3 ms·
> tl;dr:I believe that the field of data vis would benefit from a clear line between art and design. I believe that we need that boundary to judge both forms ac
by dahart 11y ago
> tl;dr:I believe that the field of data vis would benefit from a clear line between art and design. I believe that we need that boundary to judge both forms according to different criteria and therefore more fairly.
Personally, I consider most data art to be pretty bad art, and furthermore if it doesn't function as a decent data vis, then it is usually also meaningless as art. There's far too much of images being made intentionally confusing to convey the idea that the data is complex, rather than working to simplify. The "art" examples in the article fall into this category, IMO.
Of course, this depends on the image we're talking about, and it depends on what the artist or scientist was trying to achieve, but my own gut reaction is that trying to separate vis from art more carefully isn't something I think would help a lot.
"Design" is the name for the middle ground between form and function, and a good design for a data-vis-art image, or anything else, is usually defined as something that scores highly for both form and function. Personally, I would like to see both data art and data vis evaluated on a design scale by default, unless there are good reasons not to. Good data vis should be aesthetic, and good data art should be meaningful.