8 ms·
Why I Captured This MRI of a Mother and Child
- vilhelm_s 11y agoAnswer: "This particular MR image, though, was not made for diagnostic purposes, nor even really for science. No one, to my knowledge, had ever made an MR image of a mother and child. We made this one because we wanted to see it." The question I was wondering about is "how did she get two million dollars to buy a 3-tesla MRI machine". And the answer is, be a professor at MIT. (http://saxelab.mit.edu/ http://saxelab.mit.edu/)
- omginternets 11y ago"Because I had to use up my leftover grant money, and my students already had new office chairs." Edit: downvoters have clearly never worked in a university research environment.
- randlet 11y agoI'm not sure if you're trying to imply something negative about this project or not, but there are many many research MRI's around and it's not completely unreasonable to spare 15 min of MRI time for something like this.
- carlob 11y agoYeah, it's not like they are disposable machines that get thrown away after one scan.
- acveilleux 11y agoHell, most research magnets spend a fair bit of time idle, it's often possible to get that time for "free" for a variety of reasons like no show test subjects.
- vilhelm_s 11y agoI don't have anything negative to say about "the project" but I think the headline is kindof stupid; surely there is no great mystery. Of course she wants an MRI-picture of herself, I would love to have one too, wouldn't everyone? But few people are in a position to get one.
- cafebeen 11y agoIt's easy and cheap to get an MRI by volunteering to participate in an imaging research study. You can typically ask for the data, and they will actually pay you for your time.
- TorKlingberg 11y agoNeat, but clickbait.
- Sevrene 11y agoWhy I captured this MRI of a mother and child? Because I can. /article
- knowaveragejoe 11y agoThe negativity in this thread is really a shame. I would expect better from HN. > This particular MR image, though, was not made for diagnostic purposes, nor even really for science. No one, to my knowledge, had ever made an MR image of a mother and child. We made this one because we wanted to see it. > To some people, this image was a disturbing reminder of the fragility of human beings. Others were drawn to the way that the two figures, with their clothes and hair and faces invisible, became universal, and could be any human mother and child, at any time or place in history. Still others were simply captivated by how the baby’s brain is different from his mother’s; it’s smaller, smoother and darker—literally, because there’s less white matter.
- smoyer 11y agoI'd be really interested to see the difference in the brain activity when they're "embracing" versus when they're placed separately in the scanner.
- irremediable 11y agoNot sure how much you know about neuroimaging, but in case you don't know, it might be worth my pointing out that this is a structural image -- i.e. it doesn't measure "brain activity" in any way, only brain shape. The same scanner could take functional BOLD measurements, of course.
- smoyer 11y agoI know next-to-nothing about neuroimaging (and I didn't even stay in a Holiday-Inn Express last night). I was wondering why there were no bright patches like other MRIs I've seen - thanks for the explanation.
- moron4hire 11y agoThis is exactly what photography is supposed to be.
- sandworm101 11y agoSo this is meant as art? Ok. It should be judged as art. It's junk art. Another madonna. Big deal. The image of mother and child has been done to death in every medium. Doing it again in a new one isn't saying much. The author picked a subject to trigger a boringly predictable emotional response. It is as much art as the latest kittens meet puppies youtube sensation. Leave the art to actual artists. If you want your medical machine to create art, allocate some time for artists. Treat it like every other mother treats a sonogram. Put in on the mantle, not the internet. Don't waste time/money/helium on hack projects in an attempt to generate news.
- xenophonf 11y agoLeave the art to actual artists. The people who create junk Madonnas and cat videos and whatnot are artists every bit as much as the first person who scratched stick figures on a cave wall or the masters whose works reside in museums and galleries around the world. They might be novices. They might be amateurs. They might not create something you like. But they are still "actual" artists.
- sandworm101 11y agoFine. I'll correct my words. Leave costly and expensive art to the good artists. Get a paints set. Buy a camera. Leave the million-dollar paintbrushes to those non-novice artists able to create something interesting.
- trcollinson 11y agoIn the words of Mel Brooks in the History of the World Part 1: And here, in a cave, about 2 million years ago, the first artist was born. And, of course, with the birth of the artist, came the inevitable after birth... The critic. Lest I get down voted for bringing humor to a comment on Hacker News, I will make the further point. Are your comments meant to be art criticism? Ok. They should be judged as art criticism. You say it's "another madonna" as if all madonna's are junk art. Many of the madonna's are the most studied religious iconography and artistic masterpieces of all time. Almost all of the most renowned artists in history have completed a madonna. Who is to say it has been done to death in every medium? Are you attempting to say that no artist can come along and make a new masterpiece madonna? And frankly, you'll have to argue much harder to make people believe that the madonna has been done to death in every medium, particularly MR images. As for your argument that million-dollar paintbrushes should be left to non-novice artists to create something interesting. We create art with what we have on hand. This person happens to have a 3 tesla MRI machine. Why shouldn't they use it? If another artist would like to come along and use it, they can work with the university that holds it to use it. What a horrible argument to say that because they are a novice they should not be allowed to use such a beautiful tool for their own artistic enjoyment.
- Faint 11y agoWhat grabs my attention is how the baby's skull absolutely chock-full of brain - there doesn't seem to be any "cushioning" fluid space between the skull and the brain like the mother (like most adults, I'd assume) has.