6 ms·
Time estimations is an industrial way of thinking applied to a post-industrial world. In the post industrial world time isn't the problem but rather project de
by ThomPete 11y ago
Time estimations is an industrial way of thinking applied to a post-industrial world.
In the post industrial world time isn't the problem but rather project definition and scoping.
In the industrial world the problem was already solved (machine was built, market often established and output depended on a few factors that could be adjusted. Need more output add more of X)
In the post industrial world every project is about problem solving and scoping.
To put it into comparison.
If we apply post-industrial reality to an industrial world. It means that each time a product needed to be done, if not the factory, then the machines would have to be developed.
It will take many many years before time estimation will die, but it will happen.
- calinet6 11y agoThat's a good point, but it has two issues you should consider. First, the industrial world also had significant issues with project definition and understanding. The problems were not already solved, and the process, inputs, outputs and the whole system was constantly changing. Every project was already about problem solving and scoping. So there's a bit of rose-colored glasses toward the past here. Second, the idea that time estimation is no longer applicable is probably off. There are two separate problems: problem definition, and problem solving, and estimation is extremely useful in the latter. Problem definition is a different problem that still needs much focus, but it doesn't preclude the need for better understanding of time to coordinate other processes and dependencies. You might be saying that those dependencies aren't as important as we think, and I tend to agree, but that's a different argument. Generally speaking, the idea that knowledge and skills from the industrial era are no longer applicable is untrue. There is a huge body of knowledge about how products are made and built that have 99% applicability to software and technology in the post-industrial world. This is because the problems are the same: management of people, leadership, understanding interactions within complex systems, understanding statistics (the importance of which this article proves profoundly), and improving the spread of knowledge. This is the way that Toyota began operating in the post-WWII era, the way W. Edwards Deming modeled companies, and the way that the current Lean movement guides you to improve almost any business. It's highly relevant. The main point we should take away, is that time and estimates are not constraints on a system; but rather outputs that are predictable and follow statistical patterns. We can use those outputs to make better decisions, especially if we understand the whole process of production in a systemic way. Estimation need not die. It's a tool for good in the hands of a systems thinker.
- ThomPete 11y agoIt is my experience that there is absolutely not predictability in learning from the past unless you are doing exactly the same. For something like an agency that are hired to come up with something else thats normally not an option.
- calinet6 11y agoThe idea that each project we tackle is unique and a special snowflake is an illusion. In reality, most of the factors that influence the outcomes are exactly the same. Same team, same knowledge, same approaches, same psychological biases, same methods, same politics, and so much more. Those are the things that influence timelines most; not the project itself.
- ThomPete 11y agoIt's not that it's unique it's that the problems that arise in them are unique.
- Scarblac 11y agoTime estimation will always be needed, just to decide whether something is worth doing.
- coldcode 11y agoNot always true. My project has to be done since it will involve a whole host of hardware installations, marketing and other large expenditures. Canceling or changing my project cannot be done. Thus estimating to decide if it's worth doing is unnecessary. In this case it has to be finished regardless of estimates.
- pixl97 11y ago> Canceling or changing my project cannot be done. Oh, yes it can. It's called your parent company going out of business.
- coldcode 11y agoMy parent company is one that will never go out of business unless the US tanks completely.
- Scarblac 11y agoSure, but as long as there are projects where estimation is needed, estimation won't die.