6 ms·
As a parent of a toddler and a baby, this article bothers me to bits. The author somehow seems to implicitly assumes that being able to read as early as possib
by skrebbel 11y ago
As a parent of a toddler and a baby, this article bothers me to bits.
The author somehow seems to implicitly assumes that being able to read as early as possible is good, period. Younger == better. He has a huge "why" chapter, where he debunks and defends all kinds of criticism he's gotten, but I haven't been able to at all find the section where he simply describes why it's a good idea. Not why it's not not a good idea, that's not good enough. Why would I teach my children to read already?
There might be good reasons, but this author is so consumed with the "it's possible! it's not harmful!" part of things that what should have been the central argument is nearly entirely missing.
I mean, seriously, it's possible and it's not harmful? I can think of a lot of things that are possible and not harmful but still wouldn't do with my kids.
- crististm 11y agoI don't know if it is harmful or not. But I ask another question: How is reading words different from looking at a tree and saying "tree". Or looking at a bird and saying "bird"?
- leppr 11y agoIt's not, but it IS different from looking at a tree and analyzing its bark and leaves, or looking at a bird and wondering why it has feathers instead of fur.
- crististm 11y agoI vaguely remember first encounter with LCD watches when I was probably 10. The same concepts (numbers) seemed strange when presented in LCD font (especially the regularity of 2 and 5). However, adjusting to this form was very quick and after probably less than 24 hours I went from "de-constructing" to pattern recognition through some phase of "pattern acceptance". What I mean is that identifying the parts of the whole through de-construction is not the only way we recognize things.
- tudorw 11y agoReading the word tree could be described as de-constructing the letters that make up the word 't r e e', re-combining them into a whole, 'tree', then recognising the 'sound' and associating with a concept 'tree' then comprehending it's context to give it meaning 'the tree of life', 'it was like climbing a tree', ' the tree was bending'. During early years teaching it's apparently fairly trivial to identify the children who are recognizing shapes over the deconstruction technique, there's a test where they are shown lists of words with nonsense words thrown in, for those recognising shapes, when they see 'strom' they cannot help but unknowingly correct it to 'storm', their brain just fixes it for them, it's close enough and the word 'strom' has probably not been encountered, children implementing the deconstruction technique will have less of a problem. Why teachers care is that it helps them identify children who may have issues identifying letter shapes but can pass other tests by recognising whole words, early diagnosis of dyslexia can have a very positive impact on a child's educational progress.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoInterestingly, when you get proficient at reading, you stop deconstructing words. That is, you can do if you want/need to, e.g. to double-check if that weird pattern you see is a real word at all, but it's not generally what you do - instead, most of the reading is image patter-matching. That's why yuor brian will autocrroect "strom" to "storm" when you're reaidng fast.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoBecause having more skills is good under virtually all circumstances? The child can now read if the desire or need arises, and can choose not to read under other circumstances.
- feider 11y agoReally, more skills the better? I have 3yr old son and I've been reading to him / teaching him to read only as much as he can concentrate while enjoying it. It is really easy to be too pushy and have a child lost interest. The skills does not matter nearly as much as the learning experiences. I rather hope that he grows an interest in learning itself than teach him read under 4 of age and possible hating the experience.
- true_religion 11y agoAll things being equal, wouldn't you say it's better to be able to read than not read? Yes you can create a circumstance where literacy is gained through onerous means, but you can use that same hypothetical with pretty much any form of parental guidance till you get to the point where children are now only learning what they want to and not what is necssary.
- DanBC 11y ago> All things being equal Pretty big assumption there.
- feider 11y agoYes, this touches the point that is overlooked. We are eager to assume that the cost of acquiring a (reading) skill is static and low, involving only time. The way I see this is that for toddlers the added value by hour declines rapidly, so instead of investing more time to teach my child to read properly, I prefer to teach/explore other things such as story telling, cutting shapes with scissors, etc.
- learnetto 11y agoRead the section titled "What is the point?" - http://larrysanger.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/How-and-Why-I-Taught-My-Toddler-to-Read.htm#_Toc279781813 http://larrysanger.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/How-and-Wh... You may disagree with the author's reasons but at least read the whole article before saying that quite a long section is "entirely missing".
- Puts 11y agoI always felt as a child that I had so much curiosity and ability to learn but that I never had anyone around me who saw this. I would have loved to have a parent like this.
