3 ms·

Source?

nostromo 11y ago
Here's a famous paper on the subject. It's not a new paper, it's from 1977. http://people.virginia.edu/~tdw/nisbett&wilson.pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~tdw/nisbett&wilson.pdf In short, people often have no idea why they chose to do what they did. However, when asked, "why did you choose to do that?" they will rarely say, "I don't know" but will instead concoct stories that explain their choices -- explanations that are often wrong.
- SCHiM 11y ago
  This is something you will hear from disinterested teens too when their teachers try to make them vocalize their opinions on some school subject: Teacher: What did you think about <subject> Teen: I think it's fun Teacher: Why do you think it's 'fun', just saying it's 'fun' is not a valid opinion. Teen: Because it engages my curiosity and I want to learn more about <subject> Teacher: That's good, you shou... Later you'll hear the pupil complaining, that such exercises are pointless, because the second clarification of the pupil's opinion is just as circular and empty as the initial declaration of 'fun'. You can play this game to infinity, and you will never get to the point that any words have any real intrinsic value.
- personlurking 11y ago
  "but will instead concoct stories that explain their choices" Piggybacking on SCHiM's comment, and changing "choices" to "beliefs", this is also something you will learn from looking at tribal societies (creation myths, etc). Now I'm reminded of this clip from the Star Trek TNG episode Who Watches the Watchers (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uii5WrmChbE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uii5WrmChbE)
Consultant32452 11y ago
If you find this subject interesting I'd like to suggest Sam Harris' "Free Will."
- marklgr 11y ago
  I'd rather suggest "Four Views on Free Will"[1], much more in touch with the state of the art and not difficult to read. [1]: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1405134860 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1405134860
  - 55555 11y ago
    For those who don't want to drop $30 on a kindle book (don't feel bad, it's not really your choice) the Sam Harris YouTube video is pretty good and has nothing to do with his views on Islam(ism).

Source?

Here's a famous paper on the subject. It's not a new paper, it's from 1977. http://people.virginia.edu/~tdw/nisbett&wilson.pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~tdw/nisbett&wilson.pdf In short, people often have no idea why they chose to do what they did. However, when asked, "why did you choose to do that?" they will rarely say, "I don't know" but will instead concoct stories that explain their choices -- explanations that are often wrong.

SCHiM 11y ago
This is something you will hear from disinterested teens too when their teachers try to make them vocalize their opinions on some school subject: Teacher: What did you think about <subject> Teen: I think it's fun Teacher: Why do you think it's 'fun', just saying it's 'fun' is not a valid opinion. Teen: Because it engages my curiosity and I want to learn more about <subject> Teacher: That's good, you shou... Later you'll hear the pupil complaining, that such exercises are pointless, because the second clarification of the pupil's opinion is just as circular and empty as the initial declaration of 'fun'. You can play this game to infinity, and you will never get to the point that any words have any real intrinsic value.
personlurking 11y ago
"but will instead concoct stories that explain their choices" Piggybacking on SCHiM's comment, and changing "choices" to "beliefs", this is also something you will learn from looking at tribal societies (creation myths, etc). Now I'm reminded of this clip from the Star Trek TNG episode Who Watches the Watchers (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uii5WrmChbE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uii5WrmChbE)

Consultant32452 11y ago

If you find this subject interesting I'd like to suggest Sam Harris' "Free Will."

marklgr 11y ago
I'd rather suggest "Four Views on Free Will"[1], much more in touch with the state of the art and not difficult to read. [1]: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1405134860 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1405134860
- 55555 11y ago
  For those who don't want to drop $30 on a kindle book (don't feel bad, it's not really your choice) the Sam Harris YouTube video is pretty good and has nothing to do with his views on Islam(ism).