3 ms·
Running a bug bounty is not a suicide pact. A team had to convince a finance group that it was valuable to give money away to people who might be assholes. Bo
by droopybuns 11y ago
Running a bug bounty is not a suicide pact. A team had to convince a finance group that it was valuable to give money away to people who might be assholes. Bounty hunters are not a community- but if you are a bounty hunter, you should understand that many of your peers are total assholes. The company that wants to pay you a reward has to figure out if you are going to make them regret offering you a reward.
There are 4 categories of reporters: great, good, shit and crazy. Again- if you are a reporter, you should be trying to make it easy for the team to distinguish you in one of the first two categories by being simply being polite & respectful.
I will take a side- it's Facebook. Dumping data is the end of the Proof of Concept. Trying to determine if there is more data you can access through a single vulnerability chain is over the line.
Boats sink. The engineers know it. If you sink a boat in order to prove the boat had a hole, you will not get your payout.
And one final thought-
In my experience, bounty hunters almost never realize the full consequences of a vulnerability that receives a reward. Most of the time, the "Bad thing" that they identify is just the tip of the iceberg.
The choices of the researcher reflect inexperience and immaturity. The researcher has a significant misunderstanding about what is happening in the bug bounty marketplace. I think they need to apologize if they want a future in the infosec world.
Publishing this blog post was a huge error. Going to the journalist was another huge error. I don't see how this person could ever be considered employable by a reputable company.
- blazespin 11y agoAre you saying that if Wes hadn't pointed it out, than Alex wouldn't have to refresh all those keys? That if Wes hadn't dumped the keys than they were 100% secure?
- droopybuns 11y agoGood lord no. I am saying explicitly- Wes went past the point at which he should have stopped. He also should have known better, and the fact that he didn't is a problem in itself.
- dsacco 11y agoVery well said. This is a mature understanding of bug bounties.