5 ms·
Probably not going to be the most popular opinion but... The article really didn't shown any proof or even suggested anything besides hinting at various SJ iss
by dogma1138 11y ago
Probably not going to be the most popular opinion but...
The article really didn't shown any proof or even suggested anything besides hinting at various SJ issues. The Autism spectrum at this point is so overblown that I'm not sure if it's even correct anymore at some point this looks like it's becoming the new ADHD everyone has it just in a different flavor.
At this point Autism is almost no longer classified as physical neurodevelopmental disorder but with a lovely brand new name pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified.
Now don't get me wrong I don't think that low functioning Autism is fake, nor that some actual physical neurodevelopmental syndromes are but the amount of cases that 2 decades ago when psychoanalysis was still in fashion that would be classified as neurosis that are now being classified as autism even tho they do not show any of the physical signs of autism is quite staggering.
I'm not saying that those people are not "sick" I just have very strong suspicion that at the end this whole autism spectrum will blow up. It seems like every week we get a new article about normally functioning adults with various eccentricities that come out and say that they now know why they aren't normal and that's because they are autistic.
Articles like this: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/health/why-i-love-knowing-i-have-high-functioning-autism/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/health/why-i-love-knowing-i... just make me question this whole ordeal, 5 hours of diagnosis of a woman in her 40's with a career and a family is enough to deem some one being autistic without any actual developmental tests, brain imaging or even in depth psychoanalysis.
I just don't really understand all these cases when people claim that they don't feel the same way that other people do (there's almost no way to know what other person is feeling, at best empathy will let you know what state they are projecting) or what other people find easy or hard. Not everyone finds socializing easy, not everyone likes to talk about their feelings, not everyone is even capable of building complex emotional attachments and it seems like people go in and out of various states like that throughout their life.
- rdudek 11y agoAutism is a spectrum, not a single type disorder. Problem with this label is that it has 100+ different things lumped into one category. Not all autistic folks are the same, it really depends on where they land on the spectrum. Also, the word spectrum is not real good word to use, should be more like a cloud instead of a straight line since different autistic people exhibit different problems. Also, more kids are labeled as autistic so they can get the extra help they need as early as possible to improve their life in the future. Insurance companies won't cover costs of therapy unless there is a medical condition that requires it.
- dogma1138 11y agoI'm perfectly aware that it's a spectrum but at the end there's a limit to how much you can throw at it before it becomes a jackson pollock painting. Look at autism today vs even 10 years ago, look at how many perfectly adjusted individuals are diagnosed with it something just doesn't seem right to me. When I've started school we have had 2 kids with ADHD during my entire primary school class, by the end of high school half the class had some sort of form of learning disability which many of them got to get extra time on tests or other type of exemptions (verbal testing for example). I've seen this happen in front of me within a decade and it seems to happen now again with other so called disorder. Don't get me wrong I have the utmost respect to children with developmental disorders I've volunteered with a special care group for 2 summers during high school and I've seen what the ends of both the disfunctioning and functioning spectrum looked like then and the very clear similarities you could tie between them in many activities. But now? not really I've met some people that were diagnosed with Autism late in their life mostly with AAS (usually after a fairly short diagnosis session) all of them are to me perfectly functional adults yes each and everyone of them had their issues but I've seen in none of them the actual "signs" that I've seen in actual children that were professionally and clinically diagnosed with what back then was while quite polar but fairly narrow spectrum.
- rdudek 11y agoWell, part of it is that they increased the size of the "spectrum" by adding more conditions and that doctors now check early in case intervention may be required are why the numbers are not so high. Take for example my daughter. She was able to walk by herself when she was 8 months old. She got very independent quickly. She was about to recite entire alphabet and count to 20 by 15 months. The concerning fact that doctors had was that she did not point at things of interest and had poor eye contact. By her 2nd birthday, she started receiving speech and occupational therapies from a local early intervention program. It definitely helped her along with putting her into daycare/early preschool environment. She is very good at memorizing songs and objects. We're a bilingual family and she understands both Polish and English languages. Recently, she started learning some bits of Spanish at preschool. She can draw pretty well and can write her own name. Her biggest weakness that we're working on now is her speech / communication. She is currently at 27% for her age.
- mettamage 11y agoMost of your comments seem geared towards general autism and some to clinical psychology as a field. I mostly agree with it, but it is not really about this article. Furthermore, while autism might just be a label and nothing else, we do need to help people who (or who's friends and family) claim to have mental problems. Your comment about people having "various eccentricities" (perhaps unknowingly) downplays this. Realistically, it's quite hard to tell when people are eccentric or when they are in deep psychological turmoil. At this moment, diagnosing someone with autism, for example, is the most popular method we have -- I wanted to say cutting edge, but that's probably wrong. For me it was an interesting article. Since gender is partially a cultural and biological construct I can imagine how gender changes the outer appearance of autism. I wish there would be more research on it compared to what the writer claimed there is. Unfortunately, scientists mostly recruit participants that are easy to find.
