9 ms·
If you want to stimulate aggregate demand at the consumer level, you need more people to have good jobs, so they can make money, so they can spend money. This w
by dsr_ 11y ago
If you want to stimulate aggregate demand at the consumer level, you need more people to have good jobs, so they can make money, so they can spend money. This would represent a reversal of the trend since 1970 towards greater income inequality.
It is not clear to me that anyone is doing anything about that (except, of course, in the negative sense.)
- toomuchtodo 11y agoExactly correct. The Federal Reserve has the knobs and levers to create asset bubbles, but not to stoke consumer demand. Only Congress can do that with legislation increasing the minimum wage, changing corporate taxes so it behooves companies to pay employees more, or legislation increasing entitlements such as social security. Those in lower and middle classes are the ones who govern the velocity of money through the economy, not the most wealthy. https://youtu.be/iJCcoF5K0SM?t=19m https://youtu.be/iJCcoF5K0SM?t=19m
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoincreasing the minimum wage Be careful what you wish for: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/how-effective-is-the-minimum-wage-at-supporting-the-poor.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/how... legislation increasing entitlements such as social security Expected to run structural deficits by a certain point. Theoretically speaking, an endogenously determined fiat money system doesn't really have "government debt" what with it being the sovereign issuer of debt to begin with, but in reality politics and the economy don't exist in frictionless vacuums and there are political costs to pork barreling, logrolling, unsound investments and so forth.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI argue my ideas only need to hold water for another 10-30 years, depending on if technology advancement keeps up. Japan's been running structural deficits for decades, and still has a very high quality of life. > but in reality politics and the economy don't exist in frictionless vacuums and there are political costs to pork barreling, logrolling, unsound investments and so forth. As basic minimum income solves this without the messy politics surrounding it.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI argue my ideas only need to hold water for another 10-30 years, depending on if technology advancement keeps up. Given that the AI community's prediction making skills have been just slightly better than those of Nostradamus, that's a very tough gambit to rely on. Japan's been running structural deficits for decades, and still has a very high quality of life. Except for the aftermath of the whole Lost Decade thing and aging population taking tolls on aggregate productivity. I'm not qualified enough to say whether causes were monetary, fiscal, sociological or some combination thereof, but listing Japan as a positive example here doesn't strike me as wise. As basic minimum income solves this without the messy politics surrounding it. UBI would theoretically handle a minimum transfer of purchasing power for every individual. We're talking about public programs and initiatives unrelated to that. Though, if you're idealistic enough to think the UBI is a prospect soon realizable, I wonder why you're advocating minimum wage increases over say, stronger collective bargaining? Denmark for instance has never had a minimum wage law.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> > I argue my ideas only need to hold water for another 10-30 years, depending on if technology advancement keeps up. > Given that the AI community's prediction making skills have been just slightly better than those of Nostradamus, that's a very tough gambit to rely on. That's a weird comment; "technology" is a lot broader than "AI".
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI made some perhaps overly hasty generalizations. HN is a community that is heavily skewed towards a belief in transhumanism (especially that AGI will be coming very soon) and moreover that high rates of technological unemployment are upon us, necessitating a UBI or stronger reforms to make sure the general-purpose labor saving of AGI doesn't cause social unrest from crowding humans out of the labor market. I can't imagine what else could the GP have been referring to other than mass automatized labor for most sectors, hence either AGI or lots of narrow AI.
- ap22213 11y agoSo, the alternative is what? Allow wages to move toward zero? Then what?
- theseatoms 11y agoA global minimum income. Or the strictly-superior-to-a-minimum-wage Earned Income Tax Credit [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earned_income_tax_credit
- creshal 11y agoWhy is it superior? That looks a lot like making the government subsidize worker exploitation.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoHow does a negative income tax subsidize any of that? If anything, it's much more neutral regarding wage labor (since it's based on the broader definition of income in tax codes) than, obviously, minimum wage mandates.
- Yrlec 11y agohttp://www.wsj.com/articles/better-than-raising-the-minimum-wage-1432249927 http://www.wsj.com/articles/better-than-raising-the-minimum-...
- eru 11y agoAllow competetion to set the wages, just like all other prices. Singapore doesn't have a minimum, and wages there are not zero. (Neither did Germany until recently.)
