3 ms·
The usual criticism is that MBAs believe the degree endows them with far more strategic intelligence than they really have. It's like officer school. The worst
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
The usual criticism is that MBAs believe the degree endows them with far more strategic intelligence than they really have.
It's like officer school. The worst graduates come out absolutely convinced they can run an entire army, when in fact they're still almost completely clueless.
Aside from the networking - which is not trivial - the benefits of an MBA for talented individuals seem to be exposure to the idea that strategy, cost/benefit analysis, accounting, marketing, and the rest all exist, and are more relevant to a business than the code base.
This can be a surprise to straight CS people, many of whom only care about code.
But by analogy, many MBAs only seem to care about money.
There's more to running a successful business than the bottom line - or at least there should be - and more subtle management principles that build businesses by making customers and employees happy as well as making shareholders rich don't seem to figure at all in MBA schools.
The MBA point of view seems to be that happiness doesn't matter when there's profit to be made.
Ironically, there's a lot of poverty in that view - not just morally, but politically and economically. In the longer term it leads to the kind of economic picture we have today, where there's a lot of profit being made, but at the cost of rapidly shrinking broad prosperity and economic freedom for most of the population.
- anjc 11y agoI can't agree on your interpretation of an MBA point of view, but I will say that it does seem to be the most prevalent interpretation. Thinking solely about the bottom line could be the result of a twisted grounding in accounting, but no other course in an MBA relates to profit in any direct way. Almost every class typically/simply involves being grounded in decades of research in complicated areas. It seems to me that your interpretation is more of a criticism of public shareholding and the duties of the board. Coincidentally, board members in public companies may be MBAs, and their consultants may be MBAs, but the Masters isn't why they're pursuing profit. Lastly, I had whole courses on the happiness of employees (Organisational Behaviour, HR), but like Strategy and Marketing and every other class, they were extremely theoretical and totally unrelated to practicalities of business such as profit.
- stvswn 11y agoHaha cracking up over here. I went to West Point, was an officer, got an MBA and now I work at a big tech company. I must really suck.