3 ms·
Does 'rationalisation' have some strange meaning in this context that I'm unfamiliar with? As far as I'm concerned any view justifying the matter is a rational
by OJFord 11y ago
Does 'rationalisation' have some strange meaning in this context that I'm unfamiliar with?
As far as I'm concerned any view justifying the matter is a rationalisation, left or right wing politically; agree or disagree it's certainly nothing to be upset about being called a rationalisation.
- tome 11y ago"Rationalisation" has a negative connotation.
- i80and 11y agoSpecifically, it typically has a connotation of ex post facto.
- OJFord 11y agoAre you British? (I'm picking up on the 's', not sure if you're just quoting me). It seems others commenting on negative connotation are all American, but personally I would only consider it thus in the form of a question: > Oh yes? How do you rationalise that then? The answer to which is a statement of facts - how it is that I deem whatever 'that' is to be rational. I would proffer it stems from an assumption that we are rational beings (uh-oh) which may suggest that the very fact it's questionable implies it is incorrect; but we're not rational, people differ - the one thing we all have in common is that we tend to think our own actions rational. Hence "my rationalisation" is neutral; "your rationalisation" has a negative --ahem-- ex post facto connotation.
- josinalvo 11y agoRationalization is usually said when the conclusion comes first, and the "reasoning" latter. First you decide what you think, then why. This "reasoning" is considered suspect, and called a rationalization.
- dang 11y ago"So convenient a thing it is to be a reasonable creature, since it enables one to find or make a reason for everything one has a mind to do." http://www.ushistory.org/franklin/autobiography/page18.htm http://www.ushistory.org/franklin/autobiography/page18.htm
- OJFord 11y agoThis is what I mean below [0] really - I think the doubt cast on the validity of the thought/decision/thing being rationalised it is asked of someone else. My rationalisation is just what I think makes it rational. No negative connotations here. "How do you rationalise that, then?" is where the doubt creeps in. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10748700 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10748700
- isolate 11y agoWhat's interesting is that this is actually how the human brain works. It was in the news and stuff a while ago.
- OJFord 11y agoHa. I see it now. For some reason on first read I took the author to have hard-left views and objected to the thought that a right-winged attitude might dare to deem something rational. I think I just presumed someone blogging about being discriminated against for political views would have left-wing political views. I didn't really realise US academia was so skewed left politically; completely misread the subtext.
- dragonwriter 11y agoA rationalization -- as distinct from a reason -- is an story to explain an act/decision which is not the actual motivation/reason for the person offering the explanation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationalization_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationalization_(psychology)
- munchbunny 11y agoRationalization comes with the connotation that you are justifying something that is incorrect. You can "rationalize" a correct idea, but that's not common usage. The word is almost always used to imply that you're wrong and refuse to acknowledge it. So you could use the word "rationalize" neutrally, but most people don't use it that way and don't take it that way.