7 ms·
So based on that [3], open source then. What are the high speed and feature-wise comparable open source solutions to a the compromised Juniper switches?
by rdtsc 11y ago
So based on that [3], open source then.
What are the high speed and feature-wise comparable open source solutions to a the compromised Juniper switches?
- SteveNuts 11y agoThere isn't one.
- f2f 11y ago> So based on that [3], open source then. nortel networks. no bugs in the last few years.
- jhall1468 11y ago> nortel networks. no bugs in the last few years. No known bugs.
- alex_anglin 11y agoGood luck buying from a company that's gone out of business.
- rogeryu 11y ago> nortel networks. no bugs in the last few years. One week ago we could say this of Juniper as well.
- chei0aiV 11y agoThere are routers/switches based on Linux, here is one based on Debian. Unfortunately they still contain proprietary bits thanks to Broadcom. http://cumulusnetworks.com/ http://cumulusnetworks.com/
- dorfsmay 11y agoThere's also https://opennetlinux.org/ https://opennetlinux.org/ which is more open, but unfortunately only runs on a few high end switches right now.
- electrum 11y agoAccording to the article, the affected products are firewalls, not switches, but for switches, Facebook has open sourced the hardware and software for the switches used in production: https://code.facebook.com/posts/843620439027582/facebook-open-switching-system-fboss-and-wedge-in-the-open/ https://code.facebook.com/posts/843620439027582/facebook-ope...
- packetslave 11y agoGood luck finding an open-source router that can compete on performance or scalability with a Juniper MX2020 or PTX5000. (yes, those aren't the device that was found to be compromised, but the grandparent post suggested we "stop using Juniper's products altogether")
- iheartmemcache 11y agoYou're really going to have a hard time finding something that satisfies your 3 requirements (open source, high-speed and capable of what a Juniper Netscreen can do). OpenBSD can be tuned to operate really well, hit maybe 80 or 90% feature parity with those Netscreens, but the performance won't even come close to what a Netscreen can do -- Juniper fabs their own ASICs and a general von Neumann x86 won't come close to being able to packet switching at those speeds. You might be able to get close in performance with your high-end Altera's and Xilinx's gear, but that certainly won't be cheap and AFAIK the FPGA synthesis tools are still closed source -- so you're not going to get an 'open source' from top-to-bottom solution at all 3 levels (Silicon, firmware, OS and packet switching). It's arguably more trust-worthy than buying Juniper/Cisco which has complete control of the stack, from silicon to software, but you'll be paying through the nose either way. The standard Intel e1000's running OpenBSD and libpacket might be the best trade-off you're going to get in price/performance (again, if you make the concession that Intel isn't backdooring on: a) the firmware and/or drivers for the e1000s, or b) somewhere along the controller bus path -> PHY on the processor). This whitepaper [1] re: OmniPath + Xeon/PHI architecture boasts brilliant numbers (page 7 for an architecture summary, column 2 for the network switching summary, page 8 for the benchmark numbers). Again, not open-source at the hardware level, but the drivers, libraries and OS can all be audited. And at those rates of transmission, I'm guessing you could use physical probing along each component to see if any deep-packet tomfoolery is occurring, as the latency increase would be detectable, and you can't just add an extra login password at that level. Tyan's OpenPOWER compliant stack will run on BSD and other than the processor (which uses an IBM POWER8) pretty much uses jellybean components-- so you get what I'm going to coin as "security through vendor diversity" from now.[2] It comes down to how tightly your tin-foil hat has been sized I suppose. The upside is right now there's a huge open-source hardware revolution going on. OpenCores' Virtex based RISC stuff is available and that's top-to-bottom open source, and if you were really motivated and had the engineering know-how, ASIC runs can be done for under a million. [1] https://ramcloud.atlassian.net/wiki/download/attachments/22478857/20150902-IntelOmniPath-WhitePaper_2015-08-26-Intel-OPA-FINAL.pdf?version=1&modificationDate=1441327130864&api=v2 https://ramcloud.atlassian.net/wiki/download/attachments/224... [2] http://www.tyan.com/campaign/openpower/index.html http://www.tyan.com/campaign/openpower/index.html
- 11y ago