3 ms·
The anecdata that tau is helpful to learners is, IMHO, pretty strong at this point. Facts beat theory. And since anecdata is all we have, well, it's all we can
by jerf 11y ago
The anecdata that tau is helpful to learners is, IMHO, pretty strong at this point. Facts beat theory. And since anecdata is all we have, well, it's all we can use to talk about.
I think it's way, way too easy for people on the terminal end of education to forget just how easy it is to get tripped up by very, very little things. Especially if they were themselves "good at math" and really aren't bothered by extra factors of 2 flying around. This is not the normal experience.
- jeffwass 11y agoWhen someone says 90 degree angle, does that confuse you?
- jerf 11y agoAs it happens, I've tutored people in the middle of high school geometry. Radians confuse them. Full stop. If there is something that can make it easier to understand, while at the same time sacrificing absolutely nothing of mathematical consequence, it's a good thing. What confuses me is not the relevant issue. I've got $BOATLOADS of higher ed. I'm not the interesting case.
- jeffwass 11y agoOk, we're far away from my original point which was only on using tau in one website. My actual only personal argument against Tao as Hartl proposed it is the use of a standard Greek letter. Really would have preferred he picked something that was more "backwards compatible", exactly as physicists did with hbar. If you're for reducing confusion, do you think adding a new fundamental constant to the body of mathematics that is a Greek letter already used for countless other variables in history, will this cause confusion between old and new mathematical science texts and papers? Asking students of science for any texts and papers they read whether tau is 2pi or some other variable, and keeping track across them, seems more confusing to me than just consistently using pi and extra factors of 2.
- hugs 11y agoYou have a valid complaint about reusing a letter that already had meaning in other contexts. He does address that in the manifesto, though.
- hugs 11y ago"90 degrees" is not confusing to me in the same way that measurements in feet and miles is not confusing. I was raised in a system that emphasized degrees, feet, and miles (USA). But in engineering, metric is the standard/default system of measurement. And in software libraries (e.g. JavaScript's Math built-in lib) or many calculators, the default is radians, not degrees. So even though degrees is more natural for me, it was worthwhile to get a deeper understanding of radians. The Tau Manifesto got me there. (90 degrees is 1/4 turn around a circle, which happens to be expressed as 1/4*tau -- and I didn't even have to look that up!)
- coldtea 11y ago>Facts beat theory. Not necessarily. Facts (in the sense of "anecdata") are simple observations. The only make any sense against or in favor of something when we combine them with a theory why it is so. OK, students faring better on exams when they are taught with tau is an argument in favor of tau only if we theorize (assume) that it was the tau/pi thing that made the difference. Whereas it could just be that the second group of students was just better naturally (e.g. a good school vs a mediocre one), or just a chance outcome, due to the small sample we picked, or the teacher going for tau was also better at explaining and would have fared just as good if he also was the one to teach the pi group.
- jerf 11y agoIt is one of the great errors of the "SCIENCE!" attitude that it convinces people that if we do not have peer-reviewed papers, we must necessarily claim full and total ignorance and berate anybody who attempts to do otherwise. I'm not obligated to stop using my brain just because we have no SCIENCE! papers to work with. In fact, you can't. You have no choice. You must do your best with the data you have, because we do not have "science" for all the questions we encounter every day. Given how standardized education is nowadays, as I complained in another comment, it isn't exactly a far-out theory that when the same person, in the same context, switches to using tau, and sees a difference in results, that it may have something to do with using the more mathematically-sensible concept for teaching.
- jkire 11y ago> It is one of the great errors of the "SCIENCE!" attitude that it convinces people that if we do not have peer-reviewed papers, we must necessarily claim full and total ignorance and berate anybody who attempts to do otherwise. In fact, I think quite the opposite. Its one of the great errors that people assume peer-reviewed papers are always correct, a lot of the time they're not. We should be sceptical of people's claims when not supported by evidence. That doesn't mean we should ignore said claims, just that we shouldn't blindly accept them. This is the point where we should go and get some evidence, try to get a few teachers to use tau from the beginning and see if that helps. Though I do agree that we shouldn't be scared of doing things just because we don't categorically know that it is right. > Given how standardized education is nowadays, as I complained in another comment, it isn't exactly a far-out theory that when the same person, in the same context, switches to using tau, and sees a difference in results, that it may have something to do with using the more mathematically-sensible concept for teaching. Or thinking about the same concept in different ways help you to understand the concept better. Its certainly something I believe has helped me a lot previously.
- mrcsparker 11y agoI just read the Tao Manifesto and - while I was skeptical at first - I have to agree that it is much easier. Note that this is just my opinion, but I have kids and this gives me an alternative viewpoint when they have questions. I wonder what my more math oriented friends will think about Tau
- jeffwass 11y agoOf course the right constant historically should have been 6.28... And not 3.14... Nobody's disputing that (or at least I'm not). The question is whether you improve things by abandoning a universal standard with hundreds of years of support, momentum, and ginormous corpus of math/science literature all to save a 'simple' factor of two. My primary gripe with Tau is that its symbolic representation is not "backwards compatible". Ie, Hartl proposed to use yet another Greek letter which is widely used elsewhere in all sorts of formulae and constants, instead of something that would cause far less ambiguity. For example, a new symbol, as physicists did by introducing hbar instead of h (Planck constant in radians instead of cycles).