3 ms·
Everyone has to make noise sometimes, and it's not just distasteful bass. Good luck succeeding in a noise complaint about a crying infant. I'd rather make it
by nitrogen 11y ago
Everyone has to make noise sometimes, and it's not just distasteful bass. Good luck succeeding in a noise complaint about a crying infant. I'd rather make it illegal to build paper-thin walls.
- jensen123 11y agoTrue. But it's much harder to block a low-frequency sound like a thumping bass, than a high-frequency sound like a crying infant. Thicker walls etc. would take care of the sound from crying infants, but can it ever get rid of a thumping bass? Harsher punishments might be necessary for low-frequency sounds.
- nitrogen 11y agoThere's gotta be a way to isolate the subwoofer from the floor to at least reduce it. My dream apartment would have 60dB+ of isolation above 60Hz, but that would probably be prohibitively expensive and bulky if the walls weren't already concrete.
- kuschku 11y ago> if the walls weren't already concrete. And that’s when you make concrete walls mandatory.
- ggreer 11y agoConsidering that multiple complaints from multiple neighbors couldn't stop one guy from blasting music, I think current laws (at least in SF) err too much on the side of non-punishment. > I'd rather make it illegal to build paper-thin walls. Let's say you manage to pass a law forcing all new construction to have excellent soundproofing. That won't fix the problem for a century. Buildings last a really long time. Heck, tons of old buildings still have asbestos or lead paint. I seriously doubt their soundproofing is going to be fixed before those. Punishing noisy people is the only solution that works with our existing infrastructure.
- nitrogen 11y agoIf sound isolation became a feature that people wanted, with the initial push provided by building codes, then apartments could compete on isolation and both noisy and noise-sensitive individuals would move there. Then landlords would start providing more isolation to attract tenants. Of course, that's moot if supply is artificially restricted to the point where renters have no choice where to live, but not all cities have that problem.