3 ms·
I like Susan Greenfield. I have been trying to follow Chalmers, Greenfield, Ramachandran, Searle and others who purport to talk about consciousness in various w
by EGreg 11y ago
I like Susan Greenfield. I have been trying to follow Chalmers, Greenfield, Ramachandran, Searle and others who purport to talk about consciousness in various ways and from various perspectives.
The thing is, we can see that our INTERNAL SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCE is unlike any other thing we encounter in the world. It is unlike any process that we build or discover. For example, why am I in my body and not yours? As a software architect, I can recognize when there are arbitary constants being placed in the code. Likewise here, the distribution of "souls" to "bodies"... the phenomenon of internal experience corresponds exactly to my body, and not to someone else's. And since it is internal, I need to describe it from my point of view as "I", and not as something that is generated externally. It is the only thing I cannot view externally. So it is different from everything else.
- robotresearcher 11y ago> why am I in my body and not yours? The simplest explanation that doesn't appeal to magic is that the 'I' is created by the activity of the CNS (etc) of a body. That seems completely satisfactory to me. It's like asking why the engine sounds of my car are in my car and not in your car. A related answer is "because that's where your eyeballs are". If you wear a good VR headset, you can be somewhere other than your body for a while.