4 ms·
This is a rather shallow article with barely any real points. Talking about all those externalities only serves to create noise rather than support any argument
by manigandham 11y ago
This is a rather shallow article with barely any real points. Talking about all those externalities only serves to create noise rather than support any arguments against the ad model. You can just as easily argue that images and CSS should be removed to save even more bandwidth and processing power. Why even go online at all actually when you can get a newspaper for a few cents?
Here's the reality - We only have 2 options to enable the value exchange of content: direct (via you moving funds to the publisher) or in-direct (monetizing through ads). It's a binary choice. It's one or the other, that's it. There's no magic 3rd option that's available (today).
Here are a few reasons why advertising is still a better model:
- It's fast. Faster than money transfer.
- It's efficient. Money is not cheap to transfer, even today.
- It's passive. No mental energy expended or decision making required.
- It's anonymous. No need for payment details or 3rd party to handle funds.
- It's secure. Again no need for payment information, there's not much ads can do. (Malware is a different problem.)
- It's accessible. Your wealth doesn't determine the amount of content you can get. Everyone can access everything equally.
This is fundamentally a question of human behavior and the common reaction is to take things for free when possible. People just do not value content that highly, if at all. You can already see the reaction to rising rates for netflix and spotify even though they provide so much value, certainly more than an equally priced cup of coffee.
Add to that the amount of willpower and decisioning it requires to judge whether a piece of content is worth it or not and it's clear that this is not a scalable system. Perhaps a "cable subscription" for the internet with time-based billing for each domain might be something that works as a direct-payment option in the future but this is a massive technical, security and privacy challenge the way things are now.
I do agree that ads have gotten out of hand recently - however this is an implementation problem. Regulation and standards and enforcement are what's needed to fix this. It has nothing to do with the ad model itself which is still the most universally scalable and viable monetization system for content.
- Terr_ 11y agoSaying "it's just an implementation problem" understates the severity of that problem, and I think it's a little deceptive to claim that laws, regulations, and economic models are all "implementation" just as much as the raw code. I mean, would you say that dumping a type of toxic waste into a river is an "implementation" problem when there's no law against it? > It's fast. Except when ad-frameworks slow down browsing to a crawl because they heap innumerable delays on the page-load in order to "auction" the spot and maximize revenue. > It's anonymous Except for our big ad-networks that incorporated quita lot of fingerprinting, profiling, and even surveillance. > It's secure Except for how ad-networks are a vector for malware, since there's no incentive to vet content beyond maintaining their own throughput.
- manigandham 11y agoI believe you missed the statement where I said this is an implementation problem. I recently founded an adtech company to show how these issues can be fixed. Ads are fast. Ad networks however are slow. Bad tech with old vendors is most of the problem. Our ads load faster than the content half the time. Sites like Washington Post, The Guardian, Ars Technica show how you can have a fast site with ads. Very solvable through technology. Ads are definitely more anonymous than payments. Payments = credit cards or bank accounts. Guess what that means? Your name, address, age, credit history, employment, etc all perfectly accessible and tied to your identity. Profiling is used to give you more relevant ads. Someone who doesn't have children doesn't need to see diaper ads so it's a perfectly reasonable thing. I agree that sometimes it's taken too far with retargeting where you see the same ads constantly but this is a different matter. Our network focuses mostly on context of the page (tech site = tech ads) and performs just as well without any tracking (other than history of ads seen to avoid showing same ads). The internet is a vector for malware. There absolutely is a way to vet content, but standards and enforcement is just not there right now. Ad networks dont really suffer anything when bad stuff happens so they have no incentive to do much about it. We don't even accept any 3rd party content on our network so we're far more secure than even the sites we run on. Again, all of this is down to implementation - nothing wrong with the ad model itself.
- Terr_ 11y ago> I believe you missed the statement I believe you posted a reply while I was still making postscript-editing. A bad habit of mine, I know.
- manigandham 11y agoGot it. So with your edit: > I mean, would you say that dumping a type of toxic waste into a river is an "implementation" problem when there's no law against it? Yes. This doesn't mean we stop doing anything that produces toxic waste. Cars are also a vector for criminal activity. Like guns and knives and cellphones. We don't get rid of them either. Instead we use regulation and standards to enforce the safety mechanisms and proper ethical behavior.
- panic 11y agoYou could do indirect payments without ads. For example, say an organization gave grants to ad-free websites based on certain criteria. Some of these criteria could be how much people visit the site or how highly they rank it. Funding could come from people interested in keeping the web ad-free.
- manigandham 11y agoThis is still direct via donations. Just by a few doing it for the many. So the question is, who are these special few? NYT times costs hundreds of millions to run. That's just a single publisher. Most major sites require somewhere in the 8 figures. As theory and data have shown, human behavior is not conducive to paying if you can avoid it. Unless your plan is to turn content publishers into tax-funded state-run companies, I fail to see how this could possibly work. * Before it's mentioned: Wikipedia is perhaps the only example of donations working at scale. However, it's not really working because Wikipedia doesn't produce any content. It's also not a business. Wikimedia which is an actual business runs the wikia.com network of sites and they're all monetized through ads.
