5 ms·
Robotic exploration is far far greater value for money than human exploration.
by andrewstuart 11y ago
Robotic exploration is far far greater value for money than human exploration.
- adrianN 11y agoThat depends on your value function. If you want to do science then yes, robots probably provide more bang for the buck. If you want to get at least some eggs out of the basket that is Earth, eventually you have to send up humans.
- andrewstuart 11y agoBelieving that humans can ever colonise off earth in any way that is sustainable is like believing in sasquach or UFO's or the easter bunny.
- adrianN 11y agoWhat makes you say that? I see nothing impossible about building a self sustaining colony on, say, Mars.
- serge2k 11y agoThat's a completely ridiculous statement and I don't see how you can back it up.
- andrewstuart 11y agoRadiation for one, but apart from that, in 2015 we don't even go beyond low earth orbit and we'll just have to wait and see but I'm guessing that no one will ever go to Mars. No actual people have gone to Mars because its prohibitively expensive but also so incredibly unbelievably hard technically it will never happen. Also undesirable. Why the heck would we want to colonise Mars? It's a desert where we can't live without life support. It's just sci fi to imagine we can or that it would be of value or sustainable. Earth is our home and will be forever.
- fsloth 11y agoAs per the difficulty and cost of space travel - it took in the order of hundreds of years of development for several impactful technologies to be tinkered and optimized to a point where they started to make a difference. Steam engines, mechanical watches, etc. E.g. the first watches that could keep time to assist in measurement of the longitude were incredibly expensive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Harrison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Harrison. I know historical arguments are usually kinda weak but objectively - space flight is still a young discipline. I hope you respect that in historical perspective "we've never done it and so won't ever do it" is really weak. It will require empirical testing to figure out if spacefaring human civilization is a tenable concept. Large system cannot be reasoned with beforehand (well, if there are deep physical principles that are obvious then, yeah, sure, but at this point the problem space appears like more like a complex expensive mess of many uknowns rather than a physical impossibility).
- fsloth 11y agoPhysiologically, humans need shelter from the elements, a breathable atmosphere and nutrients. All of those are engineering problems. What happens to a human body when it's spent long time in zero-g? I have no idea. Can humans survive psychologically away from earth? Quite a many of us spend quite a lot of time just watching screens so the tiny boxes of first generation colonists might be livable. If we belive physiological and psychological survival is feasible, then the only matter left considering I think is acquisition of raw materials and bootstrapping a colony-based industry. I have no idea of the chemical composition of say, mars, and does is have all of the elements we need for our precious technology. But I would imagine earth is not the only place in the solar system with abundance of the all of the important ones. This last one is a bit of an unknown to me but otherwise you would need to convince me pretty hard that colonization is not a feasible concept.
- bkeroack 11y agoEvery aspect of human physiology is highly dependent upon the very specific (and, as far as we currently know, unique) conditions found on Earth. Everything from the salinity of our bodily fluids to the atmospheric pressure and composition we need to breathe, the minerals we require in our diet, even exposure to sunlight and the diurnal day/night cycle. At the risk of sounding metaphysical, we are as much a part of the Earth as your kidney is a part of your body. Yes, we probably can take your kidney out and keep it alive via artificial means for a certain period of time (it's just an engineering problem) but it is a rather large leap to do so permanently. It's worth asking whether the effort even makes sense.
- fsloth 11y agoYeah, I see your angle. However, I'm writing this north of the 60 parallel and my country survives quite well in these conditions although they are quite different than the african savannahs native to our species. Although on a dark and wet december evening, I do wonder what my ancestors were thinking coming this much north. For a human baby, the womb is the physiologically most natural growth environment. At birth we are separated from our mothers and the comforting heartbeat fades away to other noises. If I may respond to your methaphysical idea: perhaps earth is the womb of a space faring species, and our offspring will longingly observe it through telescopes like a person always misses her parents. But a longing does not incapacitate us, it merely tints the daily experience with a hint of bittersweet. But in practice - human space flight at a large scale is a messy subject and like most topics of systemantics it will require endless amount of tinkering to even figure out if the idea is valid.
- PeterisP 11y agoIf we accept the premise that humans can't ever colonise off earth, then we should not fund robotic missions as well, since that assumption makes all space exploration and the science there pointless in the first place. The point of organized missions to gather data from, say, Mars is that this data will help future human space travel efforts. If we accept that we're not going to do that ever then all the current activities are worthless and we can just stop them right now.
- jcranmer 11y agoNo. Understanding what's different about Martian geology and Earth geology, for example, can help us refine models of solar system construction, which in turn can refine how you model the Big Bang and the elapsed time of the universe.
