6 ms·
"The bad guys" ... An unfortunate choice of words. Who are the bad guys in this situation? The drug traffickers? The militarized police force? The politicia
by rwmj 11y ago
"The bad guys" ... An unfortunate choice of words. Who are the bad guys in this situation? The drug traffickers? The militarized police force? The politicians supporting prohibition? Probably all of them.
- 67726e 11y agoDefinitely the guys who butcher people and leave them in 55 gallon drums. I'm hardly gonna blame the border patrol for doing their job which is guarding the border.
- mitchtbaum 11y ago“The fall of moral civilization has always been brought about by those who were "just doing their jobs".” ― Jeremy Grantham
- 67726e 11y agoCan someone please explain to me what is wrong with the CBP's job? The Nuremberg defense isn't valid, yeah, but what makes that situation apply to folks running defense on the border. Last time I checked we weren't gassing illegal immigrants.
- lbotos 11y agoIt's a stretch: > Smugglers want to get drugs to the lucrative American market. > Border Patrol are told to stop them cause drugs are bad. >Politicians enact more border patrol regulations to counteract our strict drug policy. I'm inferring that OP wants border patrol to be political activists and fight for better drug laws instead of just "doing their jobs".
- 67726e 11y agoI guess, but CBP does more than just deal with just the smuggling of drugs so it's hardly clear that's the point.
- refurb 11y agoThat's kind of a ridiculous quote. Aren't most people "just doing their jobs" every day? That's like saying "The fall of moral civilization has always been brought about by those who "eat food on a regular basis"".
- hobs 11y agoWhat an interesting misinterpretation. Nobody would use "I was just eating food on a regular basis" as a defense against blame for misdeeds, which the GP's quote (referencing the Nuremberg defense and similar things events of disavowing blame for evil acts) would be commenting upon.
- mannykannot 11y agoThe interesting misinterpretation is in the original use of the quote in this thread - it cannot be used to assume anything in general about people who are just doing their jobs. Michtbaum may possibly be able to make the claim that these particular job-doers are a threat to civilization, but not by offering up this quote.
- 91bananas 11y agoStop and think though... It actually isn't that ridiculous. Do you not think we (humans) are contributing to the fall of moral civilization? Look around us. edit: clarity
- throwaway2048 11y agothats actually an interesting examination of the banality of evil in our everyday lives. How much harm do we cause the enviroment by eating the food we eat on a regular basis? How many people are killed and lives and futures destroyed by people that ard perfectly justified in doing their jobs? Evil isn't just for comic book super villians, nor does it require any sort of ill intent at all. Look around at your life, and the choices you and others make and ask (honestly) "who is being hurt", the answers can be suprising and unnerveing.
- dagw 11y agoThe people butchering people and leave them in 55 gallon drums are also "just doing their jobs".
- mc32 11y agoBut those "jobs" aren't backed by a legal framework, in fact, even in their own country it's considered grotesque, even in the same illegal outfits it's known as the dirty work.
- at-fates-hands 11y ago"Those who wish to reap the blessings of freedom, must, like men, undergo the fatigue of supporting it." - Thomas Paine
- kingkawn 11y agoGuarding the border against an import industry that is worth billions of dollars and is illegal because our political system is beholden to retrograde moralizing.
- jahnu 11y agoVote for politicians who aren't. Unfortunately drug lords aren't interested in votes.
- avn2109 11y ago>> "...beholden to retrograde moralizing." I wish that was the only reason for the drug war, but moralizing is probably a relatively minor factor. I claim the bigger reasons are: 1) The prison-industrial complex is large and politically powerful, and it needs drug "criminals" 2) Many recreational drugs make the working populace less productive. They'd be blowing lines of coke and screwing each other all day or giggling at Spongebob after smoking a bowl instead of diligently churning out more boxes at the packing plant. Drugs that make you more productive are perfectly legal and widely prescribed (Adderall etc). 3) Many popular drugs are easily produced at home in quantities appropriate for individual use. You can trivially grow enough weed at home to support a serious habit. The man hates that and prefers drugs that are only amenable to production on a vast industrial scale, such that monopoly, taxation, and centralized control of production are easy. Tobacco and the aforementioned psychostimulants are the ne plus ultra industrial-only drugs; it's no cooincidence that they're quite legal.
- merpnderp 11y agoI'm all for ending the horrible consequences of prohibition, but people often ignore or gloss over that a lot of the war on drugs was requested by poor communities who had to deal with the consequences of high levels of drug use. When you're poor and can't move elsewhere, you turn to the police to get the heroin junkies off your front lawn or out of your apartment complex hallways. Which is too bad because it is really a job for social workers.
- csseinpoont 11y agoSo again, who are the bad guys because all three of those groups are responsible for such activities.
- 67726e 11y agoI'm as critical of my government as any, but please show some sources for a claim as ludicrous as this. The CBP does not go around mutilating corpses of those that they disagree with.