- dogma1138 11y agoThe article it self is very problematic it's anecdotal at best and was laying it heavy in quite a few areas. The opening paragraph it self is dubious 1 of her doctors lost his license for misconduct (sleeping with patients) the other only seen her for 7 min. This isn't relevant really because if they are incompetent they would be quite well equally incompetent regardless of sex. Then the next line was about her being on medication which negatively affected her (psychiatric medication doses are nutritiously bad I've seen weight gain and utter apathy in both men and women taking anti depressants). And then the article continues with more and more anecdotal evidence. Psychiatry is plagued with miss diagnosis, including many times where actual physical conditions from STD's to poisoning are diagnosed as physiological or psychiatric disorders. This doesn't seem to be an extreme case, clinical psychiatry is probably the least accurate medical science we have and only in fairy recent decades that it started getting backup in terms of actual biology neuroscience especially neurogenetics, real time brain imaging and many other fields are still quite infant compared to many other medical fields like physiological clinical diagnosis and surgery. I can go on and on, but overall i didn't get from the article a) that she isn't an outlier as autism in adults by definition is under diagnosed if it is actually a given born condition and not an accumulated psychological disposition due to her life experience so far (24 years of being probed and medicated could might as well caused at least some of it, it's a shame that early development and child psychology is almost a tabu currently, I have my own theory about that but it's almost conspiratorial in nature) b) that there is a clear case of misdiagnosis of clinical autism in women.
- someone7x 11y agoWhat are the SJ issues? Nothing really seemed agenda-driven to me other than the anecdote of Leigh and her family's insistence that she only have female caretakers. In the given context of safety and a request for only female caretakers, is the conclusion that male caretakers are unsafe for female patients? Unfortunately it's never explained so can't understand why it's even in the article.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>In the given context of safety and a request for only female caretakers, is the conclusion that male caretakers are unsafe for female patients? A fun way to view the world: swap gender for race and see how it reads.
- sudosteph 11y agoI think you are being overly cynical. It's a label that helps people. I'm one of those people. I spent so much of my youth wondering what was so innately wrong with me that my peers would take every opportunity to mock my speech, my hobbies, my mannerisms, my preferences in food, clothes, etc. I became severely depressed during high school and nearly killed myself. I felt incredibly broken, confused, and separated from my peers in every way. My parents weren't the type to believe in stuff like ADHD or Autism spectrum stuff, so the fact that I was getting great grades/test scores/had a few close nerd friends seemed to indicate I was just bookish and shy. Teachers were the same way, nothing wrong with the quiet kid. When I finally had a psychologist tell me about Asperger's, and I went to some of the online communities and read about all of the other people with such similar experiences, it really helped. I wasn't so broken anymore, I was just different, and a lot of other people are different in the same way. By that time, I was too old to get much help out of an official diagnosis, but just being able to put a label on it gave me some peace. Even though I am well-adjusted, employed, and otherwise able to blend in and function to a point that it's mostly irrelevant, knowing about it and having a community helped me get there. I don't see why it's so terrible to have autism be a more inclusive label if it helps people.
- lutusp 11y ago> It's a label that helps people. Yes, that's very likely true. But some will argue that it's more than a label, that it has an independent reality, whether or not people find it helpful. Such people are trying to class autism with biological conditions, and they may turn out to be right. We won't know until someone uses science to link an actual objective cause to the symptoms -- a pathogen or an unambiguous organic source that can be objectively diagnosed without expert opinion playing any part at all. We're nowhere near that goal. > When I finally had a psychologist tell me about Asperger's, and I went to some of the online communities and read about all of the other people with such similar experiences, it really helped. How did you feel when Asperger's was abandoned, after an epidemic of phony diagnoses? Did it matter that many of the diagnoses were just opinion with no objective basis? This is not to claim that those with the Asperger's diagnosis were faking, but that their true subjective mental state wasn't being accurately assessed, and many smart people were being grouped with people who actually had one or another mental condition. I point this out only to show that we have no idea what Asperger's is, or Autism is, and the necessary science is not being done.
- andreasvc 11y ago> deem some one being autistic without any actual developmental tests, brain imaging or even in depth psychoanalysis. The latter two have nothing to do with psychiatric or psychological diagnoses. A diagnoses is made on the basis of symptoms, it doesn't get more exact than that. There are symptoms which frequently go together, and this is how disorders get a name. Although science attempts to find biological markers for mental illness, this has not been very successful. Psychoanalysis is just pseudoscience.
