5 ms·
Congress has broad authority to make the law the way they see fit. A lot of what we think of as the "normal" way to pass laws, are just traditions and rules tha
by snowwrestler 11y ago
Congress has broad authority to make the law the way they see fit. A lot of what we think of as the "normal" way to pass laws, are just traditions and rules that Congress sets for itself.
Those traditions and rules are good, which is why they exist in the first place. But they're not really binding or legally required.
Which, if you think about it, makes sense. Congress is the ultimate lawmaking authority in the land--who is going to tell Congress what they can't do? The only answers are the Constitution and the voters. The Constitution sets some limits on powers, but doesn't micromanage process. And the voters tend to care about issues, not process.
For CISA specifically, it had already passed both houses; adding it to the omnibus does not accomplish anything that was not already going to happen anyway. The text changes that tptacek details so thoroughly are the sorts of things that could easily happen in conference committee. Sticking it into the omnibus is mostly a matter of convenience at this point.
In the end, Congressional leaders negotiated the omnibus, will allow it on the floor, and the full Congress will vote on it. This is the same bar than any piece of legislation must get over on its own.
And there were nasty bills that did not make it into the omnibus, like de-funding Planned Parenthood.
- abannin 11y agoThere is a significant difference between bundling a bill into a high stakes omnibus such as the budget and passing it individually. It's much easier to stand up and say "I voted against a single bill" then "I voted against the budget and shut down the government". It's a strong arm negotiation tactic to force members to vote against their position on a less important issue. This is the same reason that so much pork gets thrown into the large bills.
- joering2 11y agoI +1 you because it was educational to me, but I'm seriously asking: why you said "nasty" bills like de-funding PP ? edit: tpacek, Im not asking him in terms of his own opinion, but rather what "nasty" he found in those bills. His post was very informative that's why I asked. I couldn't care less what he thinks about the subject of PP.
- tptacek 11y agoPlease not here.
- snowwrestler 11y ago"Nasty" is just my personal opinion about the efforts to defund PP. And plenty of people here think CISA is nasty. A more neutral word to make the same point would be "controversial." I probably should have written that instead.
- oldmanjay 11y ago> Those traditions and rules are good, which is why they exist in the first place. This is unsupported by evidence or reason.