6 ms·
> but given what we know about the importance of genetics in passing along favourable human capital characteristics I don't think we know that at all, and as a
by pron 11y ago
> but given what we know about the importance of genetics in passing along favourable human capital characteristics
I don't think we know that at all, and as an assumption it is a terrible one. If it is wrong (and we have no reason to assume it is correct, at least not to a very high degree), you are deciding to give up on a lot of people. You're basically guessing that the poor are where they belong and as a consequence of that guess, you make no effort to help them. Moreover, even if that assumption is right, so what? Even if people are born less capable of riches, that does not mean we shouldn't do our best to help them achieve moderate levels of success, or at least to better their lot in life. This isn't all altruistic: a more egalitarian society is a more pleasant one.
In the end, it all comes to values. But I want to clarify what those values signify: financial success isn't just about how much stuff you can buy, but more importantly about power[1]. The less money you have relative to the median, the less power, and the less power you have -- the less freedom. Giving up on power equality means giving up on greater freedom to great many people.
> it seems very reasonable that we would see less than "perfect" mobility.
There's a very long way from where the US is now to perfect mobility. Americans can start with striving for European levels of mobility for a start. We know that at least that is possible.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_(social_and_political) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_(social_and_political)
- yummyfajitas 11y agoWhat facts, measurements or data (if any) would cause you to accept that his hypothesis is true? Interpret his hypothesis in a broad manner; poor folks are predominantly where they belong due to hereditary traits, either genetics or behaviors taught by their parents. These traits will cause them to be poor in any system which rewards hard work, intelligence and the creation of value for other people as a means of gaining income.
- pron 11y ago> What facts, measurements or data (if any) would cause you to accept that his hypothesis is true? Anything that provides strong evidence that no human action -- social or technological -- can possibly improve the fortune of the poor. > either genetics or behaviors taught by their parents Even if that were true, I see no claim that they cannot change, so I don't see why the cause matters. That people's starting positions in life are widely unequal is pretty much a given; no one disputes that. In order to make a powerful claim, the only thing that matters is not the source of their misfortune, but that it cannot be changed. Genetic, "wide" social or "close" social (family), I see no such claim being made, and if anyone were to make that claim, I think that they have no good foundation to base it on. I do see people make that (usually implied) assumption, but as I said before, this assumption is no more than a reflection of their values[1]. > These traits will cause them to be poor in any system which rewards hard work, intelligence and the creation of value for other people as a means of gaining income. Only provided that the system doesn't do other things, too (and why can't the poor work hard? I think I work far less hard than a great many number of people far poorer than me). ---- [1]: As to values, I have absolutely no problem with people holding values that say "every man to himself", and we shouldn't go out of our ways to help the poor. I do see a huge problem with people offering social structures that try to curtail whatever power the poor do have, but not the power of the rich. The rich have their money and the poor have their numbers. They can use their numbers for violence or the threat of violence, to achieve better standing, or through a more sophisticated mechanism of democracy, where they impose restrictions on the rich. As a consequence, I see no ethical problem with either a social democracy or anarchy. But I see a big ethical problems with ideologies that prohibit violence, the threat of violence, and any form of organization imposing restrictions, while at the same time placing no restrictions on the use of power that comes from money. Those people are saying, "every man to himself as long as we make sure no one with different sources of power than me can use their's against me".
- yummyfajitas 11y agoGenetic, "wide" social or "close" social (family), I see no such claim being made, and if anyone were to make that claim, I think that they have no good foundation to base it on. Asift made this claim and you asserted it was false. What evidence (if any) would cause you to believe it to be true? Even if that were true, I see no claim that they cannot change, so I don't see why the cause matters. The cause matters because it affects potential solutions. If the cause of a mobility difference between the US and Sweden is economic, then the fix is probably adopting the Swedish economic system (e.g., privatizing education and adopting their sane corporate tax system). If the cause is genetic then the solution would be adopting Swedish genetics by removing from the gene pool anyone of non-Nordic descent. If the cause were close social then the solution would be preventing poor people from transmitting their harmful values and behaviors to their children. Hypothetically, suppose I could provide adequate evidence (as per my prior question) that Ashkenazi Jews have superior intelligence and other hereditary advantages that cause them to occupy disproportionate chunks of the top rungs of society (thereby lowering mobility). Asift and myself would oppose changing this since the only solutions are violent. If one doesn't eliminate violence as a possible solution, what new avenues open up for us to solve this "Jewish problem"?
- pron 11y ago> What evidence (if any) would cause you to believe it to be true? I said: any strong evidence that no human action could improve the poor's fortunes. I doubt such evidence could be found, though. First, equality has improved a lot due to human action, so the claim needs to be "but where we are now is as good as it gets", which sounds suspiciously convenient (especially as the people making that claim believe that almost everything else can be greatly improved, and their claim is usually based on no study at all of human society, so not understanding how change has been achieved so far makes the claim that we can't take it further even more suspect). Second, we are now able to stay underwater or in space, and to fly over oceans -- things we are genetically less inclined to do -- so I seriously doubt human ingenuity stops when it comes to equality. The question is how far should we work towards equality, but that is a question of values, again. > The cause matters because it affects potential solutions. Of course, but we're not arguing about solutions but about whether solutions need to be sought at all. > Asift and myself would oppose changing this, since the only solutions are violent and we both seem to prefer low violence to high mobility. If one doesn't oppose violence, what violent solutions to this hypothetical Jewish problem are acceptable? I, too, would oppose a violent solution, and not only for egotistical reasons, but your example is a non-sequitur. In order for this problem to be a problem at all, you'll need to show that it is in fact a major cause for lowered mobility. Second, I don't see what violence has to do with it. Your entire argument sounds like, "I need to get to the top floor of that building, but as someone opposed to violence I wouldn't kill everyone in the street and climb the nice incline of the pile of bodies to get to the top; how does one who isn't categorically opposed to violence suggest to get up there?" Why, she might just take the elevator. In other words, why would you even think that the only solution to inequality is violence?
- asift 11y agoActually there is a tremendous amount of research on the importance of genetics (particularly twin and adoption studies). My quick summary here is going to be overly simplistic, but at a very high level, so long as a child wasn't raised in an abusive environment, genetics are much more important in predicting things like intelligence and future earnings than a family's characteristics are. That conclusion is not merely anecdote. It's one of the most extensively studied questions in parenting research.
- pron 11y agoI think that your interpretation of the results is very wrong. Studies on criminality show a significant genetic component -- not that it is the most significant factor. The IQ studies indeed show that a much stronger correlation with the biological parents, but IQ variation has not been found to be a major cause of social inequality, AFAIK. I.e. to draw your conclusions you'd need another missing element, which is to show that low IQ is a major cause of poverty, and other causes don't play as significant a role. I am not aware of any such claims. Indeed, in the famous twin-adoption studies, heredity was found to explains only ~20% of the variation in earnings in men and ~10% in women -- certainly significant, but far from being the determining cause. Also, that genetics may have a significant influence on future earnings does not mean that no action is possible to counter that effect -- if we choose to take it. Choosing to take it or not is a value-based choice. Genetics also prevents us from flying or some people born with deformities from walking, yet we have built airplanes and prosthetics.