4 ms·
Does that roughly mean that FB must (to be shielded from lawsuits) anonymize the data before passing it to the government? This isn't particularly comforting,
by jessriedel 11y ago
Does that roughly mean that FB must (to be shielded from lawsuits) anonymize the data before passing it to the government? This isn't particularly comforting, since it could still be used to prosecute individuals if identity can be inferred from other context.
The EFF's criticism is basically that the bill is overly broad and can be used nefariously, even if it's not an all purpose FB message vacuum:
> The bill's broad immunity clauses, vague definitions, and aggressive spying powers combine to make the bill a surveillance bill in disguise. Further, the bill does not address problems from the recent highly publicized computer data breaches that were caused by unencrypted files, poor computer architecture, un-updated servers, and employees (or contractors) clicking malware links.
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/10/eff-strongly-oppose-cisa-cyber-surveillance-bill-and-cfaa-amendment https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/10/eff-strongly-oppose-ci...
That seems consistent with my aforementioned worry.
- tptacek 11y agoThey have to do one of two things: 1. They can establish and run a process that ensures that data doesn't have personally identifying information in it. For instance, they can have a process by which they sign off on the types of things they're willing to share, and share only the stuff that never has PII in it. 2. They can instead run software that tries to spot PII and zaps it before sharing it. I don't know how people can take EFF seriously when they say things like "aggressive spying powers". Whatever "spying powers" are in this bill are subtle; I don't think they're there at all. EFF does this a lot: they know their readers aren't going to read the bill, and further that their readers want to believe that the bill is horrifying, and they play that to the hilt.
- jessriedel 11y agoThanks very much for info. Much appreciated. Agreed that the EFF risks its reputation when it freely uses hyperbolic language. But I think some of this is due to (mostly philosophical) difference about how much we should worry about granting vague powers to the government which are mostly not abused. People similarly differ in how fiercely they fight free speech restrictions, etc.
- tptacek 11y agoI think the underlying worry here is very legitimate. But my interest is in making sure we know the truth as precisely as we can, and I believe nobody is well-served by the propagation of falsehoods, even when the falsehoods support a valid narrative.
- soared 11y ago3. They aren't required to share any data, and can keep it to themselves.