- ceejayoz 11y agoAnd what's the point of that if our single-planet civilization is going to get wiped out by the next big asteroid?
- jcranmer 11y agoAnd what's the point of doing anything if you're gonna die in 70 years anyways? Just as most people can find value in doing things despite knowing that their ultimate life is rather short and finite, it's possible to extract value from doing research without trying to force it to be about a race surviving infinitely long.
- andrewstuart 11y agoI don't agree that the only value of space exploration is as precursor to sending people.
- adrusi 11y agoWell, no, those beliefs are beliefs that things exist without any evidence. Beliving that humans can colonize another planet is a belief that something can be accomplished that we currently have no idea how to do. 200 years ago, there were no UFO beliefs and no "easter bunny" as we know it today, but there were sasquatch legends. The claims are as unsubstantiated today as they were then. 200 years ago some people believed the humanity could one day visit the moon. At the time they had no idea how, but 200 years later we have not only gone to the moon but become bored by it. But I also don't see why you don't think we could establish a martian colony even with the technology we have today. I suppose I don't know what you mean by "sustainable," and if you mean truly terraforming the whole planet to make it a second earth, you're right that that is still the realm of science fiction. But you don't need that. All you need is a large climate-controlled enclosure with hydroponic farming equipment. The martian atmosphere contains enough oxygen (0.14%) to keep this enclosure supplied, and water exists on mars, certainly in solid form. Such an enclosure would be sufficient for a person to live an entire lifetime without assistance from earth, which is a reasonable criteria for sustainability. The project would be economically possible, but probably politically impractical.
- danieltillett 11y agoThis depends on your aim and what you consider value. There is also the point that robotic exploration is only politically supportable on the back of human exploration. Even the very rich and powerful have dreamt about being personally involved in human space exploration.
- SCHiM 11y agoThis might be true, but you should also consider that sending humans up is more challenging. And if science rises to the challenge we will learn more from sending humans than from sending robots.
- Shivetya 11y agoI think this only holds true until the technology catches up. Twenty years ago the moon was probably best still observed and such with probes, but now as the number of options increase for how we can get there it might be viable to put people there permanently; provided private or government justification can be proven. The moon problem I see is, what happens when a private company decides to make a profit off of the resources there? Pretty sure every government is going to scream bloody murder all the while trying to do the same but expecting their stance; as governments; to be more important. Should be an interesting time for rights when that occurs
- Symmetry 11y agoAs the technology for easier human travel improves so does the technology for smarter and more mobile robots.
- mattmanser 11y agoI'm tired of seeing this post in any space exploration thread that involves humans. I don't think it's on topic any more.
- jerf 11y agoThis opinion was born and raised in an environment of government funding for space. There is no fundamental reason why it should cost dozens of billions of dollars to get to space. If private industry brings it down to a cost more related to the true, fundamental price, it goes flying out the window. Merely millions to put people in space is of a kind with oil exploration, building transport networks, and all sorts of other situations where private industry under solid government routinely invest by the millions or even billions. At that point the argument actually completely flips around; anywhere we can afford to put a human, it is more cost-effective to do so than send a robot.
- adrusi 11y agoThis is wrong. The fact is we take our humans back, but leave our robots in space. It's harder and more expensive to prepare a return voyage, and the robots can ultimately spend more time in space and for some applications that means it will be more effective at gathering data.
- jerf 11y ago"Anywhere we can afford to put a human", and I'll remind you, that's under the new, wildly cheaper domain of space flight, not the current one. If only a robot is affordable at all, there's no debate about which is "better". Clearly that is not the argument being made, though, because then there's no point in even repeating the line about robots being more cost effective. If space flight is cheap, you're better off sending a far more capable human than a robot, because if you're going to spend $3million for a robot or $5million for a human, the human is going to be more than 40% more effective than a robot. It's a totally different story than when the difference is $12billion or $500billion.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoAndrew's point is taken. But human exploration requires so much technology just to make space survivable that there are huge ancillary payoffs. At the end of the day, space is R&D. We can develop (and have developed) wonderful robotic missions and we should absolutely continue to do so. But we owe it to the world and ourselves to continue to research safer and cheaper ways to get humans to space. Eventually, there will be cities up there, and a trip to the moon or an orbital station will be just a bit more complex than a flight from London to Tokyo. But it's not going to happen without the necessary hard work and financial investment up front. Also worth noting -- if we (U.S.) don't do it, China is still planning to put humans on the moon. We can watch and admire, or we can be in the race. Which would you rather?