2 ms·
Most driving is fairly routine, but without strong AI I don't see how a self driving car can handle things like: There is a car accident on the side of the roa
by ars 11y ago
Most driving is fairly routine, but without strong AI I don't see how a self driving car can handle things like:
There is a car accident on the side of the road, and there is a human cop waving cars one at a time to drive past on the wrong side of the road.
I am part of a funeral procession, or a police escorted parade and I need to drive through red lights in order to stay in the procession. (That at least I know from the start to take manual control - except google wants a car with no wheel, and in a world with lots of such cars people won't know how to drive.)
Or, there is an ambulance behind me sirens wailing and in order to get out of the way I must drive illegally for a moment (through a red light, or on the wrong side of the road).
How about something as simple as driving the car up some ramps so I can service the car. How would you do that without both a steering wheel and experience in how to drive?
I don't see how a self driving car can handle any of those.
- cheez 11y agoSelf-driving cars should only need to handle 90% of driving tasks. For the rest, a qualified human can and should be required to take over.
- ars 11y agoThat leaves humans without enough experience to actually know how to drive. It takes years of driving to get good at it. If people drove only 1/10 as much as now no one would ever get good at it. It's called "The Paradox of Automation" and it's a huge problem. Basically the better the Automation the less often humans do anything, but it means that when humans do have to do something it's much much more critical than usual. Which is exactly the situations the humans have no experience with since they take control so rarely. Basically some automation is good, but a lot of automation is actually detrimental to safety. For each industry you have to calculate that cutoff point and do no further automation past that point, until you are able to reach 100% perfection.