3 ms·
What does that responsibility mean? Let's say I accept my responsibility for benefitting from killing all this wildlife and murdering the inhabitants. Now what?
by mikeash 11y ago
What does that responsibility mean? Let's say I accept my responsibility for benefitting from killing all this wildlife and murdering the inhabitants. Now what? Does this change something? Is there some action I should take?
- simonh 11y agoYes, you can support efforts to preserve remaining habitats and examples of that wildlife and conserve the cultural heritage of the victims. Or at least you could avoid actions that might hinder or prevent such efforts, such as by not voting for representatives that might de-fund them or pass laws hindering them. Nobody's suggesting you should be tried for the crimes of your ancestors, or previous members of your society. What we can do is stop doing more damage and try to rectify some of it, where it is reasonable and affordable to do so.
- mikeash 11y agoI'm all for that, but I don't see that being linked to taking responsibility, it's just the right thing to do. Maybe this is just a terminology thing.
- yepguy 11y agoI disagree. While I think your suggested actions are reasonable, nothing distinguishes them from actions we would take if our hands were clean, and instead another group were at fault.
- simonh 11y agoI think it's just a matter of degree. I feel a general responsibility towards planet earth in general to preserve its environmental and cultural heritage. But I feel a greater obligation to contribute towards mitigating some environmental and cultural harms than I do towards others due to my nation and cultures role in exacerbating them. There's no law at work here though. If there is some specific issue you are particularly concerned about that happens not to have any such historical link to you, but it bothers you so much that you take a special personal interest in it then that's fine. But even without dedicating our personal resources towards righting the worlds wrongs, as tax payers, consumers and voters we often make decisions that bear on these issues. I think it's worth bearing that in mind.
- hsitz 11y agoGood question. Someone else pointed out that _all_ societies have benefited from destroying the environment. I get the feeling they were pointing this out to argue that "we" (modern day Americans) don't really need to feel responsible. "Everybody does it, so it must be okay." I don't know what the answer is to the question of what actions I (and "we") should take because of my responsibility (and our shared responsibility). I do know that the responsibility I feel is greater the more tightly I am tied to a society or community. I don't feel much responsibility at all for homo sapiens' eradication of Neanderthals (assuming that's what happened). The actions happened too long ago and the "society" is too loose (homo sapiens). I do feel some responsibility for what my country's recent forebears have done; I feel a tie as an American and 100 or 200 years in the past is just a handful of generations. For me it seems the minimum is to identify myself as an "environmentalist". Many (most?) of the objections to proper care of the environment come from people who argue against it because doing so will lessen business profits by a little bit. Even assuming it's true that it will lessen profits, seems like we need to devote more of our resources to preserving the environment. At a minimum, that should mean that businesses in our society should have to accept somewhat lesser profits (perhaps by being taxed) in exchange for better preservation of the environment. Also, I have no problem with businesses that affect the environment negatively bearing much more of the cost to replace past harms. In the past, and even now, we've allowed businesses to pollute our environment (air, water, land) without them paying for the damage they've caused. They are among the prime offenders, although everyone does share some responsibility for being part of a society that's let those businesses operate as they have.
- 13thLetter 11y ago> Good question. Someone else pointed out that _all_ societies have benefited from destroying the environment. I get the feeling they were pointing this out to argue that "we" (modern day Americans) don't really need to feel responsible. "Everybody does it, so it must be okay." Not quite. What I was getting at is this argument is usually presented in the context of blaming the West generally or the United States specifically for various atrocities, and gently eliding how the societies which were aggressed upon were usually no different from a morality standpoint: it was simply a matter of who got to who first with a bigger stick in their hand. Not "everybody does it, so it must be okay," just "everybody does it, so casting blame on a specific group is, paradoxically, unfair." For that reason, our responsibility to properly safeguard the environment and to ensure the rights of all people cannot be dependent on one nation or culture atoning for some crime their ancestors allegedly committed in the past. That just builds a never-ending tower of recrimination and anger. It has to be simply our obligation as human beings to each other, right now, today.