4 ms·
Thank you for the detailed response. In my circles that judge books, I'd actually expect more sympathy for Rand than Marx (or Piketty), so I think mileage varie
by pjmorris 11y ago
Thank you for the detailed response. In my circles that judge books, I'd actually expect more sympathy for Rand than Marx (or Piketty), so I think mileage varies.
To me, it seems that what you describe as the 'key idea' of Atlas Shrugged is actually two separate ideas; 'individual is more important than the state', and 'sacrifice of a few innocents for the many is not morally valid'. Leaving the individual aside for the moment, for the second idea, how do you reconcile the reasonable notion of not sacrificing innocents for the many with cases where the many will suffer unfairly (e.g. the Trolley Problem [1]) when it is in your power to act?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem
- crdb 11y agoQuick Google gives me: > Ayn Rand's key point: "man does not live in a lifeboat -- in a world in which he must kill innocent men to survive." > She also observes: "Under a dictatorship -- under force -- there is no such thing as morality. Morality ends where a gun begins.... Moral rules cannot be prescribed for these situations [lifeboats or dictatorships], because only life is the basis on which to establish a moral code." http://objectivistanswers.com/questions/1892/what-is-the-objectivist-position-to-moral-dilemmas-like-the-trolley-problem http://objectivistanswers.com/questions/1892/what-is-the-obj...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DrScump 11y agoIn my circles that judge books Do the others in your circles also judge books before reading them?