5 ms·
Some people are misunderstanding what this report means by "bad luck", which isn't surprising because this BBC report is lousy, and it follows on from a differe
by DanBC 11y ago
Some people are misunderstanding what this report means by "bad luck", which isn't surprising because this BBC report is lousy, and it follows on from a different paper that said something different and that was also poorly reported.
This older report suggested that two thirds of cancer was because of random mutation, rather than genetic predisposition or lifestyle.
Here's an example of the confusing way that older study was reported: http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jan/02/two-thirds-adult-cancers-bad-luck http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jan/02/two-thirds-ad...
> Two-thirds of adult cancers, say the researchers from the Johns Hopkins Kimmel Cancer Center in the United States, are caused by random mutation in the tissue cells during the ordinary process of stem cell division. In the other third, our genetic inheritance and lifestyles are the main factors.
> The scientists have created a mathematical model which, they say, shows it is wrong to assume that there are such things as “good genes” that may prevent us getting cancer even though we smoke, drink heavily and carry excessive weight.
This new study disputes that, and says that normal random mutation only accounts for 10% to 30% of cancer, and the rest is because of lifestyle or genetic predisposition.
From a public health point of view that's pretty important. Stop smoking, and control how much alcohol you drink, continue to be important public health messages to reduce the incidence of cancer.
- williamjennings 11y agoWhen you translate "Bad Luck" or 'Unlucky" into Confucian-era Chinese, the term is respectively equivocal to poverty or impoverished. "Random mutation" is vaguely technical enough to have the same connotation in the public lexicon. The term does not have specific meaning in molecular biology, so it might as well be superstition. The risk factors are there because we do not do enough to care for each other as individuals in society. The statistics are the tool used for trading liabilities in the applied oncological epidemiology colloquially referred to as health insurance risk modeling.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoCite? It's not "Confucian-era Chinese", but google translate gives : 倒霉 which per wiktionary (https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/倒 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/倒 and https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/霉 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/霉) I don't see anything relating to poverty or impoverishment.
- williamjennings 11y agoIt does not seem like you understand the historical context of written Chinese; or the importance of social class within Confucianism. You would be better off reading a textbook on the sociology of ancient China; instead of abusing google translate. Jared Diamond would be a good author to start reading from, if you are unfamiliar with the topic. My primary source has been Chinese friends, and they have explained that "Bad Luck" is one example of a regressive tradition which was abolished during the cultural revolution. It is my opinion that the phrase "Bad Luck" is a conditional mood of impoverishment. In the third person, it is a superstitious euphemism which detaches the speaker from empathy. There are also languages where the concept does not exist at all.
- KhalilK 11y ago>Stop smoking, and control how much alcohol you drink, continue to be important public health messages to reduce the incidence of cancer. That obviously depends on the type of cancer. Smokers are way more likely to get lung cancer but for other types of cancer with high mortality rates (prostate, breast, myeloma, lymphoma etc) there is no single attributable 'exposure' that is known to be the cause.
- teach 11y agoI would disagree that there's no "exposure" component for many of those other cancers. * Eating red meat * Eating processed meat * Drinking 3+ glasses of milk daily * Inadequate levels of vitamin D These are all well-known to the nutrition community to increase cancer risk.
- JshWright 11y agoScience in the "nutrition community" is really not very good (this isn't surprising... it's hard to control what people eat (even willing study participants), and even harder to blind anyone involved). Nutrition research is almost entirely based on cohort studies, which are certainly valuable in helping our understanding, but are not great at rigorously proving anything. This isn't a slight on the field of nutrition research, it's just a really hard problem to solve. Much harder than many people tend to think... I think it's overstating it a bit so say those things are "well-known". There are some indications that those things may result in slight increases of risk for certain types of cancer.
- teach 11y agoMy wife has a PhD in nutrition, so I don't think it's overstating things at all. We're well-aware of how nutrition studies are done and their limitations, but these are clear results shown in study after study for years. I would seriously question the credentials of any PhD nutrition researcher at a decent university that disputed any of those factors.
- wordbank 11y ago
- Retric 11y agoCancer requires more than a single mutation. Also, "They did not look at tissues from two of the commonest forms of cancer – breast and prostate" this is not an accurate description of 'cancer' just the types of cancer they are studying. Further, this is focused on types of tissue. Environmental factors that increase risks for all forms of cancer are ignored. PS: Mathematically, if a very small percentage of the population had much lower risks of cancer it would be almost impossible to detect.