3 ms·
That initial minor boost is enough to throw a submission high up the frontpage - even 2 points, given close enough together in time, can do it. simple solution
by 10ren 17y ago
That initial minor boost is enough to throw a submission high up the frontpage - even 2 points, given close enough together in time, can do it.
simple solution: remove the automatic upvote given when an article is submitted that has already been submitted. If people want to upvote it, it's negligible effort to do so once they get to the story on HN. bonus submitting an article is a quick hack to find it on HN. Often one would also want to upvote the article, but not always e.g. one might be seeking the comments to help evaluate the article. Counting these "submissions" as "upvotes" is inaccurate.
summary: auto-upvoting of submissions is a needless, inaccurate and distorting convenience.
- johns 17y agoThe submitter's vote isn't counted in the algorithm as far as I know. The original algorithm (since chanced) I believe is (p - 1) / (t + 2)^1.5 with p being the number of points. So you can see the initial vote is subtracted.
- jacquesm 17y agoIt isn't with the first one, but it is with all subsequent submissions.