5 ms·
Its nonsensical to think a human can take over at a moment's notice during a particular maneuver. Its the threat of death/accident that makes me pay attention t
by donpdonp 11y ago
Its nonsensical to think a human can take over at a moment's notice during a particular maneuver. Its the threat of death/accident that makes me pay attention to every moment of driving. On autopilot I wont have that kind of attention. Its simply a trait of the human attention span.
That being said, every self-driving car needs a manual override because there are plenty of situations that cant be easily explained to a computer. the override could be done with a steering wheel and gas pedal, or just a joy-stick mode on the touchscreen pad.
For instance someone has a big empty lot and they want to move a car from row A to row B. The new spot is exactly 50 feet to the right. I just want to back the car up, and go forward while steering over to the right a bit. Row B has no 'street address' to program into a route-computer. I could click on a map but the map doesnt know where on the grass i want to drive.
Even with lidar, etc. there are grey areas that self-driving algorithms are going to have trouble with. Drop a sheet of tissue in the path of a self-driving car moving at 60MPH. The lidar will see it as a solid object and might decide a very dangerous plan - maximum braking - is the best plan, when going through it is actually the best plan.
- not_that_noob 11y agoThis already happens today with cruise control - and yes, the driver will have to be paying attention while driving, at least in this version of the rules.
- mindslight 11y agoCruise control still requires one to mostly drive, and the only "moment's notice" thing a human would do with cruise control would be stomp the brake. Regardless of what any rule says, stand-by humans will not be paying attention and ready to drive. Even if reading/sleeping/daydreaming were successfully policed, the human will still be out of touch with how the car responds to controls. Think of the first time you drive after not having driven for a few months - now imagine being already moving at highway speed.
- mmanfrin 11y agoAll cruise control does is set the speed, it is not analogous to self-driving.
- jeffdavis 11y agoYou assume it's for safety, but it's more likely to be a case that the car can't handle at all and simply stops. For instance, if there's some kind of minor obstruction, a human may decide to drive over it or go into the oncoming lane or get out and pick it up or follow an officer's instructions.