3 ms·
"things like IPMI interfaces or SCADA devices the alternatives approache zero" My strategy with IPMI has been to assign IPMI non-routable, private IP addresses
by rsync 11y ago
"things like IPMI interfaces or SCADA devices the alternatives approache zero"
My strategy with IPMI has been to assign IPMI non-routable, private IP addresses, then block that address space at the interior of the network (which is sort of redundant) and then require folks to SSH onto an interior host and connect to IPMI that way.
I would be very interested in, and receptive to, criticisms of this model ...
- technion 11y agoIf you consider "ssh jump host" and "vpn" somewhat similar implementations of the same general strategy (forcing users to jump through something secure) we have a similar recommendation.
- nathwhal 11y agoIn my experience, IPMI is generally considered a part of the control plane, and not accessed via the same network as apps/data, but through a separate, more restricted/audited privatenetwork.
- lmm 11y agoThe argument there would be that it's very hard to secure all access to a network - anyone compromising any network device, or e.g. physical access to the cable runs in the building, then had access to IPMI. In a high security situation I'd keep the IPMI network physically segregated, with a small number of machines acting as access to it. Or maybe connect IPMI only within each (locked) rack, and require using something like ansible if you want to perform an operation across more than one rack. Whether the cost/benefit fits for your circumstances is another question of course.