- crdoconnor 11y agoSingapore wages aren't zero but they are really low for the non-managerial classes (i.e. the people who do all the work) and oversized for the managerial classes. It's about 3x the size of San Francisco and clearly has aspirations of becoming a similar center for startups but with the prevailing wages for the people who do all the actual work so low the quality of what is produced is usually shitty. It's not a place you'd want to emulate.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "increasing the minimum wage Be careful what you wish for: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/how-effective-is-the-minimum-wage-at-supporting-the-poor.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/how... " Let's look at what is being said: "Unlike most public income support programs, increased earnings from the minimum wage are taxable. Over 25 percent of the increased earnings are collected back as income and payroll taxes" Is that a problem? The minimum wage should be the minimum needed to live on, that includes taking taxes into consideration. " Adopting this empirical scenario, the analysis demonstrates that an increase in the national minimum wage produces a value-added tax effect on consumer prices that is more regressive than a typical state sales tax and allocates benefits as higher earnings nearly evenly across the income distribution." So the argument is that raising the minimum wage increases prices, thereby negating the potential benefits. Here's the thing, competition drives prices down, but if low wage earners have limited options to shop around (because they look towards the big chains to get low prices), then competition can't fulfil this function. This quote would seem to support this view: "Even after taxes, 27.6 percent of increased earnings go to families in the top 40 percent of the income distribution."
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoCompetition drives prices down, but chances are people with limited options to shop around and who disproportionately head towards mass retailers already, by example, live in areas with imperfect competition and in the worst case, food deserts. As such, a minimum wage would seem to negate itself again.
- eru 11y ago> Competition drives prices down, [...] Tell that to Google and Facebook bidding on programmers.. Or people trying to buy real estate in London.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoThe competition in Google and Facebook's case isn't "programmers", but "exceptionally skilled programmers," which is a different good, a much scarcer one and with less diminishing returns than the former. I'm not aware of the real estate situation in London to make a comment.
- gohrt 11y agoForm the linked article: > allocates benefits as higher earnings nearly evenly across the income distribution OK by me. Note that it doesn't allocate benefit to idle owners f investment income. > Even after taxes, 27.6 percent of increased earnings go to families in the top 40 percent of the income distribution. "top 40%" is rather silly bucket. That includes basically the median family, all the way to billionaires. > Over 25 percent of the increased earnings are collected back as income and payroll taxes (aka effectively a tax on businesses that pay the minimum wage) It takes massive concern trolling to argue that this effect is worst than not raising the minimum wage Pardon me if I overlooked the anti-minimum-wage camp yelling "lower taxes on the working poor!"
- dragonwriter 11y ago> "top 40%" is rather silly bucket. That includes basically the median family No, top 40% does not include "basically the median", by any remotely reasonable standard.
- gnaritas 11y agoThat's why he said basically, it's pretty much the upper half which yes, includes middle class families and billionaires and is a silly bucket to put in one group.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Be careful what you wish for: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/how.. http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2015/03/how.... tl;dr if you raise the minimum wage imperceptibly, poverty reduction is affected imperceptibly and prices are affected imperceptibly. In general if something will have a negative effect on corporate profits (minimum wage hikes have an outsized effect on corporate profits) you will be able to find a legion of economists who will lie to you about what it really does.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoThe reason many economists are unsure or against the minimum wage is not because they're some agents of bourgeoisie capitalists, but because arguments in favor of it tend to be moral, not economic. For instance, here's a case for the minimum wage presented by an (otherwise very knowledgeable, I'll grant) Post-Keynesian economist: http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-easiest-argument-for-minimum-wage.html http://socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-e... It's pretty weak. The first two are very flimsy normative/moral arguments that, even if true, do not at all imply minimum wage is the solution over say, basic income, unionization, community-based mutual credit or a variety of other initiatives. The third one is a can opener assumption. "Oh, minimum wage might work, but only in the case of Post-Keynesian full employment with buffer stocks of labor." You might as well speak of spherical cows in a vacuum. Followed by an unsourced claim about post-WWII prosperity being strictly due to Keynesian policies, when there's no consensus what factors exactly caused it.
