4 ms·
And that is, what I think is Rossi's biggest problem. Very showy, very secretive. The explanation I've heard is that he has something which works (for some def
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
And that is, what I think is Rossi's biggest problem. Very showy, very secretive.
The explanation I've heard is that he has something which works (for some definition of works) but doesn't know how it works or why. And because of that he is walking around afraid that if too many details get out about how it works then someone smarter then him will jump in and patent/publish the why and then be forever known as the person who "invented" this technology.
I don't know if that is true, but listening to Rossi talk and what he has written it seems like it could be true.
But elephant in the room is that if you can produce a MW of usable energy out of this thing then why not run it 24/7 and generate your quarter million a year in revenue (pretty much any market will buy baseload power at $30/MWhr. Use your first quarter million to build another one in year two, then use the half million from year two to build two more for year 3 and use the million dollars you get in year 3 to build four more, and the two million dollars from year 3 to build 8 more. Etc. Easy to sell shares in a company that is doubling in revenue each year and will continue to do so until it reaches 25% of baseload power (1TW or about a billion a year in revenue).
Either way, the way in which Rossi's e-cat story is playing out it screams hoax not breakthrough. That has nothing to do with the "reputation" of cold fusion and everything to do with the difference between seeing breakthroughs get promoted and hoaxes get promoted.
- marshray 11y agoAnother possible explanation is: He is really not very good at measuring energy input and heat output. He built something and confused himself into thinking it was producing more energy than it consumes. He took some money from investors to develop the technology. He spent much of the research money, eventually to realize that his device does not, in fact, produce energy. His investors now want their money back and he is concerned they are going to break his legs. So at this point he has no choice but to maintain his original claims for as long as possible. Appearing now to be bumbling and incompetent may be preferable to appearing accurate and precise with measurements.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoA reasonable guess, the only counter factual is that a number of people who are not fools seem to have convinced themselves that there is something there but they don't know what. And as the article points out there are a number of labs around the world that have independently seen results that were anomalous with respect to the current understanding of how things should work chemically. So if nothing else there is a really good parlor trick in there somewhere, but even tricks need an explanation.
- marshray 11y agoIt's very common for people who are totally not fools to get sucked into free energy scams. This is one of the better ones being demonstrated at the technical univeristy of Delft I believe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHW6b1aFPfU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHW6b1aFPfU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKCEceWs-Gc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKCEceWs-Gc
- skrebbel 11y agonice. how did it play out? has it been debunked?
- marshray 11y agoThis site has a lot of information http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Muammer_Yildiz_Magnet_Motor http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Muammer_Yildiz_Magnet... There was some sort of plan in the works to have a model undergo a 30 day examination at a major European university. But (surprise surprise) there's no information to suggest that ever happened. Another experimenter tried to replicate the device from the patent without success. http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Muammer_Yildiz_Magnet_Motor#Replication_Attempts http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Muammer_Yildiz_Magnet... Yildiz got involved in some sort of legal dust-up in Germany: http://pesn.com/2013/01/09/9602262_Yildiz_Tells_the_Story_About_His_Magnet_Motor/ http://pesn.com/2013/01/09/9602262_Yildiz_Tells_the_Story_Ab... As of May 2015 they were said to be preparing a "sales launch" and licensing distributors: http://pesn.com//2015/05/05/9602616_Yildiz-preparing-for-sales-launch/ http://pesn.com//2015/05/05/9602616_Yildiz-preparing-for-sal...
- disbelief 11y agoThe article mentions two independent groups of physicists who both had access to his device and both reported the same results. That would mean that both groups were in on it, or he's become so good at faking his results that they withstand a month of scrutiny.
- mcguire 11y agoOr that they have screwed up themselves somehow. In '89, there were several labs which claimed to replicate P&F's results, too. They were eventually found to have calorimetric or similar problems.
- ars 11y ago> He is really not very good at measuring energy input and heat output. Calorimetry is actually extremely hard to do right. VERY hard. I stopped following this field a few years ago, but back then EVERY single positive result was due to faulty calorimetry.
- Gibbon1 11y agoJust temperature measurement is hard once you start talking accuracy better than a few tenths of a degree C. Add in heat flow, yeah whatever.
- htns 11y agoLubos Motl called out the specifics of the Energy Catalyzer hoax some years ago. I think it had to do with neglecting hydrostatic pressure within the water pipes, which allowed steam to get in.
- raverbashing 11y agoTrue, to claim you are able to produce 1 megawatt of power you actually have to put it somewhere.
- j1o1h1n 11y agoYou could generate bitcoins.
- ars 11y ago> The explanation I've heard is that he has something which works (for some definition of works) but doesn't know how it works or why. This happened to someone - one batch worked, one did not. Turns out that palladium can be refined from spent nuclear fuel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthesis_of_precious_metals#Palladium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthesis_of_precious_metals#P... and his first batch was "contaminated" in this way, and worked. His second batch was traditional mined from the ground and did not work. Caveat: This is a story I heard, I have no direct evidence for it.
- PepeGomez 11y ago>But elephant in the room is that if you can produce a MW of usable energy out of this thing then why not run it 24/7 and generate your quarter million a year in revenue I guess the fundamental problem could be that while it does produce excess heat, it doesn't produce more than a heat pump would, so you can't actually use it for anything useful.