6 ms·
Humans Caused a Major Shift in Earth's Ecosystems 6,000 Years Ago
- rubyfan 11y agothere's a creationism joke brewing somewhere right now
- andrewflnr 11y agoIt actually seems to have a tight tie-in to theistic evolution: Genesis 1-2 was a metaphor for the advent of agriculture.
- rubyfan 11y agoInteresting, do you have a reference for that? I've always found Genesis to be a beautiful poetic passage though I've never read it as having an alternate meaning.
- andrewflnr 11y agoNot really, it's just an idea. But it's at about the right time (6kya) to transition between evolutionary and biblical history. Both are about a transition from living off the land to tilling the soil, and the rise of civilization. If you can figure out how moral responsibility ties in, you have yourself a pretty theory, if not a rock-solid one.
- marincounty 11y agoI just happened to be reading The Emigrants' guide to Oregon and California. It was the guide that the Donner party used to take a short cut. The book doesn't embellish. (The Donner party took one sentence out of that guide, and made a mistake.) My reason for posting here is when the author was describing California; it was almost like reading fiction. The amount of wildlife was staggering. We were all told about the Bufflo, but there were so much more wildlife. Wildlife that we destroyed. One sentence really got to me. It stated, 'Salmon are 10 lbs. to 60 lbs.' I thought 60 lbs--it must be an exaggeration, but I think it's true.
- npongratz 11y ago> Wildlife that we destroyed. Who is "we"? I didn't do any of the destruction. Did you?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hsitz 11y agoThis comment is symptomatic of a lot of modern-day problems, especially in U.S. "We" are a society, a community. "You" don't exist alone. You couldn't exist without the benefits from human societies you live in. It's hypocritical and immoral to take the benefits of those societies, and then to disclaim participation in actions that society takes (or has taken), which are in part responsible for those benefits. American individualism is all well and good, but it gets carried way too far. For America is also a single society, and members of a society can't rationally accept the benefits of that society while disclaiming all participation in the actions that produced those benefits. I'm not saying "you" destroyed any wildlife. What I am saying is that (if you're American) you are reaping the benefits of a society that exists as it does because it dominated a continent, destroying much of the existing landscape and natural inhabitants. There is some level of responsibility that individuals have for prior actions taken by their society. Surely not as great a responsibility as if you'd done the actions yourself, or approved of the actions at the time they were taken. But some level of responsibility nonetheless (and when adding up the small responsibility of each current member the responsibility to do something as a group to rectify past wrongs may become quite large indeed).
- Spooky23 11y agoYou are reaping the benefits of slaughtering the Neanderthals and wiping out the mammoth. Shame on you.
- 13thLetter 11y ago> What I am saying is that (if you're American) you are reaping the benefits of a society that exists as it does because it dominated a continent, destroying much of the existing landscape and natural inhabitants. Every society on Earth exists as it does because it destroyed much of the previously existing landscape and natural inhabitants, most definitely including the Native American societies. If you read Over the Edge of the World, a fascinating book about Magellan's voyage around the globe, you'll find that as he traveled the straits at the southern tip of South America -- the most miserable, cold, dreary, and awful environment that could be imagined -- he met a miserable and starving aboriginal tribe: a tribe that, it turns out, had been pushed all the way to the tip of Tierra del Fuego by succeeding waves of "native" migration across the land bridge from Siberia to Alaska. The sin of the United States is not original with the United States: it is the sin of every society. > But some level of responsibility nonetheless (and when adding up the small responsibility of each current member the responsibility to do something as a group to rectify past wrongs may become quite large indeed). You could smuggle an elephant inside that parenthetical clause. For starters, how specifically is one to "rectify past wrongs" that were committed against people who have been dead for hundreds of years? And are the remnants of those societies that still exist today also obliged to "rectify past wrongs" against the people they aggressed on even farther in the past?
- jefurii 11y agoMaybe it had something to do with the "6,000-year-old temple with sacrificial altars discovered in Ukraine"? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10753820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10753820
- simonh 11y agoIn the sense that agriculture, as well as triggering the ecological changes discussed in this report also allowed the formation of dense populations capable of building structures like that, yes.