7 ms·
Wow, "On average, college graduates earn $640,000 more over their lifetimes than nongraduates do." $640k/lifetime is really small.
by wyldfire 11y ago
Wow, "On average, college graduates earn $640,000 more over their lifetimes than nongraduates do." $640k/lifetime is really small.
- twoodfin 11y agoIt's not that small, especially if it's in constant 1987 dollars (unsure of the origin of Bennett's statistic). That $1.3M in 2015 dollars, and over 47 years of (potential) employment from 18-65, it's $27,000/year. Of course, past performance is no indication of future results. And I suspect that this is the kind of statistic where "average" is misleading: Most exceptionally high earners have college degrees.
- doctornemo 11y ago"$640k/lifetime is really small." Pretty fine payout for $30K in debt (which is the current average for the 2/3rds of students who own debt).
- cornholio 11y agoNo doubt, the decision to go to college pays off, when taken on the individual level. However, it's less clear if the higher incomes are caused by the increased productivity afforded by education, or it's merely a signaling effect: productive people go to college to signal to the employer that they are intelligent, hard working, and willing to commit to a career in the field by irreversibly burning years of their lives and future incomes on the hope of penetrating the respective professional field. It's most likely, a combination of both. What critics of the education bubble point out is not that a degree is necessary to earn a good income; but that the onerous costs of modern education have to little to do with the actual productivity gain and useful skills students earn in return. In support of this view we can see how the MOOC revolution failed to produce significant effects on the labor market: it's not that MOOC education is has low value (quite the contrary), it's that is cheap enough that too many people can afford it, negating the signal (or "sheepskin effect" of an expensive degree).
- gertef 11y agowhy are you ignoring the opportunity cost of the down payment?
- staticint 11y ago> Most exceptionally high earners have college degrees. Interestingly though, most exceptionally high earners have post-graduate degrees, according to Gallop[1]. When you exclude that group, the non-college graduates make up the largest portion of the highest earners. If there is causality here, it seems one has to be mindful to continue their studies long enough to see the benefits. Simply getting a degree does not seem to pave the way to a better income. [1] http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Production/Cms/POLL/glqwiblfrkemnu8b6ij8aq.gif http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Prod...
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoFor reference, working 40 years at $30,000 a year will earn you $1.2 million. Earning $640,000, or ~53%, more is certainly substantial. Edit: The $30,000/year reflects current incomes, the $640,000 lifetime difference is based on 1987 dollars, like @twoodfin pointed out. It works out to greater than double lifetime earnings using the adjusted $1.3 million figure.
- maratd 11y ago> For reference, working 40 years at $30,000 a year Why are you using 30K as the baseline? The median per capita income in the US is 56K [1]. 40 years will earn you $2.24 million. Earning $640K or 29% more isn't as substantial as you make it out to be. Let's also factor in 4 years lost income and cost of attending an institution. (4 x 30K (starting salary)) + (4 x 40K (tuition/housing/food at a public university)) = 280K $640K - 280K = 360K 360K is 16% of total earned income. That's not that much. We're also not factoring in interest, assuming you borrowed money to pay for that degree ... and let's not forget I'm quoting prices for a public university while the $640K figure includes some very expensive colleges that might put you in the red. If you're going to attend a university, don't do it for money. That's a really stupid rationale. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_...
- pc86 11y agoThe very page you linked to shows that HS graduates early roughly half what college graduates do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_States#By_educational_attainment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_...
- maratd 11y agoI was using the figure provided by OP. The post has since been edited to note that was an older figure. Using the data on that page, it would be 981K over the lifetime of the worker. Plug that into the formulas above and it's still nowhere near half after all the costs are factored in, although it's a far healthier percentage. One thing that isn't noted though ... there is a fundamental difference between causation and correlation. There is no evidence to suggest colleges add that value. Merely that people who earn more go to college.