- DanBC 11y agoBut there are things you could be learning instead of "how to read" - relationships between things, for example, would probably be more useful. You start with hotter / colder; bigger smaller; and move onto "meat eating" / "plant eating" - look at the big claws, look at where the eyes are.
- aaronem 11y agoYes, but reading is the single skill with the highest payoff, when it comes to learning things that let you learn more things. Why give the kid a fish, if you can teach her how to catch her own? (Again, as in my other comment, I feel it worthwhile to point out that this isn't a purely theoretical discussion for me: I was myself taught to read at age two, and have never been other than glad of it.)
- DanBC 11y ago> but reading is the single skill with the highest payoff, when it comes to learning things that let you learn more things Not when you're two. When you're two you need to learn that asking questions is okay, how to ask questions, and how people answer questions.
- aaronem 11y agoIt takes bad parenting to give a kid that age the impression that asking questions could ever not be okay. As long as that mistake isn't made, the rest follows organically.
- dctoedt 11y ago> Why would I teach my children to read already? To start the "compound interest" benefits as early as possible?
- barry-cotter 11y agoThere are no compound interest benefits to learning to read early. Children who learn to read at 5 and at 7 have indistinguishable reading skills at 11. That's why reading instruction in Finland and Germany begins in grade school, not kindergarten. I regret I've lost the study (observational, not experimental) on students in North Rhine Westphalia on long term effects of early reading instruction but it showed children who learned to read later doing better at 16 or 17 than the ones who learned to read earlier. I think it was published in an economic of education journal but that's all I remember. Edit: The below study shows tiny differences between performance/school readiness of French and German children on entering primary school despite the French system being much more school like and placing a much greater emphasis on reading. Italics in abstract not in original. French nursery schools and German kindergartens: effects of individual and contextual variables on early learning Eur J Psychol Educ (2011) 26:199–213 DOI 10.1007/s10212-010-0043-4 The present article investigates the effects of individual and contextual variables on children’s early learning in French nursery schools and German kindergartens. Our study of 552 children at preschools in France (299 children from French nursery schools) and Germany (253 children from German kindergartens) measured skills that facilitate the learning of reading, writing and arithmetic at primary school. We also evaluated educational family practices and parents’ expectations of their children’s pre-school education. In order to take into account the hierarchical structure of our data, multilevel models were used in the analysis, which was carried out using MLwiN software version 2.02 (Rasbash et al.2005). Although French nursery schools emphasise academic learning, we did not find any significant differences in overall performances between the French and German samples. However, significant differences were obtained for some subscale results. In addition, our results indicate that individual and contextual variables have an impact on the differences observed between children from the two countries.
- isolate 11y agoMaybe that's just on average though. My guess is that when you look at high-IQ groups, learning to read early is better.
- aaronem 11y agoWell, I can't give you a peer-reviewed, n>500, p=0.001 answer, but I can tell you that I've never regretted my mother teaching me to read at age two. Reading has given me a great deal of both pleasure and knowledge throughout my life, and I can't think of a single time I've looked back and said "Gosh, you know, I sure wish Mom had waited three more years to teach me to read, or just left the matter in the hands of the public school system." Of course, that was thirty-odd years ago, before kindergarten-aged kids were expected to be familiar with English lit back to Chaucer and mathematics up to basic trigonometry. I can see how in the modern environment someone might react negatively to the suggestion that it doesn't hurt kids to know how to read when they're two, because letting on about it could well result in an environment where a kid who's three years old and can't yet read is either developmentally delayed or has bad parents, or of course possibly both. Edited to add: It doesn't help at all that the author of the article under discussion couches his reasoning in terms of improved educational outcomes -- he's explicitly trying to turn his kids into highly performant overachievers, and that is super creepy. If that's your only available perspective on the matter, I can't blame you at all for being bothered by it, because I actually was taught to read at age two like he's advocating and it bothers me too. He sounds more like an education researcher than like a father, and that's disturbing. But Mom didn't teach me to read early because she had some kind of n=1 eugenics experiment in mind. She did it because she loved me and thought I'd enjoy being able to read, and she didn't use the rather chilly and vaguely clinical-sounding methods this author describes. As she described it to me not long ago, she'd just read part of a story to me, showing me each word in turn and helping me sound it out and learn its meaning, and offer me as much help as I wanted in figuring the rest out for myself -- which I would, because I wanted to know how the story turned out. Evidently this method worked well enough, and as I said before, I've never regretted it. Make of that what you like, of course.