4 ms·
This is mostly a disappointing response that tries to deflect with "hey, we do good stuff too!" which is a PR move, not an argument against the events which cau
by minimaxir 11y ago
This is mostly a disappointing response that tries to deflect with "hey, we do good stuff too!" which is a PR move, not an argument against the events which caused the accusations against Product Hunt.
The highlighted quote and central thesis of "Everyone’s upvote is equal — my upvote counts the same as yours" misses the point that the product selection process is opaque, and the updated FAQ of "we receive so may products per day!" does not absolve PH of that. (it's a 2 year old startup. They no longer get a pass on scalability issues).
Speaking of the FAQ, here's the update discussing conflicts of interest:
> "Do I need to disclose that I’m invested or advising a company I post to Product Hunt?
Product Hunt is a place for authentic, honest conversation and we highly encourage people to disclose any potential conflict of interest in the comment thread."
...which misses the point entirely. The conflicts-of-interest are with the moderators themselves, and friends-of-friends of the submitters. And given the culture of PH, very few people will disclose a conflict of interest willingly if it hurts them.
I'm not reassured that anything will change in the near future.
EDIT: Added my comment to the comments on the Medium article.
- avinassh 11y ago> the events which caused the accusations against Product Hunt. can you tell me more about this? I do have a PH account, I have hardly used it, so I don't know much.
- tedmiston 11y agoHe's referring to the Medium post from earlier this week: How Product Hunt really works by Ben Wheeler https://medium.com/@benjiwheeler/how-product-hunt-really-works-d8fdcda1da74#.qbcdbg1wj https://medium.com/@benjiwheeler/how-product-hunt-really-wor... I have another post in the comments here that explains the context a bit more as well.