5 ms·
> Plus it seems extra presumptuous to claim some kind of inherent right to profit off derivative works of my software. Who's claiming that? On the other hand,
by eropple 11y ago
> Plus it seems extra presumptuous to claim some kind of inherent right to profit off derivative works of my software.
Who's claiming that? On the other hand, I've met more than a few pro-FSF people who seem to think it's cromulent to claim that I don't have the right to profit off my work (which is insane; you can pick whatever license you'd like, copyleft or not, and so can I).
- Nadya 11y agoYou aren't profiting off your work, you're piggybacking off their work with just enough tweaks to sell it. Go write your own software if you want to profit off your work. Then you won't have to deal with the copyleft licenses because you won't be using anyone else's work. Which is the exact purpose of a copyleft license.
- eropple 11y agoI think you should re-read my post. I don't have a problem with other people choosing to use the GPL, and dealing with its terms or choosing not to use it. I have a problem with the temerity of people like the FSF insisting I use copyleft or I'm somehow immoral.
- the_ancient 11y agoI think you have likely confused what the pro-FSF people say... Likely they said it is unethical for you to distribute software with out access to the code. Which you interpreted to be against profiting since you likely believe that open source == no profit.
- eropple 11y agoI'm well aware of how to make money with open-source software. I do it. I am working to no longer do it, because wage slavery (be it W-2 or under the guise of "consulting") sucks. Turns out that you need capital to do that, and the FSF's insistence that digital bits as capital is immoral is silly.
- simoncion 11y ago> Turns out that you need capital to do that, and the FSF's insistence that digital bits as capital is immoral is silly. Jesus. Read this http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#DoesTheGPLAllowMoney http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#DoesTheGPLAllowM... and this http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html It's a pity that you're so misinformed. :(
- eropple 11y agoThat has nothing to do with what I've said, and I don't think you understand what capital is. The GPL is fundamentally incompatible with the notion of software as a capital asset; when its value as a salable object is effectively zero due to the ease of marginal duplication, one's business model becomes a labor-oriented one, i.e. consulting. Which means burning one's time, which is what one acquires capital assets to avoid doing. But, clearly, I'm so misinformed. I obviously haven't thought this through. I didn't read everything Stallman wrote a decade ago. And I certainly haven't read the GPL (both v2 and v3) line-by-line to understand its ramifications. It's a pity you felt like you needed to be an asshole about this.
- simoncion 11y ago> ...I don't think you understand what capital is. I -uh- do. > The GPL is fundamentally incompatible with the notion of software as a capital asset; when its value as a salable object is effectively zero due to the ease of marginal duplication... Two things 1) That applies to all software. All software -regardless of license- has an effectively-zero duplication cost. 2) You can still sell software distributed under the terms of the GPLv2. You can charge any price you like. Calling me names doesn't change the falsity of your statement, which was: > [T]he FSF... [insists] that [treating] digital bits as capital is immoral[.] This isn't their position. It never was. You seem to think that the only way a thing can be considered capital is if one retains the exclusive rights to control the distribution of the thing. This is an over-narrow definition of capital. :)
- 11y ago