4 ms·
Sexism is not "over-rated" OECD's Social Institutions and Gender Index Is at http://www.genderindex.org http://www.genderindex.org, and is a litany of baked in
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
Sexism is not "over-rated"
OECD's Social Institutions and Gender Index Is at http://www.genderindex.org http://www.genderindex.org, and is a litany of baked in prejudice, violence, lack of access to education, lack of access to property and other normal legal rights.
When we compare the lot of a 16 yo girl in Rwanda to a High schooler in SF, yes it is hard to find where the High schooler is having problems, but we just have to look at the ratio of men and women in tech to see there is a problem - even in modern, western, progressive San Francisco.
So globally, sexism is a violent oppressive force holding back progress for billions. In our happier world, it's waaaay better, but still not equal - and where there is inequality, there is profitable arbitrage opportunity. Both for talented women and for companies willing and able to introspect and overcome whatever is blocking their use of talented women.
The most obvious example I can see is I should be able to hire the very best development talent, for 80% of the price of the equivalent male talent ! Win!
- smikhanov 11y agoWhen we compare the lot of a 16 yo girl in Rwanda to a High schooler in SF, yes it is hard to find where the High schooler is having problems, but... You should have stopped at this "but". Do you seriously think that it's reasonable to put into the same basket the girls' problems in Rwanda and girls' problems in modern San Francisco?
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoNo it's not reasonable - that's the point. The OP came up with "sexism is overrated" - I wanted to point out that if you are a girl in large parts of the world that's a frankly laughable statement. It is also wrong in modern western world, but not to the same degree - but it is still measurably wrong to think sexism is over rated.
- marrs 11y agoI think it's fair to assume that the OP was speaking within the context of working in the IT industry
- adrianN 11y agoI'm still not convinced that the lack of women in tech is due to sexism. Maybe women just aren't as excited by the field as men? Nobody seems to question that this is the reason why there are so few male preschool teachers.
- rayiner 11y agoThere are so few male preschool teachers because our society is very sexist against men when it comes to interacting with kids. This is societal and not innate because in many other countries male teachers are the norm.
- tptacek 11y agoAre we really sexist against male teachers? I don't buy it. There are male teachers everywhere at all levels in Chicago, and male teachers are routinely represented in the media, usually positively.
- patio11 11y agoMuch like the existence of female engineers does not prove that the industry does not discriminate against women...
- tptacek 11y agoIt looks like there are twice as many male teachers as there are female engineers.
- janzer 11y agoIf I'm searching the BLS site correctly, nation wide 57% of secondary, 80% of primary, and 97% of preschool/kindergarten school teachers are women. [Edit: For comparison it shows 21% of computer programmers as women.]
- kencausey 11y agoIn these 'many other countries' are women as high of a percentage of the workforce as in the US? I personally believe that more women are teachers in the US because it is an occupation that is more open to them than many. Men simply have more options.
- facepalm 11y agoI find it a bit funny that they call it a "gender index", but it really just cares about discrimination against women. Way to go... Are girls equally likely as men to be recruited as child soldiers? Presumably their statistics won't show it... Also I think access of women to education in the third world might be a good indicator of economic and health care in those countries, not necessarily discrimination. If women are more like to die or be unable to work for extended periods of time because of childbirth, and you can only afford to send one of your kids to school, it just makes more sense to send the boy. It's unfair in a way, but not because people don't like girls, but because of biological and economic realities. As for women in tech: women have other options than going into tech. That might be all there is to it.
- DanBC 11y ago> Are girls equally likely as men to be recruited as child soldiers? Yes, girls are likely to be recruited as children. Sometimes that's as a child soldier, sometimes that's as a sex slave. Some armed groups see women (including girls) as equal to males. >> About 40 percent of the hundreds of thousands of child soldiers scattered across the world’s conflicts today are thought to be girls, but the numbers of girls enrolling in child soldier DDR programmes dwindles to five percent or less. http://www.irinnews.org/report/97463/analysis-girl-child-soldiers-face-new-battles-in-civilian-life http://www.irinnews.org/report/97463/analysis-girl-child-sol...
- facepalm 11y agoThank you for the statistics. My point, though, that a gender index should not just look at girls, still stands. "Male" is also a gender.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>I find it a bit funny that they call it a "gender index", but it really just cares about discrimination against women. Find all issues where women are worse off than men. Create an index to compare places all over the world. Update the index to remove areas where women are no longer worse off than men and to add any new ones where they are.
- jkot 11y agoPoor and oppressive countries (India, Ukraine, Saudi...) typically have more women in tech compared to western countries. There are not that many job options, and IT is often only reasonable option to get western salary.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- venomsnake 11y agoI am not quite sure why you lump Ukraine with the others.
- jkot 11y agoIt should be probably 'poor or...'. I was at Ukraine a few times. Tech is one of a few ways to make good money there.
- meowface 11y ago>OECD's Social Institutions and Gender Index Is at http://www.genderindex.org http://www.genderindex.org, and is a litany of baked in prejudice, violence, lack of access to education, lack of access to property and other normal legal rights. You have me. >When we compare the lot of a 16 yo girl in Rwanda to a High schooler in SF, yes it is hard to find where the High schooler is having problems, but we just have to look at the ratio of men and women in tech to see there is a problem - even in modern, western, progressive San Francisco. >So globally, sexism is a violent oppressive force holding back progress for billions. Yeah, you lost me. Not only are you comparing things of very different degrees, your second example doesn't even support your point. Of course sexism is a major problem in large parts of the world. But you completely failed to apply that to San Francisco. Evidence of an employment ratio difference, or even a wage gap (without careful controlling of as many variables as possible), is not necessarily evidence of sexism.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoEvidence of an employment ratio difference, or even a wage gap (without careful controlling of as many variables as possible), is not necessarily evidence of sexism. Yeah it is. Hear hooves, think horses, don't try too hard to eliminate zebras. EDIT: I am one the many reasons women don't like working (in tech). Friends of mine are at work, overly enthusiastic when engaging with female colleagues - nothing overt, nothing offensive, but noticeable. Smarmy perhaps. It's something most women at work seem to accept as normal if distasteful. I am reasonably certain I am on the smary spectrum. Problem is I don't tell my friends, so they don't tell me. And the fact that it has taken me till my forties to have sufficent self- knowledge indicates the world is full of guys like me - and that's not a world I want my daughters to work in. Edit2: perhaps a simpler approach - I get fed up watching people demand incontrovertible proof that they are part of the problem. If there are climate change deniers, there are sexism-is-a-problem deniers. (Yes of course the two problems are not of same magnitude, but the psychological issues at play are the same)
- meowface 11y ago>Yeah it is. Hear hooves, think horses, don't try too hard to eliminate zebras. Not sure what you're trying to say there. No studies have empirically gotten at the root causes of the gender gap. Sure, sexism probably accounts for some percentage of women deciding not to choose such a profession, but there's no evidence to think it's a predominant role. Sounds like you may be projecting your own attitude towards women onto others, possibly? I've never acted smarmy towards female coworkers, and haven't seen anyone else do so. Nor have I ever heard them complain about such a thing. Occasional social awkwardness; some older gentlemen being a little too eager to help (not in a smarmy way or with romantic/sexual overtones or anything like that, just polite "old-fashioned" behavior); but that's about it. That doesn't mean it hasn't happened to them, but if it did, they probably would have said something to someone if they felt it was a big enough issue. Of course, I can't speak for women in general; maybe a lot of them do deal with smarminess in the workplace. All I have are anecdotes. But your anecdote doesn't mean you can speak for them in general, either. Are there any blog posts or testimonies by women in tech who've discussed this that I could look at?