- autismdad 11y agoAs a father of a 15 year old girl with autism on the lower ability end of the spectrum I agree with some of what your saying. I feel that the 'spectrum' is getting so wide that anyone that has any social issues, or has any odd habits is labeled as autistic now. It's frustrating when I hear people that are fully functional in society and maybe just have a hard time socializing with people (probably because they grew up on facebook, etc... and never really interacted with real people) that say they are autistic. It is like the new ADHD. I spent the first 11 years of my daughters life changing diapers, usually with her fighting me the entire time. Wasn't until she was 7 that she ever even called me dad. 15 now and can barely read Dr. Suess books or answer basic yes or no questions. I worry that as more and more fully functioning people are added to the spectrum that it will result in less help out there for people like my daughter that really need it.
- taurath 11y agoI would certainly hope not - they may call it a continuum but that does only really muddy the water. While there are a lot of similarities in what can help high functioning and low functioning people cope the amount of day-to-day help can be black and white. I much preferred when high functioning people had "aspergers", because even within the high functioning moniker there's a huge range. HF folks don't like to be treated as if they have a fundamental disability (which is disempowering) just as caretakers of LF people need a lot more of the recognition and assistance that a serious disability requires.
- ScottBurson 11y ago> I worry that as more and more fully functioning people are added to the spectrum that it will result in less help out there for people like my daughter that really need it. Do you actually see this happening? It seems to me just as likely that greater awareness of the entire spectrum will bring more acceptance and more resources. Anyway, for my wife, learning that she has Asperger syndrome has been a great relief. It's hard for me to see that as a bad thing. Your story is heart-wrenching, and I hope your daughter gets the help she needs. I just don't see why my wife's experience and yours need to be in conflict.
- 11y ago
- lsc 11y agoyour attitude is common... and I don't really understand it. I mean, yes, psychology, as a science, and psychiatry as a medical discipline, is young and not nearly as systematized and objective as many other sciences. Psychiatry is less so than the rest of medicine, really, and medicine is less so than, say, civil engineering. But, that doesn't mean that it's without value. Sure, there's a lot less value in psychiatry now than there will be once it becomes more like civil engineering, but that's not a reason to ignore what we've got. >The Autism spectrum at this point is so overblown that I'm not sure if it's even correct anymore at some point this looks like it's becoming the new ADHD everyone has it just in a different flavor. Why do you think ADHD is not a useful or "correct" diagnosis? Unlike Autism, there is a spectrum of drugs available which seem to help people who are diagnosed with ADHD quite a lot. Personally, I think that treating these sorts of things is a "social good" to the extent that being productive and able to support oneself is a social good. if you take someone's ADHD and properly treat it, you can take a person who is not capable of contributing positively to the economy, and you can put them in a position where they can hold down an upper-middle class job. I think that for Autism, the workplace is changing some in ways that allow some people who could not previously have held down jobs to do so, which is great, but attacking the problem from the other side; developing medical treatments that allow some percentage of the population to function in society is, in my mind, unalloyed good. edit: more correct psychology/psychiatry usage, I believe.
- dogma1138 11y agoADHD can't be that new, in less than a decade it turned from less than 1% to 50% in the class room that points at it being a pill pushing campaign. In the 60's you would get slapped and send to bed without dinner (I'm not condoning beating children just stating a fact). There's probably a good reason why ADHD all of a sudden sprouted out with the last of the baby boomers / first millennials which decided to let their children roam free which coincided with us deciding the schools should not long discipline children but just feed them facts, and instead of having kids run around till they fall asleep from exhaustion we stuck them in front of the screen fed with nothing but sugar. A sloth under those conditions would get ADHD. When half your class is on Ritalin something went wrong, and this only makes things worse for people which actually have learning disabilities as it just gives untrained professionals that should not be diagnosing the color of the sky the ability to pump kids with pills because their parents can't give a frack to discipline them. I had 2 childhood friends that were "diagnosed" with ADHD and gotten Ritalin since they were in 6th or 7th grade it turned out that both were dyslexic and got frustrated in class because they had hard time reading the bloody assignments and the actual conditions were discovered pretty much after they flunked high school because the only thing that Ritalin did is glue them to a chair. And yes I see a similar thing with Adult Onset Autism these days. The entire industry is screwed up I got "diagnosed" as a child with everything from being a genius to an autistic with ADHD only because I could care less about class, this got some what aggravated by the fact that my soviet schooled parents decided to tutor me so a 4th grade student that can solve 2nd order equations in 4th grade and is too bored to do homework or had a vocal argument with his 7th grade science teacher that in he that mass isn't a "fixed amount of matter" that never changes (I got expelled for shoving like 50 xerox copies of a very poor proof into every teachers locker) surely has some disorders bring on the pills. Wile the truth was that it was just the outcome of 2 soviet parents with several PHD's between them, father was a surgeon, mother was a psychiatrists, sister a clinical psychologist, other kids weren't as lucky because by reading the diagnosis manual if you like taking the VCR apart you now have autism, right...