.” Fast and right, it turns out, don't always agree with each other.
- 15155 11y agoFast and right can be had, it just won't be cheap.