- csseinpoont 11y agohttp://boingboing.net/2015/07/01/us-customs-and-border-protecti.html http://boingboing.net/2015/07/01/us-customs-and-border-prote... Politicians continue to support a war effort which has murdered millions in the ME, they continue to turn a blind eye to torture, and hold the innocent in jails without trial. So yeah, all three groups are about as bad as each other.
- scient 11y agoWhat the hell are you even talking about? How is the police force battling _illegal_ drug traffickers the bad guys here?
- dev1n 11y agoit's common knowledge that legalizing drugs would destroy incomes for gangs, who as we all know are the root of violent crimes. If the gangs don't exist, the violence drops.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoWow - that's quite a leap. Legalize drugs, then the Cartels just say, "Oh, you guys legalized all the drugs were smuggling into your country? I guess we better quit our gang get day jobs now." Just like we saw when marijuana was legalized here, the cartels simply diversified and started smuggling more heroin, coke and meth and less marijuana. Did their violence subside? Nope. Did it really have a huge impact on their business? Hardly.
- dasil003 11y agoThe idea is to legalize and control all drugs. Where will the cartels get their money from?
- DanBC 11y agoSome drugs are still going to be cheaper from the illegal market. Criminal gangs don't pay tax; sometimes use slave labour; don't have the best quality control; etc. See also the amount of counterfeit and smuggled cigarettes in the UK.
- simonh 11y agoTrue but the effect is likely to be fairly small. It's probably better to compare legalization of most drugs to the end of prohibition. That saw a collapse in crime and incarceration rates back towards (although admittedly not all the way down to) pre-prohibition levels which only picked up again with the war on drugs. If you don't trust that comparison, how about looking at the actual real world effects seen recently in Western countries such as Holland and Portugal that have tried this.
- rayiner 11y agoDrug overdose kills more people in the U.S. than car accidents: http://abcnews.go.com/Health/Drugs/drug-deaths-exceed-traffic-deaths/story?id=14554903 http://abcnews.go.com/Health/Drugs/drug-deaths-exceed-traffi.... But the politicians supporting drug control are the bad guys. Right.
- Zikes 11y agoTreating drug addiction as a disease instead of a crime would go a long way towards reducing overdoses and keep otherwise potentially productive members of society out of prison. At the very least, amnesty should be offered for addicts that want treatment.
- rayiner 11y agoBut we're talking about drug traffickers, not drug users. Should that be a disease?
- stronglikedan 11y agoActually, according to your comment above, we're talking about "the politicians supporting drug control". Those same politicians support treating drug addiction as a crime, rather than a disease, thereby placing a stigma on addicts who want to get help. Some addicts that go without the help they need due to this unnecessary stigma are the ones that end up contributing to the overdose statistic that you mentioned. The politicians supporting prohibition are the bad guys, for this and other reasons, such as continuing to waste taxpayer dollars on a failed drug war. The same drug war that feeds the pockets of the drug traffickers. The same drug traffickers that require militarized police forces to fight against. The same militarized police forces that require tax payer dollars to pay for. The same tax payer dollars that could be used to treat addicts and reduce the overdose statistics.
- lmm 11y agoProbably. Many of the low-level dealers make below minimum wage; it would be pretty easy to give them a better options.
- benologist 11y agoThe drug cartels, who also traffic people, child sex slaves, engage in wide-scale murder, and any other form of fear and misery they can convert into $$$. When the drug landscape changes they will continue in all their other endeavors. I read the other week they were even fighting over the rent mining companies pay Mexican towns to mine "conflict free gold".
- debacle 11y ago> traffic people, child sex slaves Mostly the result of outdated laws preventing legal prostitution. By no means do I intend to defend cartels, but if you remove their financial incentive to exist, they will shrink or disappear altogether.
- benologist 11y agoLegalizing prostitution won't disempower them anymore than legalizing drugs will - they will prey on some other group, or the same group, or sell sex slaves alongside legal enterprise, or anything else they think of that can unfairly extract money from society. We could never legalize the full extent of their activities either - murder, extortion, kidnapping, slavery etc. We've had legal brothels in my city (Brisbane, Australia) for decades and Wikipedia's estimating 90% of prostitution there is unregulated or illegal. It just co-exists alongside a legal market. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Australia#Queensland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Australia#Quee...
- csseinpoont 11y agoActually it will, you are wrong. Regulating something so that you may as well make it illegal isn't really the same as decriminalizing the activity. Countries with reasonable prostitution laws are tremendously safer for those turning tricks.
- benologist 11y agoCountries with reasonable prostitution laws are safer for the people working within that legal framework, not the ones coerced into working outside it - I live in Costa Rica where it is also legal but there are still enslaved adults and children coerced into selling sex, Amsterdam has illegal prostitution coexisting alongside women in windows too. That's examples of illicit sex industries alongside legal ones on three different continents. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_the_Netherlands#Human_trafficking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_the_Netherland... But let's say you are right. Prostitution globally is completely legalized and somehow there is no illicit demand for boys and girls, cheaper rates etc. How does that stop the cartels from making money in hundreds of other ways? It is just one line of business, they have plenty more and can always invent new ones.