3 ms·
You're partially correct. If you are paying everything off, you will not be rated as high as someone who is carrying a reasonable amount debt every month. Why?
by falcolas 11y ago
You're partially correct. If you are paying everything off, you will not be rated as high as someone who is carrying a reasonable amount debt every month.
Why? If you pay everything off (no interest), the banks make no money, so you're simply not as attractive of a customer to lend money to. So, it's not about the payment, it's about using debt.
Other negatives: Reposession, defaulting on debts, bankruptcy, late payments, having monthly payments over some percentage over your income... it varies by provider (and most of it's automated).
Source: Worked for a 3rd party which does the actual approval and denial calculations for many different providers.
- etjossem 11y agoThis does raise a good point: your goal is not the same as the bank's goal. A terrible credit customer (pays credit cards in full every month, never gets a mortgage or car loan) may be the most financially responsible person they ever see. Keep that in mind when striving for a better score.
- derefr 11y agoIt's not about how much you pay off each month at all. The banks don't calculate credit scores—the credit reporting agencies do. And the credit-reporting agencies don't think that way. The thing about credit event streams is that they're very low-detail: basically they amount to, for each credit instrument you have, a series of {pay-period, code} pairs with nine possible codes, R1-R9. Your score is entirely calculated† by taking (a seven-year sliding window of) those event-codes and applying weights to them. R1, the most-positively-weighted event, just means "paid on time this month." The thing you want to do to build good credit quickly, is to generate as many R1 events as you can. You can carry some of your debt on a card to "stretch" one large charge into multiple R1 events... but a more efficient strategy (that doesn't involve paying any interest) is to simply have several cards, use them all for at least one trifling thing each month, and then pay them all off each month. Three cards you paid off $5 charges on is three R1s, and counts for just as much as one $500 charge you paid in three instalments (also three R1s.) If you want to dig in and see exactly how much information a CRA will give you, here's a Ruby implementation of the Experian Connect API: https://github.com/ehutzelman/experian https://github.com/ehutzelman/experian --- † Well, okay, there's also two other things: 1. a positively-weighted factor for how much unused credit each instrument holds each month. Which usually translates to "you get punished for carrying an 80%+ balance on a credit card." The key with this one is that—all else being equal—it's better to have cards with higher credit limits, because then you're not using as much of each instrument's capacity, and that reflects better on you. 2. a negatively-weighted factor for any "hard inquiries" that the credit-reporting agency had to respond to within some time window. Each time you apply for a credit instrument and the loaning institution asks the reporting agency to calculate your credit score for the purpose of determining credit eligibility, that's a "hard inquiry" event. (You can think of these as their own credit event on a "meta" instrument held by the reporting agency itself.) Unlike normal credit instruments, there are no industry standards on how to set the weights or time-window for the effects of "hard inquiries", but the windows are usually short (~6 months), AFAIK. All else being equal, don't quickly, repeatedly apply for credit: each successive loaning institution will see a lower score. (And note the "for the purpose of determining credit eligibility" bit. There's another kind of event, a "soft inquiry", that happens when you—or some third-party on your behalf—just asks the reporting agency for your credit score in order to know it, or background-check you, or whatever else. I'm pretty sure none of the big three CRAs in the US give any weight to a "soft inquiry" event.)
- etjossem 11y agoEdit, did my own research: these codes are part of the credit report and represent the status of the account each month. They aren't the only factor (length of history, utilization, number of accounts, and type of accounts matters too): R0 or I0: Not enough credit history to judge risk. R1 or I1: On-time payment, in 1 month. R2 or I2: Late payment, in 2 months. R3 or I3: Late payment, in 3 months. R4 or I4: Late payment, in 4 months. R5 or I5: 120+ day late reporting. R7 or I7: Consolidated debt payment. R8 or I8: Repossession. R9 or I9: Default.