- panic 11y agoIf enough people care about an ad-free web, it wouldn't have to be a special few: it could be a relatively large group of passionate people. But that's just one idea. The point is that it's not a dichotomy of low-friction, indirect ads versus high-friction, direct payment. There may be other options.
- pdkl95 11y ago> NYT times costs hundreds of millions to run. Maybe their product isn't worth hundreds of millions of dollars. As for willingness to pay, you seem to be projecting your own selfish behavior onto others. I know quite a few counter-examples that prove people are willing to pay for content they actually value. They have embraced technology to lower costs, and have cultivated very generous audiences using places like Patron. > only example of donations working at scale LOL. Only if you don't look. Also, why do you think everything has to work "at scale"? Small-but-loyal audiences are fine.
- sarciszewski 11y ago> - It's secure. Again no need for payment information, there's not much ads can do. (Malware is a different problem.) http://www.wired.com/insights/2014/11/malvertising-is-cybercriminals-latest-sweet-spot/ http://www.wired.com/insights/2014/11/malvertising-is-cyberc... Advertising is an attack vector. A security risk for the end user.
- manigandham 11y agoThe entire internet is an attack vector. Malware has existed for a long time in numerous forms, ad networks are just another possibility but so are websites themselves, downloadable software, mobile apps, etc. As mentioned in another comment - We also have cars and cellphones that can be used by criminals. That doesn't mean modern transportation and communication has a problem, it means that criminals will be criminals and we need better ways of dealing with them. As far as I can see, that's an implementation problem. Here's the truth: I've been in the ad industry for a long time and there is literally 0 enforcement of anything. Lots of fraud and shady practices but no regulation and nobody to answer to. If you do get caught, change the name of the company and try again. I can guarantee that if we actually send people to jail for not vetting malware or running illegal or shady ads, this problem will pretty much go away immediately.
- pdkl95 11y agoAdding to what Terr_ already pointed out: > It's efficient Money may not be changing hands, but a lot of information is, which is easily worth more. Leaving out these costs are yet another reason why advertisers have a reputation for dishonesty. Also, the article specifically discussed the terrible power efficency that is always going to be associated with the extra transfer and processing associated with fetching ads. Or do you think they get to violate conservation on energy to be downloaded? If you are adding ad to a page, you are making the client pay more to see it. Offloading costs like this - while pretending it is efficient - should really be criminal. > It's passive Bullshit, and you know it. The very idea of advertising is to be distracting. The arms-race we've seen over the last few decades where advertising went from simple banners, to popups, to various other dynamic rendering tricks, to the modern modal/click-through video ads - and worse - are all about not being passive. This is suck a basic concept in advertising that I have to conclude you are dissembling deliberately, or are such a "true believer" in advertising you cannot see it any other way. Also, it takes an incredible amount of energy to ignore ads. Anybody that thinks ads don't cost any mental energy is either lying or addicted. Install an adblocker and use it 100% reliably for several months to break the addiction, and you will be shocked at the energy advertising wastes when you see it again. > It's accessible Except if someone is poor, they cannot afford whatever it is you are advertising. I've seen this meme a lot recently, so it's obviously a talking point the advertising indujstry is using to try to justify their drain on society. You're not fooling anybody, and this kind of appeal only makes advertisers look desperate. -- While Terr_ already mentioned this one... > It's secure. You don't get to exclude malware, when advertising is the vector. Even ignoring that, leaking tracking information makes you malware!
- manigandham 11y ago>>> Also, the article specifically discussed the terrible power efficency that is always going to be associated with the extra transfer and processing associated with fetching ads. Or do you think they get to violate conservation on energy to be downloaded? If you are adding ad to a page, you are making the client pay more to see it. Offloading costs like this - while pretending it is efficient - should really be criminal. These are externalities. Do you get upset that articles have images in them? What about products coming in packaging that you just throw away? Isn't that gas and energy you are wasting on something you don't want? Power efficiency of ads is really not that big of a deal. >>> Bullshit, and you know it. I was talking about the effort involved in choosing to pay for each pageview. Not ad formats. I believe you're conflating the two together. >>> The very idea of advertising is to be distracting. Actually the idea is to gain your attention. And yes, we already know this because it's quite literally what advertisers are paying for. Your attention. >>> advertising went from simple banners, to popups, to various other dynamic rendering tricks Yes, this is an implementation issue where ads have gotten out of hand. I agree with you that we need to return to better standards. However this doesn't mean the advertising model is broken. It's still magnitudes less effort required than having to decide to pay everytime you load a new page. >>> to ignore ads The point isn't to ignore ads. Advertisers are paying for your attention which pays for the content. It obviously wouldn't be a very good model if they never got the attention that they paid for. Yes it takes energy to ignore, also takes energy to choose to pay. Ads are generally easier to deal with. >>> when advertising is the vector Everything is a vector. Pick any object in the world. It's a vector for use by a criminal. We should focus on stopping the criminals, not banning everything. >>> leaking tracking information makes you malware Genuinely don't understand this. What tracking information and what is harming you?