3 ms·
I would call it satire, i.e. putting a humourous spin on a serious subject. But I will respond to your post in a serious manner nonetheless. Your second senten
by tremon 11y ago
I would call it satire, i.e. putting a humourous spin on a serious subject. But I will respond to your post in a serious manner nonetheless.
Your second sentence perfectly illustrates the point the article is trying to make, that "the increasing moralisation of mundane choices is strongly associated with the phenomenology of interminable inescapable guilt". As the article argues, when we overload our moral judgements by making every single act a moral deliberation, one measurable effect will be an overall lessening of our moral convictions.
Yes, you only vote a few times every odd years. No, your tax dollars are not "channeled in a particular direction". Yes, business interests are still fundamentally at odds with environmental concerns. No, the few pennies you spend on products of a particular business do not affect the business' behaviour. The amount of moral deliberation that is reasonable to "demand" for such a simple act should be proportional to the ratio of your expenditure versus the entire business size.
> And yes ethical consumption is complicated. A good starting point is to assume everything is tainted unless you know otherwise
I don't think this is a useful starting point. If you start by assuming everything is tainted, you are already making a moral judgement about every purchase. Judgements and decisions cost mental energy, and we already know that mental energy is not infinite.
> That is, dont be pit off from trying to do one thing right just because you can't do everything right.
But that is exactly what's happening subconciously anyway: if we perceive (some of) our morals to be untenable (because of unrealistic demands, no way to actually make an impact, or general information/decision overload), that causes us to weaken all of our morals, even the ones we can affect.
Pick your battles, is what I'd take from this. And when evangelizing a cause, make sure the burden you're placing on others is realistic.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- codeulike 11y agoI'm not talking about tax dollars. I'm talking about peoples personal spending decisions. No, the few pennies you spend on products of a particular business do not affect the business' behaviour. Thats patently false. Its a small effect obviously, but its an effect. You could argue that recyling household waste is pointless from the same logic (and people do, I know)
- tremon 11y agoWell, patently false... I think individual actions are negligible. In order to have an effect, you need a concerted effort from many people. I realise there's a chicken-and-egg problem here, because such efforts start with individual actions and need to gain critical mass from there. I did not mean to say that such causes are futile. However, care should be taken that moral appeals are targeted and realistic, or they risk defeating both themself and other appeals.
- ggchappell 11y ago> I would call it satire, i.e. putting a humourous spin on a serious subject. Ah, right. That's what it's called. Thanks for reminding us all about a sadly underused word.
- tremon 11y agoMy sarcasm detector is hitting red here, but I'm glad to be of help :)
- ggchappell 11y agoNope, not sarcasm. I couldn't figure out what to call it. Then you reminded me. Thanks. Really. :-) EDIT. We need a standard symbol for "I'm not being sarcastic". (Of course, then people may start using it sarcastically.)