- crdoconnor 11y agoI'm not at all concerned about economists who are "for" or "against" the minimum wage. They can hold whatever opinions they want if they don't lie. It's the economists who poorly design studies with the intent of demonstrating that it either causes prices to rise uncontrollably (which it doesn't), causes unemployment to rise (which it also doesn't) and who pointedly never, ever, ever look at the effect it has on profits (it is savage towards profits, which is why the marketing budgets for stuff like this gets approved: http://kron4.com/2014/07/18/new-sf-billboard-says-workers-will-be-replaced-by-tech-if-15-minimum-wage-is-approved/ http://kron4.com/2014/07/18/new-sf-billboard-says-workers-wi...). They all know where the money is in their profession: it's at ideological corporate think tanks. If you can tread the fine line between not lying and saying things which they really like you've got a good career ahead of you. As it happens, 'moral' arguments that say that you shouldn't raise the minimum wage work better when you can claim that it will hurt the people it is designed to help. Those arguments fall flat on their face when it becomes apparent that raising the minimum wage just transfers profits into workers' pockets directly.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> changing corporate taxes so it behooves companies to pay employees more "Corporate" is perhaps too restrictive, but shifting the relative tax burden from labor to capital, without changing the overall share of the economy represented by taxes or government spending, would probably be pretty powerful here. There are, to say the least, political difficulties involved.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- branchless 11y agoSo kill the asset bubble and give the next generation more disposable income...
- laotzu 11y agoI question the assumption that "job creation" is the necessary prerequisite for money creation especially in an age of automative ephemeralization and surplus. Large demand for money already exists among the poor whether or not they have a job. >In technology's "invisible" world, inventors continually increase the quantity and quality of performed work per each volume or pound of material, erg of energy, and unit of worker and "overhead" time invested in each given increment of attained functional performance. This complex process we call progressive ephemeralization. In 1970, the sum total of increases in overall technological know-how and their comprehensive integration took humanity across the epochal but invisible threshold into a state of technically realizable and economically feasible universal success for all humanity. -Buckminster Fuller
- brc 11y agoConsumer demand is meaningless. Trying to push it is like trying to push a string. Demand is an artefact of production. Unless your economy is producing, you won't increase quality of life and wealth for all citizens. This point is obvious, but gets completely lost in all the frenzy around 'stimulating demand'. To buy something, first you have to produce something worthy of exchange. Everyone has to start from this point.
- redler 11y agoSupply and demand are entwined in a perpetual dance, and "if you build it they will come" only goes so far. A product has to find a market capable of making the purchase. Opening a Whole Foods supermarket in rural Tanzania isn't going to boost sales of Tom's of Maine Wicked Cool Toothpaste -- a product apparently worthy of exchange among sufficiently wealthy consumers in a different context.
- brc 11y agoMalinvestment in incorrect production is part of the process. The person who produces unwanted goods and services must gain the feedback that they have, so they can switch production to what is desired. This is a very important reason why crony capitalism, protectionism and secession regulation hurts everyone. I have never stated that 'if you build it they will come', because that is patently false. This is a common straw man erected by the true 'aggregate demand is all' believer (I don't know if this is your position or not). If you build it, they will come is as absurd as 'if we just gave everyone a bit more money, the economy would grow'.
- millstone 11y agoYou're arguing that a glut is due to producing what is not desired, instead of what is desired. So when there is a glut in one area, there must be corresponding shortages in other areas. This is easy to debunk. Look at the labor market. The US unemployment rate went from ~4.5% in 2007 to 10% in 2010: a big labor glut. The "malinvestment" theory predicts unfulfilled demand comparable in size to the unemployment. Large sectors of the economy should have had millions of unfilled job listings, spiraling wages, etc. But this did not happen. The right explanation is simply that total labor supply exceeded demand.
- washedup 11y agoCheap debt has been one "solution", but this can only work temporarily.
- rodgerd 11y ago> It is not clear to me that anyone is doing anything about that (except, of course, in the negative sense.) Precisely - monetary policy in the English-speaking world has, since the 80s, been focused on avoiding inflationary pressures via avoiding "too much" growth. Anything that would lead to upward income pressure outside the executive suite is "too much".
- lintiness 11y agogood lord. read some history. if you're not afraid of inflation, you haven't lived long enough.
- cheald 11y agoIncome equality has jack-all to do with absolute income levels. The richest getting richer at a pace greater than others doesn't mean that others aren't making money. Real income is up for all quintiles since the 1970s, as are consumption expenditures. Real income is up quite a lot more for the upper quintiles, but since we don't operate in a zero-sum economy, that doesn't require that it be down for other people.